
Initiate at Sell with a $22 target as peak card profits meet a rich multiple
| Jan/Feb YE, $m | FY24A | FY25A | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net sales | 3,823.0 | 3,629.9 | 3,364.5 | 2,953.4 | 2,722.1 |
| Growth y/y | −27.5% | −5.1% | −7.3% | −12.2% | −7.8% |
| EBITDA pre-imp. | 22.4 | 300.5 | 627.4 | 543.3 | 440.5 |
| Margin | 0.6% | 8.3% | 18.6% | 18.4% | 16.2% |
| GAAP net income | 131.3 | 418.4 | 998.8 | 542.8 | 473.7 |
| EPS, GAAP/adj. ($) | 0.33 | 0.77 | 1.10 | 0.90 | 0.84 |
| Growth y/y | n.m. | +133.3% | +43.0% | −17.9% | −6.8% |
| Free cash flow | 129.6 | 597.3 | 640.5 | 586.9 | 513.2 |
| At $25.36 close | FY24A | FY25A | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P/E (GAAP/adj.) | 76.8x | 32.9x | 23.0x | 28.1x | 30.1x |
| Retail EV/EBITDA | n.m. | 19.6x | 9.4x | 10.8x | 13.3x |
| P/B | 2.60x | 2.35x | 1.71x | 1.59x | 1.50x |
| FCF yield | 1.0% | 4.7% | 5.0% | 4.6% | 4.0% |
| Dividend yield | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% |
| ROE (GAAP/adj.) | 4.2% | 8.1% | 10.2% | 7.0% | 5.7% |
| Net debt/EBITDA | n.m. | −16.1x | −3.4x | −5.0x | −7.4x |
| P/E at our target | 66.4x | 28.4x | 19.9x | 24.2x | 26.0x |
Source: Company filings (A); Penmark Research model (E). FY24A–25A EPS/ROE are GAAP (FY25A incl. $131.6m bitcoin loss); n.m. = not meaningful.
We initiate on GameStop Corp. at Sell (low conviction) with a $21.90 target and −13.6% total return from $25.36. GameStop sells collectibles, games and pre-owned gear in about 1,900 US and Australian stores, backed by $6.9bn of net cash, eBay stock and bitcoin. Collectibles (trading cards, graded cards and pop-culture goods) rose 61% in H1 FY26, yet the price assumes peak profits last.
- Trading-card sales cool 12% in FY27E as physical games shrink. Pokémon chase cards fell 60%–75% in 30 days and digital launches erode trade-ins. Valuing mid-cycle EBITDA ($489m) instead of peak FY26E ($627m) at 7.3x cuts $1.99 a share.
- Shrinking specialty retail warrants about 7x mid-cycle EBITDA, not 12x. Paying 7.3x instead of the price-implied 9.4x on FY26E earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) cuts $2.62 a share ($4.60 combined with normalization).
- Cash, eBay and bitcoin less the notes are worth about $14 a share, but risks skew down. Net non-operating assets equal $13.72 a share. Weighting our bear case at 30% and bull at 20% takes $0.71 off our $20.76 base value.
What the market is missing. Our $0.90 FY27E adjusted diluted earnings per share (EPS) sits 11% below $1.02 consensus, while $25.36 implies +35% FY27E card growth. Our $1.10 FY26E adjusted EPS is 1% above consensus; generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) EPS of $1.68 includes eBay gains.
Catalysts. Expected December 2026 Q3 results test +12% H2 card growth; March 2027 Q4 results frame FY27. Choices on the 43.4m-share eBay stake (worth $5.1bn, cost $4.4bn) and $2.0bn buyback follow.
Valuation and target. Sum-of-the-parts (SOTP) sets retail enterprise value (EV) at $3.6bn (7.3x mid-cycle EBITDA) plus $6.9bn of net non-operating assets for $20.76 base value ($19.48 discounted cash flow). Weighting bull 20%, base 50% and bear 30% gives $20.05, rolled at 9.2% to target.
Risks. The card boom (+$3.15 a share) or a case for the 8.8x all-peer multiple would each move us to Hold; an eBay sale near $125 adds $0.42.
Downside to our bear case is more than twice the upside to our bull case
Source: Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research model (spot values rolled 12m at 9.24% cost of equity).
Spot $27.13. Collectibles +25% H2 FY26E, +20% FY27E; collectibles gross margin +2pp; eBay at $125 offer.
Spot $20.76. Collectibles +12% H2 FY26E, −12% FY27E; pre-owned −13%/yr; 7.26x EBITDA.
Spot $14.15. Collectibles −30% FY27E; collectibles gross margin −3pp; eBay −15%; 10% deal haircut.
| Income, $m | FY24A | FY25A | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net sales | 3,823.0 | 3,629.9 | 3,364.5 | 2,953.4 | 2,722.1 |
| Gross profit | 1,113.9 | 1,196.1 | 1,360.9 | 1,223.8 | 1,131.5 |
| EBITDA | 22.4 | 300.5 | 627.4 | 543.3 | 440.5 |
| EBIT (GAAP) | −26.2 | 232.1 | 616.4 | 525.8 | 424.0 |
| Net fin. & inv. | 163.4 | 151.9 | 724.2 | 198.0 | 207.6 |
| Income tax | −5.9 | 34.4 | −341.8 | −180.9 | −157.9 |
| Net inc., GAAP/adj. | 131.3 | 418.4 | 656.0 | 542.8 | 473.7 |
| Net inc., GAAP | 131.3 | 418.4 | 998.8 | 542.8 | 473.7 |
| Cash flow, $m | FY24A | FY25A | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EBITDA | 22.4 | 300.5 | 627.4 | 543.3 | 440.5 |
| WC & non-cash | −34.2 | 8.4 | 107.9 | 41.3 | 36.6 |
| Int. & tax CF | 157.5 | 305.9 | −79.9 | 17.0 | 49.7 |
| Oper. CF | 145.7 | 614.8 | 655.4 | 601.6 | 526.8 |
| Capex | −16.1 | −17.5 | −14.9 | −14.8 | −13.6 |
| Free cash flow | 129.6 | 597.3 | 640.5 | 586.9 | 513.2 |
| eBay / bitcoin | 0.0 | −501.2 | −4,343.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
| Equity & notes | 3,451.5 | 4,146.2 | −358.3 | 0.0 | −2,800.0 |
| Bal. sheet, $m | FY24A | FY25A | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash & sec. | 4,774.9 | 9,013.8 | 4,948.8 | 5,535.6 | 3,248.8 |
| eBay & bitcoin | 0.0 | 368.4 | 5,241.0 | 5,241.0 | 5,241.0 |
| Inv. & rec. | 545.2 | 448.3 | 399.9 | 346.2 | 318.5 |
| Other assets | 555.3 | 557.9 | 305.9 | 299.0 | 293.8 |
| Total assets | 5,875.4 | 10,388.4 | 10,895.5 | 11,421.8 | 9,102.1 |
| Total debt | 16.9 | 4,164.3 | 2,800.0 | 2,800.0 | 0.0 |
| Net cash | 4,758.0 | 4,849.5 | 2,148.8 | 2,735.6 | 3,248.8 |
| Total equity | 4,929.8 | 5,444.4 | 7,477.3 | 8,052.1 | 8,558.7 |
| Per sh & KPIs | FY24A | FY25A | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Diluted sh (m) | 394.7 | 549.1 | 595.8 | 600.4 | 562.5 |
| EPS, GAAP/adj. | 0.33 | 0.77 | 1.10 | 0.90 | 0.84 |
| EPS, GAAP ($) | 0.33 | 0.77 | 1.68 | 0.90 | 0.84 |
| FCF / sh ($) | 0.33 | 1.09 | 1.07 | 0.98 | 0.91 |
| BV / sh ($) | 11.03 | 12.14 | 14.82 | 15.96 | 16.96 |
| Collectibles ($m) | 717.9 | 1,060.2 | 1,400.8 | 1,232.7 | 1,171.1 |
| Collectibles (%) | 18.8% | 29.2% | 41.6% | 41.7% | 43.0% |
| Ending stores | 3,203 | 2,206 | 1,879 | 1,841 | 1,805 |
Source: Company filings (A); Penmark Research model (E). FY24A–25A net income/EPS are GAAP; Ex 5 FY24A equity/notes is share sales; Ex 6 FY24A debt is French term debt and FY26E+ stores are US/Australia.
EBITDA margin peaks near 19% in FY26E, and our FY27E EPS is 11% below consensus
| Growth / mgn | FY24A | FY25A | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Growth y/y | |||||
| Net sales | −27.5% | −5.1% | −7.3% | −12.2% | −7.8% |
| EBITDA | −15.5% | +1,242% | +108.8% | −13.4% | −18.9% |
| EBIT | n.m. | n.m. | +165.6% | −14.7% | −19.4% |
| EPS (GAAP/adj.) | n.m. | +133.3% | +43.0% | −17.9% | −6.8% |
| DPS growth | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% |
| Margins and coverage | |||||
| Gross margin | 29.1% | 33.0% | 40.4% | 41.4% | 41.6% |
| EBITDA margin | 0.6% | 8.3% | 18.6% | 18.4% | 16.2% |
| EBIT margin | −0.7% | 6.4% | 18.3% | 17.8% | 15.6% |
| FCF margin | 3.4% | 16.5% | 19.0% | 19.9% | 18.9% |
| EBITDA / int. | n.m. | n.m. | n.m. | n.m. | n.m. |
| Ratios & mult. | FY24A | FY25A | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Returns and leverage | |||||
| ROE (GAAP/adj.) | 4.2% | 8.1% | 10.2% | 7.0% | 5.7% |
| ROA (GAAP/adj.) | 3.1% | 5.1% | 6.2% | 4.9% | 4.6% |
| ROIC (model) | n.d. | n.d. | 175.9% | 159.2% | 131.8% |
| ND / equity | −96.5% | −89.1% | −28.7% | −34.0% | −38.0% |
| ND / EBITDA | n.m. | −16.1x | −3.4x | −5.0x | −7.4x |
| Valuation at $25.36 | |||||
| P/E (GAAP/adj.) | 76.8x | 32.9x | 23.0x | 28.1x | 30.1x |
| EV / EBITDA | n.m. | 19.6x | 9.4x | 10.8x | 13.3x |
| P/B | 2.60x | 2.35x | 1.71x | 1.59x | 1.50x |
| FCF yield | 1.0% | 4.7% | 5.0% | 4.6% | 4.0% |
| Div. yield | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% |
| P/E at our target | 66.4x | 28.4x | 19.9x | 24.2x | 26.0x |
Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model. FY24A–25A EPS, ROE, ROA and P/E are GAAP (+43.0% FY26E compares adjusted EPS with GAAP); historical ROIC is n.d. (not computed); P/B uses diluted market cap ($12,802m); EBITDA/net interest is n.m. on net interest income.
| $m / $ per share | Q3 FY26E | Q4 FY26E | FY26E | FY27E |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue ($m) | ||||
| Penmark estimate | 741.5 | 997.5 | 3,364.5 | 2,953.4 |
| Consensus | 722.5 | 1,012.0 | 3,360.0 | n.a. |
| Prior-year period | 821.0 | 1,104.3 | 3,629.9 | 3,364.5 |
| Diff. vs consensus | +2.6% | −1.4% | +0.1% | n.a. |
| Growth y/y (Penmark) | −9.7% | −9.7% | −7.3% | −12.2% |
| Adjusted EPS ($) | ||||
| Penmark estimate | 0.22 | 0.30 | 1.10 | 0.90 |
| Consensus | 0.20 | 0.31 | 1.09 | 1.02 |
| Prior-year period | n.a. | n.a. | 0.77 | 1.10 |
| Diff. vs consensus | +10.0% | −3.2% | +1.0% | −11.4% |
| Growth y/y (Penmark) | n.a. | n.a. | +43.0% | −17.9% |
Source: Zacks via Yahoo Finance (6 Nov 2026) for Q3/FY26E; MarketBeat via IBTimes (2 Nov 2026) for FY27E EPS; Penmark estimates. Model-derived Q3/Q4 allocates H2 FY26E on H2 FY25A seasonality; FY25 quarterly adj. EPS is n.a. (not available).
Source: Company filings (A, GAAP); Zacks (FY26E) and MarketBeat via IBTimes (FY27E); Penmark Research (E).
GME trades 65% above low-growth peers on mid-cycle EBITDA despite falling sales
| At 17 Nov 2026 | GME (FY26E) | Peer (FY25) | Diff. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Valuation multiples | |||
| P/E (adj. / all-peer) | 23.0x | 13.8x | +66.7% |
| Retail EV / EBITDA (all-peer) | 9.36x | 8.79x | +6.5% |
| Retail EV / mid-cycle (low-gr.) | 12.01x | 7.26x | +65.4% |
| FCF yield (all-peer) | 5.0% | 5.4% | −0.4pp |
| Dividend yield (all-peer) | 0.0% | 1.4% | −1.4pp |
| Growth, margins and balance sheet | |||
| Sales growth (all-peer) | −7.3% | +9.3% | −16.6pp |
| Sales growth (low-growth) | −7.3% | +0.4% | −7.7pp |
| EBITDA margin (all-peer) | 18.6% | 11.9% | +6.7pp |
| ROE (adj. / all-peer) | 10.2% | 21.5% | −11.3pp |
| Net debt / EBITDA (all-peer) | −3.4x | 0.4x | −3.8x |
| Collectibles share of sales | 41.6% | n.a. | n.a. |
Source: Peer SEC filings; Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research model. GME on FY26E/mid-cycle; peer medians on FY25 across six US peers (BBY, FIVE, DKS, ASO, BBWI, OLLI) or three low-growth peers (BBY, ASO, BBWI).
- Dec 2026Q3 FY26 release (date unconfirmed): tests +12% H2 card growth and $722.5m sales consensus.
- Mar 2027Q4 & FY26 10-K: tests >$650m EBITDA guide ($677.4m est.) and modeled Q4 console/code lift.
- Jun 2027Q1 FY27 print: laps +65.0% Q1 FY26 card jump, testing our −12% FY27E card reset.
- Nov 2027Capital deployment: 43.4m-share eBay stake monetization vs $2.0bn buyback execution.
Source: Company filings; Penmark Research calendar.
- Card cool-down. FY27E collectibles drop 30% vs −12% base. Likelihood High (55%); −$1.79/sh.
- Stock-funded eBay bid. Dilutive deal haircut on non-operating capital. Likelihood Med (25%); −$1.91/sh.
- eBay premium unwinds. eBay falls 15% from takeover-lifted levels. Likelihood Med (30%); −$1.17/sh.
- Upside: card boom extends. Collectibles grow +20% in FY27E. Likelihood Med (20%); +$3.15/sh.
Source: Company SEC filing-date equity; Yahoo Finance closes. Price-to-book (P/B); SD = standard deviation.
Source: Peer SEC filings; Yahoo Finance (JB Hi-Fi, Fnac, Currys); Penmark Research model (DKS M&A excluded from fit).
Six charts show why we value GME about $5 a share below the price
GameStop’s operating profit jumped on trading cards and store closures, yet quarter-end share prices barely tracked collectibles growth (r = 0.04). Stripping $6.9bn of net non-operating assets shows the market pays $5.9bn (12.0x mid-cycle EBITDA) for a shrinking retail business we value at $3.6bn.
Source: Company 10-Q and 10-K filings; Yahoo Finance closes.
Source: Penmark Research model.
Source: Company 10-K filings (A, global); Penmark Research model (E, US and Australia from FY26E).
Source: Penmark Research model.
Source: Company Q2 FY26 10-Q; Penmark Research model (17 Nov 2026 marks).
Source: Penmark Research model.
Three debates explain the $5 gap between the price and our value
Non-operating cash, bitcoin and eBay shares are worth $13.72 a share at market prices, net of the notes. Every dollar of disagreement between the share price and our valuation comes down to three questions on trading-card normalization, peer multiple selection and scenario skew.
| Debate | Market view | Penmark view | Evidence | What changes our view | Resolves |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Card normalization ($1.99/sh gap) |
Peak FY26E EBITDA ($627m) lasts; separately, $25.36 implies +35% FY27E card growth. | Collectibles cool to +12% in H2 FY26E and −12% in FY27E; valuing mid-cycle ($489m) vs peak at 7.3x cuts $1.99. | Secondary Pokémon chase-card prices dropped sharply in late 2026 while modern sealed sits 15%–25% off its 2025 peak. | +20% FY27E collectibles growth adds $3.15 a share and would move us to Hold despite tough H1 FY26 (+61%) comparisons. | Mar 2027 |
| Retail multiple ($2.62/sh gap) |
Retail operations deserve 9.4x FY26E (12.0x mid-cycle) EBITDA plus deal optionality. | Shrinking sales warrant our 7.3x low-growth peer median; paying 7.3x vs 9.4x on FY26E EBITDA cuts $2.62. | Low-growth US peers (BBY, ASO, BBWI) trade at 4.7x–8.9x; May 2026 eBay bid coincided with a −10.1% one-day stock drop. | Accretive eBay monetization near $125 or evidence supporting a target multiple above about 8x mid-cycle EBITDA. | Nov 2027 |
| Scenario skew ($0.71/sh gap) |
Prices base/bull upside with minimal discount for M&A or eBay mark-to-market risk. | Our 30% bear ($14.15) vs 20% bull ($27.13) weighting trims $0.71 from our base value. | The large eBay holding plus 2.5bn authorized shares leave material mark-to-market and deal-dilution risk. | Board retires excess share authorization or commits excess cash to par note redemptions. | Dec 2026 |
Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model.
Source: Penmark Research model (each implied figure holds other base inputs fixed).
Card normalization drives our first thesis pillar: falling card prices and digital-only games pull FY27E EPS to $0.90 vs $1.02 consensus.
Retail multiple anchors our second pillar: shrinking specialty retail warrants 7.3x mid-cycle EBITDA, not 12.0x.
Scenario skew underpins our third pillar: net non-operating assets cushion downside while deal and mark risks skew weights.
Source: Company 10-K Note 13 and Q2 FY26 10-Q Note 15; Penmark Research calendar.
A video-game chain now gets 45% of sales from collectibles and holds about $10bn of cash, eBay stock and bitcoin
GameStop runs about 1,900 neighborhood strip-center shops in the US and Australia that buy and resell games, consoles and graded trading cards. Yet two-thirds of what the company is worth sits outside its stores in cash, bitcoin and a 43.4m-share stake in eBay.
The scene
Walk into one of GameStop’s 1,598 US strip-center shops today and a collector is handing plastic-slabbed Pokémon cards across the counter for instant cash or grading intake. Ten years ago that counter stacked PlayStation 4 discs and generated $8.6bn of annual sales. Digital downloads hollowed out physical software and pushed operating losses past $368m in fiscal 2021. Instead of vanishing, GameStop closed unprofitable leases, turned remaining counters into card and console trade-in hubs, and raised billions in equity and zero-coupon debt.
What it actually does
GameStop runs two businesses under one roof. One is a specialty retailer across about 1,900 stores in the US and Australia under the GameStop and EB Games banners after exiting Canada and Europe. The other is an investment pool overseen by Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Ryan Cohen’s board committee, holding $4.7bn of cash after September’s note exchange, 4,710 bitcoin and a 43.4m-share eBay stake.
How the money comes in
Customers pay upfront at the register or online across three streams with wide margin gaps. Collectibles and grading services reached 45% of Q2 FY26 sales, ahead of new video games at 33% and pre-owned gear at 22%. New consoles and games carry estimated gross margins of 20% to 25%, whereas trade-ins and cards leave roughly 45% to 54% gross margin. In fiscal 2026 each dollar of sales leaves 40 cents of gross profit, 18 cents of operating profit and 19 cents of group free cash flow, including cash interest.
Where the story turns
Mr. Cohen became Chairman in June 2021 and CEO in September 2023. Management shut 727 US shops in fiscal 2025 and scaled Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) grading, lifting Q2 operating profit to a record $160m. In 2026 GameStop bought its eBay stake (worth $5.1bn in a ~$52bn company), sent a non-binding $125 bid in May, and retired $1.4bn of notes in September.
Why it works, and why it might not
Local counters verify used consoles and graded cards on the spot without shipping risk. Falling Pokémon chase-card prices and digital-only games test that loop across our Card normalization, Retail multiple and Scenario skew debates.
Source: FY25 Form 10-K (2,206 total stores incl. exited Europe; 1,898 US & Australia), Q2 FY26 Form 10-Q, and Penmark Research model.
Collectibles make up 42% of FY26E sales and over half of gross profit across about 1,900 shops
Source: FY25 Form 10-K, Q2 FY26 Form 10-Q, 2026 DEF 14A, 4 May 2026 Form 8-K, and Penmark Research model.
1 · Customers
2 · Offerings
3 · Revenue ($3,364m)
4 · Channels
5 · Cost to serve
6 · What is left
Source: FY25 Form 10-K, Q2 FY26 Form 10-Q, and Penmark Research model. Category gross margins (games: 25% H1, 20% H2 = 22.2% blended) are model estimates; SG&A combines H1 actuals and H2 model.
What it sells, and why customers buy
Immediate cash payouts and in-person grading intake bring traffic to strip-center counters. Customers sell used consoles, controllers and PSA-graded cards across the counter for cash or credit, which GameStop refurbishes and resells alongside sealed trading cards and new hardware.
How it is priced and paid for
Sales settle upfront per unit across about 1,900 US and Australian stores. Roughly 30% of FY25 sales fell in the fourth-quarter holiday window, while gift cards and trade-in credits create $244.9m of interest-free customer liabilities.
Each dollar of FY26E sales leaves 40 cents of gross profit, 18 cents of EBIT and 19 cents of group FCF (incl. interest)
Source: Penmark Research model (FY26E, before $6.9m impairment benefit; SG&A split combines H1 actuals and H2 model).
Merchandise cost is variable, while store labor and rent act as semi-fixed costs per shop. FY26E SG&A of $751m combines $564m of US and Australian store costs ($271.5m H1 actual plus $292.7m H2 model), $136m of corporate and other costs, and $51m of exited H1 European SG&A. Closing 727 US stores cut H1 FY26 SG&A by 13% to $389m, while capex stays near 0.4% of sales.
Source: Company Q2 FY26 Form 10-Q; Penmark Research model. Shaded blue nodes denote key modeled operating drivers.
Source: Q2 FY26 Form 10-Q (42.2% reported H1 group GM); category gross margins are calibrated Penmark model estimates.
Source: Company Q2 FY26 Form 10-Q, Note 8 (Europe exited by Q3 FY26; Q2 EBIT: US $153.2m, Aus $8.1m, Europe −$1.1m).
Content is 86% of $61bn of US game spending; GameStop’s growth now comes from collectibles
Source: Entertainment Software Association / Circana 2025 US consumer spending ($60.8bn total; $52.4bn content, $5.4bn hardware, $2.9bn accessories).
| Trading-card & grading indicator | Reading | Period / note |
|---|---|---|
| Pokémon 30th chase cards | −60% to −75% | 30 days to Nov 2026 |
| Modern sealed TCG product | −15% to −25% | Below 2025 peak |
| PSA share of major grading | ~65% | Aug 2026 (~71% Collectors) |
| October 2026 cards graded | 3.87m cards | +20% vs Sep record (GemRate) |
| PSA weekly output & Value tier | +~50% YTD | ~90k/day; reopened 29 Oct |
| GME–PSA FY25 volume | $39.8m | Incl. $18.3m Power Packs |
Source: Penmark Research model; CNBC / GemRate; PSA updates (backlog eased 12.4m Jul to 7.2m Oct on capacity); 2026 DEF 14A.
Demand drivers and cycle position
Console hardware moves in multi-year waves, while trading cards track collector pricing and set releases. US game spending totaled $61bn in 2025, led by $52bn of content where digital stores take most downloads. In cards, Pokémon chase prices dropped sharply in late 2026 and modern sealed sits 15%–25% off its 2025 peak. Meanwhile, PSA lifted weekly grading output nearly 50% this year and reopened its Value tier on 29 October.
Concentration and vendor power
Three suppliers dominate upstream intellectual property. Nintendo, Sony and Pokémon accounted for a majority of GameStop’s FY25 new-product purchases, while Collectors-owned brands handle about 71% of major card grading.
Who earns the margin
Platform owners keep digital software margins above 70%, leaving estimated 20%–25% spreads on new hardware at retail. Physical shops earn wide spreads by inspecting and reselling used consoles and graded slabs at estimated 45%–54% gross margins.
Substitution threats
Games sold without a disc shrink both new retail sales and future trade-in supply. H1 FY26 video-game revenue fell 34.9% on lapping the Switch 2 launch, H1 FY25’s inclusion of France, and digital-only releases; our model assumes pre-owned sales fall 13% annually in FY27E–29E.
Source: FY25 Form 10-K, 2026 DEF 14A, CNBC / GemRate, and Penmark Research calibrated category margins.
Source: Company filings, PSA updates, and Penmark Research model assumptions (card normalization, code-in-box and disc-end assumptions).
GameStop leads on walk-in trade-ins and PSA card intake, but only two of seven moat sources are strong
Source: Peer SEC filings; Penmark Research model (FY26E GME vs FY25 peers).
| Source | Strength | Evidence from filings and industry data |
|---|---|---|
| Scale & density | Strong | 1,598 US and 300 Aus shops (~1,900 total) anchor trade-ins and refurb centers. |
| Partnerships | Strong | PSA intake generated $39.8m in FY25 (incl. $18.3m Power Packs); Nat Turner on board. |
| Cost position | Moderate | Small strip-center boxes keep SG&A at 22.3% of FY26E sales after 727 US closures. |
| Brand | Moderate | GameStop & EB Games lead physical resale awareness; weak in digital downloads. |
| Network effects | Moderate | Local trade-ins feed refurbished inventory, but online marketplaces outscale selection. |
| Switching costs | Weak | Pro loyalty points phased out Jul 2026; buyers shop price across Walmart/eBay. |
| Proprietary IP | None | Relies on Nintendo, Sony and Pokémon for majority of new-product supply. |
Source: FY25 Form 10-K, Q2 FY26 Form 10-Q, 2026 DEF 14A; Penmark Research.
Source: FY25 Form 10-K competition disclosures; Penmark Research competitive assessment.
Where the advantage holds, and where it erodes
No national chain matches GameStop’s roughly 1,900 US and Australian counters for instant payouts on used consoles and PSA-graded cards. Collectibles revenue rose 61% in H1 FY26 to $705m as collectors used walk-in grading intake. By contrast, H1 FY26 video-game sales fell 35% on lapping the Switch 2 launch, H1 FY25’s inclusion of France, and digital-only releases on console stores.
Competitors by segment
Mass merchants (Walmart, Target, Best Buy, Amazon, JB Hi-Fi) compete on new hardware allocations, while eBay (including TCGplayer) and local hobby shops lead in rare card selection.
Ryan Cohen takes no salary, bought $97m of stock in September and October and controls how the cash is used
| Executive / role | Tenure | How they are paid (FY25 proxy) | What they own ($25.36 close) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ryan CohenPresident, CEO & Chairman | 3.1 yrs as CEOChair since Jun 2021; CEO since Sep 2023; director since Jan 2021. Prior: founder & CEO, Chewy. | $1.76m total, FY25 $0 salary, $0 bonus, $0 FY25 equity; 100% security program cost. Proposed $2.5bn option grant withdrawn Jul 2026. |
$1,077.5m post-Oct 8.4%42.08m sh on 20 May 2026 (38.35m common + 3.73m $32 warrants expired 30 Oct); +4.14m sh bought Sep–Oct ($97.1m → 42.49m sh). |
| Daniel MoorePrincipal Financial & Accounting Officer | 3.3 yrs in rolePAO since Aug 2023; PFO since Mar 2024; 5.3 yrs at GME. Prior: VP Tax, Elevate Textiles. | $2.37m total, FY25 $0.20m salary, $0.08m special bonus, $2.09m time RSUs. Metric: $50m US operating profit unlocks $0.50m RSU grant. |
$3.59m proxy <0.1%141,528 sh on 20 May 2026 (incl. 18,237 unvested RSUs; 18.0x base salary). Oct 2026: sold 22,777 sh ($0.60m). |
| Mark RobinsonGeneral Counsel & Secretary | 4.8 yrs in roleGC since Jan 2022 (ex-GM Jun–Sep 2023); 11.3 yrs at GME. Prior: Norton Rose Fulbright. | $2.61m total, FY25 $0.20m salary, $0 cash bonus, $2.41m time RSUs. Metric: $50m US operating profit unlocks $0.50m RSU grant. |
$3.41m proxy <0.1%134,434 sh on 20 May 2026 (incl. 18,237 unvested RSUs; 17.0x base salary). Oct 2026: sold 11,178 sh ($0.28m). |
| Nathaniel TurnerNon-Independent Director (PSA Partner) | 2.0 yrs on BoardDirector since 2024. Concurrent Chair & CEO of Collectors Holdings (PSA); Flatiron co-founder. | $0.00m total, FY25Board ended all non-employee director cash and equity pay in 2024. Owns up to 10% of PSA ($39.8m FY25 GME volume). | $0.27m post-proxy <0.1%0 sh on 20 May 2026 proxy; salary multiple n.d. Bought 10,462 sh for $0.25m ($24.33/sh) in open market on 1 Oct 2026. |
Source: FY25 DEF 14A (ownership as of 20 May 2026; filed 22 May 2026; 448.7m record-date shares; post-exchange % on 504.8m diluted shares); SEC Form 4 filings to Nov 2026; valued at $25.36. n.d. = not disclosed.
Source: SEC Form 4 filings, Sep–Oct 2026.
Source: Penmark Research model (17 Nov 2026).
Does pay reward per-share value?
Executive pay aligns managers with the share price, without per-share dilution caps. Mr. Cohen takes no salary, bonus or time-vested stock, tying his wealth directly to his 42.5m direct shares. Other officers receive $200k base salaries and about 90% of pay in restricted stock units (RSUs), plus an annual $500k RSU grant above $50m of adjusted US operating profit. In January 2026, the Board proposed granting Mr. Cohen 171.5m options ($20.66 strike, $2.5bn fair value) tied to $20bn–$100bn market-cap and $2bn–$10bn EBITDA hurdles. The Board withdrew that plan at the 7 July 2026 annual general meeting (AGM).
Governance, pledging and related parties
Three of five directors are independent, while investment authority sits with Mr. Cohen. Lead Independent Director Alan Attal, Larry Cheng and Jim Grube are independent; Mr. Cohen is executive Chair and Nat Turner is non-independent due to his Collectors/PSA role. PSA grading and Power Packs generated $39.8m in FY25 (including $18.3m from Power Packs) under Audit Committee review. On 20 May 2026, 38.35m of Mr. Cohen’s shares and 0.60m of Mr. Attal’s shares sat in Schwab margin accounts with a 50% loan-to-value (LTV) cap.
Share and note sales built a $9.9bn cash pool; $4.3bn went into eBay and none into buybacks
Source: Company 10-K filings (A); Penmark Research model (E, notes repaid at par in FY28E; accounting if-converted count shown).
Source: Company 8-K (26 Jun and 8 Sep 2026); Zacks consensus; Penmark Research model.
Guidance record and disclosure
Management resumed annual EBITDA guidance in June 2026 and raised it 11 weeks later. GameStop holds no earnings calls; it set an FY26 adjusted EBITDA floor above $600m on 26 June 2026 and raised it above $650m on 8 September 2026 after H1 FY26 hit $339.7m.
| Capital use (FY25A–Nov 2026) | Cash / cost | 17 Nov 2026 value | Return / yield vs 9.24% CoE | Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 43.4m-share eBay stake (May $125 non-binding bid) | $4,386.3m cost | $4,963.4m after tax | +17.3% pre-tax (+13.2% net) | Accretive to date |
| Treasury bitcoin purchase (4,710 BTC bought in FY25) | $500.0m cost | $306.2m spot | −38.8% cumulative mark | Value destructive |
| Convertible note exchange (retired ~$1.4bn par on 3 Sep 2026) | $358.4m + stock | $2,800.0m par left | Cut 2028 note puts by 33% | De-risked debt |
| Cash & marketable securities ($2.0bn buyback unused) | $4,701.9m held | $4,701.9m book | ~3.8% pre-tax yield (<9.24% CoE) | Return drag |
| Store maintenance capex (~1,900 US/AU stores, FY26E ROIC 175.9%) | $23.7m over 18 months | Core fleet | 175.9% model retail ROIC | Disciplined |
Source: Company 10-K/10-Q and 8-K filings (FY25 OCF $614.8m + H1 FY26 OCF ~$400m = $1,015m; eBay cash outflow $4,343m, cost basis $4,386.3m, market value $5,145.7m); Penmark Research model (CoE = 9.24%).
Dilution vs unused $2.0bn buyback
At-the-market (ATM) stock sales and notes lifted shares from 304m to 505m diluted (notes as debt), while buybacks stayed at zero. On 7 July 2026, stockholders raised authorized Class A stock from 1.0bn to 2.5bn shares. That keeps acquisition-currency risk live after May’s non-binding $125 cash-and-stock bid for eBay.
What it means for value
We value $4.7bn of cash, the 43.4m-share eBay stake and bitcoin at market prices, worth about $14 a share net of notes. Cash yields about 3.8% pre-tax against our 9.2% cost of equity, and bitcoin sits $194m below cost. A stock-funded eBay bid carries 25% risk (−$1.91 a share), supporting our 30% bear weight.
Three drivers move the stock; shares swung twice as much on deal and debt filings as on 10-Qs
GameStop does not trade like an ordinary specialty retailer. Routine quarterly reports brought modest single-day moves unless collectibles or annual guidance surprised, whereas debt-exchange and takeover filings coincided with double-digit swings. GameStop holds no earnings calls; filing-day moves, multi-year returns and weekly trading confirm three drivers behind the share price.
| Confirmed driver | What moves the stock | Evidence | Market reaction vs our model value | Debate linked | Next number to watch |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Balance-sheet & dilution filings | Note exchanges, M&A bids and share-count votes | Filing-day moves & share count | GME closed −12.2% on the 3 Aug note-exchange 8-K and −10.1% on the 4 May $125 eBay bid 8-K. Cash ($4.7bn), eBay ($5.1bn) and bitcoin less notes sit at market value; weighting scenarios cuts $0.71/sh (2.8% of the share price). | Scenario skew | Q3 FY26 10-Q cash, eBay & shares (date unconfirmed): we model $4.7bn cash after the Sep exchange, 0 buybacks. |
| Trading-card & EBITDA surprises | Quarterly card growth and annual EBITDA floor raises | Filing-day beats & 1Y/3Y profit turn | GME closed +5.3% on the Q2 10-Q (+56.5% cards) and +3.6% on June’s >$600m guide. Valuing mid-cycle EBITDA ($489m) instead of peak FY26E ($627m) at 7.3x cuts $1.99/sh (7.8% of price); separately, $25.36 implies +35% FY27E card growth. | Card normalization | Q3 FY26 sales & EPS (date unconfirmed): Penmark $741.5m / $0.22 (H2 seasonal split) vs Zacks $722.5m / $0.20. |
| Retail multiple vs peers | Retail EV multiple vs low-growth specialty chains | 5Y multiple reset & retail peers | The $25.36 price implies 9.4x FY26E (12.0x mid-cycle) EBITDA vs our 7.3x target. Paying 7.3x instead of 9.4x on FY26E cuts $2.62/sh (10.3% of price), or $4.60/sh combined with normalization (moving 12.0x to 7.3x on mid-cycle). | Retail multiple | FY26 10-K & FY27E guide (Mar 2027): we model $543.3m FY27E EBITDA (−13.4% y/y) as physical games shrink. |
Source: Company SEC filings; Yahoo Finance price history to 17 Nov 2026; Penmark Research model.
Source: Company SEC filing dates; Yahoo Finance observational day-0 closes (not causal).
Source: Penmark Research model and Yahoo Finance price returns to 17 Nov 2026 ($0 dividends paid).
Source: Penmark Research model (504.8m diluted shares, notes treated as debt).
Market factors explain only about a tenth of weekly moves; company news drives the rest
Source: Yahoo Finance 52-week weekly returns to 17 Nov 2026 (joint R² = 10.6%; residual = 89.4%).
Why index and asset tickers miss the story
Together, the S&P 500, the SPDR S&P Retail exchange-traded fund (XRT), eBay and bitcoin explain only 10.6% of weekly share-price moves. The remaining 89.4% comes from company news and retail positioning. GameStop holds no earnings calls, so investors react to SEC filings on debt exchanges, takeover bids and card sales. Cash, the 43.4m-share eBay stake and bitcoin are visible at market prices, so we take them at market value.
How the price reacts
Equity issuance and control-deal terms move the stock far more than routine earnings. Issuing 55.5m shares in the note exchange and floating a stock-and-cash eBay offer raised dilution concerns that outweighed the cash-rich balance sheet.
How it hits value
Non-operating assets sit at market value, so capital allocation skews risk to the downside. Our bear case applies a 10% capital-allocation haircut ($908m), while a stock-funded eBay bid is a separate −$1.91 a share risk (25% probability).
What breaks the pattern
Links to Scenario skew. Returning cash via buybacks below $20 or monetizing eBay shares for cash would narrow downside skew; resuming stock-funded deal bids would widen it.
How the price reacts
Investors extrapolate recent card momentum into FY27E. Despite a near-zero (0.04) quarterly correlation between card sales and share returns, Q2’s collectibles jump and two FY26 EBITDA guidance raises drove the +24% 12-month stock rally.
How it hits value
Peak-to-mid-cycle normalization ($627m to $489m EBITDA at 7.3x) removes $1.99 a share. Separately, our −12% FY27E card forecast versus the +35% implied in $25.36 is the same $4.60 retail gap ($25.36 minus $20.76 base value; about $0.99 per 10 points, not additive with the multiple gap below).
What breaks the pattern
Links to Card normalization. Holiday card sell-through and Q3 FY26 collectibles against H2 FY25’s much tougher base will test whether secondary price declines hit store intake.
How the price reacts
Retail investor positioning holds the implied operating multiple above comparable chains. Over five years, post-squeeze multiple compression left shares down 52% even as cash climbed, showing how sensitive the stock is to valuation resets.
How it hits value
Paying 7.3x instead of 9.4x on FY26E EBITDA cuts $2.62 a share. Combined with the $1.99 peak-to-mid-cycle adjustment, moving from 12.0x to 7.3x on mid-cycle EBITDA removes $4.60 a share ($5.9bn implied retail EV vs our $3.6bn base).
What breaks the pattern
Links to Retail multiple. Sustaining positive store traffic or lifting FY27E EBITDA above $600m would support a multiple above our 8.1x Hold threshold.
| Candidate factor | Why it does not drive weekly moves |
|---|---|
| Broad equity market (S&P 500) | GME rose 37.8% over three months while the S&P 500 fell 5.2%, and lags by 108 points over five years. |
| Weekly eBay share price | Takeover bids move GME, whereas routine weekly eBay moves are visible at market prices and already reflected. |
| Spot bitcoin price | GameStop’s 4,710 bitcoin ($306.2m at spot) represent under 3% of our $10.5bn base equity value. |
| Routine filings without new guidance | The FY25 10-K (24 Mar 2026) and Q1 10-Q (11 Jun 2026) coincided with −1.0% and −1.1% single-day moves. |
Source: Yahoo Finance price history to 17 Nov 2026; Company SEC filings; Penmark Research model.
What the market believes
Investors extrapolate H1 FY26’s 61% collectibles surge as a lasting growth trend. Consensus models $1.09 of FY26E diluted EPS (Zacks) and $1.02 in FY27E (MarketBeat), pricing in only a small profit dip after FY26 adjusted EBITDA clears management’s $650m floor.
At our 7.3x peer multiple, the $25.36 share price implies +35% collectibles growth in FY27E. Bulls assume PSA walk-in intake will keep compounding off FY26’s record base.
Falling card prices meet a tough H2 comparison
Secondary card prices have rolled over sharply entering the holiday half. Pokémon 30th Celebration chase cards fell 60%–75% in the 30 days to November 2026, while modern sealed product sits 15%–25% below its 2025 peak. Q1 and Q2 FY26 collectibles ($349m and $356m) held close to holiday Q4 FY25 ($365m). However, H2 FY26E now laps a $621m H2 FY25A base that sat 42% above H1 FY25A.
Source: Company FY25 10-K (A); Penmark Research scenario model (E).
| Independent source | Observed metric and period | What it means for FY26E–FY28E forecasts |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Card secondary-market pricing | Pokémon 30th Celebration chase cards fell 60%–75% in the 30 days to November 2026, while modern sealed product sits 15%–25% below its 2025 peak. | Lower chase-card and sealed-box prices squeeze flipper spreads and collector resale budgets, driving our −12.0% FY27E collectibles pullback ($1,232.7m) after FY26E’s $1,400.8m peak. |
| 2. SEC 10-Q & 10-K half-year comparisons | Collectibles rose 60.6% y/y in H1 FY26 to $705.2m against an H1 FY25A base of $439.1m, whereas H2 FY25A collectibles reached $621.1m (+41.5% above H1 FY25A). | Q1 and Q2 FY26 held up well after holiday Q4 ($365.0m), so we model +12.0% H2 FY26E growth ($695.6m) against the much higher $621.1m H2 FY25A base before card cooling hits FY27E. |
| 3. Game-category filings & vendor mix | Nintendo, Sony and Pokémon represent most FY25 new purchases. In H1 FY26, video games fell 34.9% y/y (Switch 2 lap, France exit, digital releases) and pre-owned fell 11.9%. | Physical games and trade-ins shed $345.2m of H1 sales vs a $266.1m collectibles gain. Once card sales cool in FY27E, all three retail lines contract at the same time. |
Source: GameStop FY25 10-K and Q2 FY26 10-Q; Penmark Research model.
Cooling cards pull EBITDA from a $630m peak to mid-cycle, cutting about $2 a share
Source: Penmark Research model (Revenue build).
Source: Penmark Research model (Sensitivities; category GM is model-estimated).
Penmark vs consensus on the card cycle
| Metric ($m except EPS) | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E |
|---|---|---|---|
| Collectibles sales, Penmark | 1,400.8 | 1,232.7 | 1,171.1 |
| Collectibles growth y/y | +32.1% | −12.0% | −5.0% |
| Total net sales, Penmark | 3,364.5 | 2,953.4 | 2,722.1 |
| Net sales, consensus | 3,360.0 | n.d. | n.d. |
| Adjusted EBITDA, Penmark | 677.4 | 575.3 | 473.5 |
| Adjusted diluted EPS, Penmark | $1.10 | $0.90 | $0.84 |
| Diluted EPS, consensus | $1.09 | $1.02 | n.d. |
| Penmark EPS vs consensus | +1.0% | −11.4% | n.a. |
Source: Zacks via Yahoo Finance (FY26E, 6 Nov 2026) and MarketBeat via IBTimes (FY27E EPS, 2 Nov 2026); Penmark Research model. n.a. = not applicable.
What it is worth per share
Valuing mid-cycle EBITDA ($489m) instead of peak FY26E ($627m) at 7.3x takes $1.99 a share off price-implied value. Our 12% FY27E collectibles pullback ($168m) plus game and pre-owned declines cuts FY27E sales by $411m (−12%) and pre-impairment EBITDA from $627m to $543m. Separately, our −12% FY27E card forecast versus the +35% implied in the share price reflects the same $4.60 retail gap ($25.36 minus $20.76 base value; about $0.99 per 10 points).
Dated signposts to confirm or disprove
- Q3 FY26 10-Q (date unconfirmed): Confirms if collectibles slow toward our +12% H2 pace; disproves if Q3 collectibles top $384m (+50% y/y).
- March 2027 (FY26 10-K): Full-year card mix and initial FY27 adjusted EBITDA floor test whether $650m+ marked a peak.
- June 2027 (Q1 FY27 10-Q): First lap of Q1 FY26’s +65.0% card jump ($348.9m vs $211.5m).
Source: Company 10-K filings (A); Penmark Research model (E).
Source: Peer SEC filings; Penmark Research model.
What the market believes
At $25.36, subtracting $6.9bn of net non-operating assets leaves $5.9bn of implied retail EV. That equals 9.4x peak FY26E EBITDA ($627m) and 12.0x mid-cycle EBITDA ($489m), a multiple peers earn only when opening stores and growing sales.
| Independent source | Observed metric and period | Why it caps GameStop’s retail EV/EBITDA at 7.26x |
|---|---|---|
| 1. US & global specialty-retail peer multiples | Low-growth US peers trade at 4.74x–8.94x EV/EBITDA (Bath & Body Works 4.74x on −0.2% growth and 18.9% margin; Academy Sports 7.26x on +2.0% growth; Best Buy 8.94x on +0.4% growth), while 15x–18x multiples go to +17%–23% unit growers (Ollie’s, Five Below). | Across eight organic US and global peers (excluding Dick’s Foot Locker acquisition), sales growth is associated with 77% of EV/EBITDA variation (R² = 0.77). Bath & Body Works shows that a 19% margin trades under 5x when sales are flat to shrinking. |
| 2. SEC 10-K & 10-Q store-closure saturation | GameStop cut total stores from 4,573 (FY21) to 2,206 at FY25 year-end (1,898 in the US and Australia after closing 727 US stores and exiting Canada, with France exited by Q3 FY26) and expects no major FY26 US closures. | Pruning weak leases lifted EBITDA margin from −4.7% (FY21) to 18.6% (FY26E), well above the 3.8% FY13–25 median. Across about 1,900 remaining US and Australian shops, store SG&A ($300k/store in FY27E, +3% inflation) deleverages as physical games shrink, pulling margin to 14.5% by FY30E. |
| 3. Cross-check 10-year retail DCF valuation | Discounting H2 FY26E–FY35E unlevered retail free cash flow (expensing $32m–$41m annual stock-based compensation) at a 9.24% cost of equity and −1.5% terminal growth gives $2,907.6m of retail EV (5.94x mid-cycle EBITDA). | Cash-flow discounting values the shrinking retail chain 18.1% below our $3,551.2m peer-multiple EV ($19.48 vs $20.76 base value per share), showing that 7.26x is generous rather than harsh. |
Source: Peer SEC filings and Yahoo Finance global peers (17 Nov 2026); GameStop FY25 10-K and Q2 10-Q; Penmark Research model.
What it is worth (about $2.60 a share) and low conviction
Paying 7.3x instead of 9.4x on FY26E EBITDA cuts $2.62 a share, and combined with $1.99 of EBITDA normalization, moving from 12.0x to 7.3x on mid-cycle cuts $4.60 a share ($2.3bn). We credit a 16.6% FY26E–30E margin (4.7 points above the 11.9% peer median). We would move to Hold if the evidence supports a target multiple above about 8x mid-cycle EBITDA (8.1x; 8.8x all-peer median), which explains our low conviction.
Signposts and what bulls get wrong
Bulls treat cash plus retail as a compounding holding company while physical games shrink and comps stay negative. Watch the March 2027 FY26 10-K for store-level SG&A ($300k/store base) and the US and Australian store count (1,879 modeled). Then watch the H1 FY27 10-Qs (June and September 2027) for SG&A rising above 23.6% of sales as revenue contracts.
Source: Penmark Research model (spot values per share on 17 Nov 2026).
Source: Penmark Research model (spot values per share on 17 Nov 2026).
What the market believes
Bulls treat GameStop’s $4.7bn of post-exchange cash, $5.1bn eBay stake and $0.3bn of bitcoin as a free option on mergers and acquisitions (M&A). Net of $2.8bn of 0% convertible notes and $245m of customer liabilities, non-operating assets total $6.9bn. Bulls argue this balance sheet floors downside while Mr. Cohen hunts for deals.
| Independent source | Disclosed terms and dates | Why downside skew outweighs upside optionality |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Form 8-K (4 May 2026) & Q2 10-Q Note 10 | GameStop sent a non-binding proposal on 3 May 2026 to buy all of eBay (market cap about $52bn) for $125.00/share in cash and GameStop stock. It holds 43.4m eBay shares ($5.1bn at $118.59, cost $4.4bn). | eBay already trades within 5.4% of the $125 bid ($118.59), capping bull upside on the stake at $0.42 a share after tax, while a stock-funded bid carries a separate −$1.91 a share dilution risk (25% probability). |
| 2. AGM (7 Jul 2026; 8-K filed 8 Jul) & Buyback Note | Stockholders raised authorized Class A stock from 1.0bn to 2.5bn shares on 7 July 2026. Zero shares were bought under the $2.0bn buyback authorization through 1 August 2026. | Management holds 2.0bn unissued authorized shares for control deals while buying back none below $25, leaving asymmetric dilution risk if acquisition bidding resumes. |
| 3. Convertible Note 8-Ks (Aug/Sep 2026) & 10-Q Note 15 | After exchanging $1.4bn of notes for $358.4m cash and 55.5m shares on 3 Sep 2026, $1,100m of 2030 notes ($29.85 conversion) and $1,700m of 2032 notes ($28.91 conversion) remain. | Below $28.91–$29.85, 2028 note puts let holders put $2,800m back at par in FY28E (starting April 2028 on the 2030 notes), claiming 60% of $4.7bn pro-forma cash; above $29.85, 95.6m conversion shares cap upside. |
Source: SEC Forms 8-K (4 May, 8 Jul, 3 Aug, 31 Aug, 8 Sep 2026) and Q2 FY26 10-Q; Penmark Research model.
Weighting bear 30% and bull 20% takes about 70 cents a share off our base value
| Item ($m except per-share) | Bear (30%) | Base (50%) | Bull (20%) | Weighted | Basis in Penmark model |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash after 3 Sep 2026 exchange | 4,701.9 | 4,701.9 | 4,701.9 | 4,701.9 | $5,060.3m at 1 Aug less $358.4m cash paid |
| eBay stake after unrealized-gain tax (43.4m sh) | 4,373.8 | 4,963.4 | 5,174.6 | 4,828.8 | Bear −15% ($100.80); Base $118.59; Bull $125 bid |
| Spot bitcoin holdings (4,710 BTC) | 306.2 | 306.2 | 306.2 | 306.2 | $0.3bn market value; $500.0m cost |
| Less: customer liabilities (gift cards, credit) | (244.9) | (244.9) | (244.9) | (244.9) | Operating cash encumbrance |
| Less: 0% convertible notes (2030 & 2032 par) | (2,800.0) | (2,800.0) | (2,800.0) | (2,800.0) | $1.1bn 2030 + $1.7bn 2032; 2028 note puts |
| Less: bear-case capital-allocation haircut (10%) | (907.6) | 0.0 | 0.0 | (272.3) | 10% haircut on net cash and after-tax eBay in Bear |
| Net non-operating value ($m) | 5,429.5 | 6,926.6 | 7,137.8 | 6,519.7 | Base $6,926.6m (66.1% of base equity) |
| Net non-operating value per share (504.8m sh) | $10.76 | $13.72 | $14.14 | $12.92 | Bear drops $2.97/sh below Base |
| Retail operations EV per share (504.8m sh) | $3.39 | $7.03 | $12.99 | $7.13 | Retail EV: Bear $1,711.7m; Base $3,551.2m; Bull $6,556.9m |
| Intrinsic value per share (17 Nov 2026) | $14.15 | $20.76 | $27.13 | $20.05 | Scenario skew = $20.05 − $20.76 = −$0.71/sh |
| 12-month target price (rolled at 9.24% CoE) | $15.45 | $22.67 | $29.64 | $21.90 | Total return −13.6% vs $25.36 (Sell) |
Source: Penmark Research model (504.8m diluted shares with notes as debt; Base net non-operating value $6,926.6m).
What scenario skew is worth (about 70 cents a share)
Weighting the bear case at 30% and the bull at 20% takes $0.71 off our $20.76 base value, leaving $20.05. In our bull case, eBay reaching the $125 bid adds only $211.2m after tax ($0.42 a share) over base, and any rally past $28.91–$29.85 triggers 95.6m conversion shares.
In our bear case, total value falls $6.61 a share below base ($14.15 vs $20.76). A 15% eBay pullback (−$589.6m after tax) and a 10% capital-allocation haircut (−$907.6m) cut net non-operating value by $2.97 a share while retail EBITDA shrinks.
Dated signposts to confirm or disprove
- Any 13D or 8-K on eBay (2026–27): Monetizing the 43.4m-share stake near $125 adds $0.42 a share after tax; launching a stock-funded takeover carries a separate −$1.91 a share impact (25% probability).
- Quarterly 10-Q buyback disclosures: Using the $2.0bn buyback authorization below $20 a share lifts per-share value; buying above $25 reduces it.
- April 2028 (2028 note puts): First par put window on $1,100m of 0% 2030 notes if GME trades below $29.85.
Group FCF reached about $600m in FY25A (including interest), while investment gains doubled H1 GAAP profit
Source: Company Q2 FY26 earnings release, Schedule II; Penmark Research model.
Source: Company FY25 10-K and prior 10-K filings (group FCF includes $271.5m FY25A cash interest).
Four-year operating turnaround (FY21A–FY25A)
Sales shrank 40% over four years, yet operating profit swung by +$601m. Store closures, country exits and digital games cut net sales from $6.0bn (FY21A) to $3.6bn (FY25A). Over the same period, gross margin climbed from 22% to 33% and SG&A fell 47%, lifting GAAP EBIT from −$369m to +$232m.
Multi-site retail accounting and earnings-quality review
1. Non-operating investment marksMajor distortion
Under GAAP, equity derivatives, eBay shares and bitcoin mark to market through net income. In FY25A, a $131.6m bitcoin loss cut pre-tax profit, while $271.5m of cash interest and a $34.4m tax benefit lifted GAAP net income to $418.4m. In H1 FY26A, $506.8m of eBay derivative and equity gains plus $29.4m of other gains less a $73.9m bitcoin loss added $462.3m pre-tax, doubling GAAP net income ($688.3m vs $345.5m adjusted).
2. Customer liabilities ($244.9m)Watch item
Unredeemed gift cards, trade-in store credit and Pro loyalty deferrals rose by $50.0m in H1 FY26A to $244.9m. That working-capital inflow lifted H1 FY26A reported free cash flow ($393.6m vs $343.6m excluding customer liabilities). To avoid double-counting, our valuation deducts $244.9m in the equity bridge and excludes customer-liability inflows from valued retail cash flow.
3. Stock-based comp & transformationAdjusted out by co.
Company-defined adjusted EBITDA ($345.4m in FY25A; $339.7m in H1 FY26A) adds back stock-based compensation ($26.7m FY25A; $15.8m H1 FY26A) and asset impairments ($53.8m FY25A; −$6.9m H1 benefit). It also removes $18.2m of transformation and other items, including $15.6m of other income. Because stock awards make up ~90% of non-CEO officer pay, we value retail on EBITDA after expensing stock compensation ($627.4m FY26E).
4. Lease accounting & capex intensityClean & consistent
Short store lease terms left operating-lease right-of-use assets at $158.9m and lease liabilities at $165.4m on 1 August 2026 (down from $197.6m at FY25A end). Rent is expensed inside EBITDA for both GameStop and all six US peers, and lease liabilities are excluded from EV on both sides. Capital expenditure was just $17.5m in FY25A (0.5% of sales); FCF was 143% of net income ($597.3m vs $418.4m).
FY26E adjusted EBITDA of about $680m beats guidance, while FY27E EPS sits 11% below consensus
Source: Company FY25 10-K (A); Penmark Research model (E).
| $m unless stated | FY25A | H1 FY26A | H2 FY26E | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E | Driver reasoning in Penmark model |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ending US & AU stores (#) | 1,898 | n.d. | 1,879 | 1,879 | 1,841 | 1,805 | −1% FY26E (10-Q guide), −2%/yr FY27E–30E |
| Collectibles revenue | 1,060.2 | 705.2 | 695.6 | 1,400.8 | 1,232.7 | 1,171.1 | +12% H2 FY26E vs $621.1m H2 FY25A; −12% FY27E |
| Video games revenue | n.d. | 549.8 | 678.2 | 1,228.0 | 1,080.6 | 994.2 | Modeled Q4 console/code lift, then −12% / −8% decay |
| Pre-owned & refurbished | n.d. | 370.5 | 365.2 | 735.7 | 640.0 | 556.8 | −13%/yr FY27E–29E as digital shrinks trade-in supply |
| Total net sales | 3,629.9 | 1,625.5 | 1,739.0 | 3,364.5 | 2,953.4 | 2,722.1 | Europe exited from Q3 FY26; US & AU retained |
| Gross margin (%) | 33.0% | 42.2% | 38.9% | 40.4% | 41.4% | 41.6% | Est. GM: cards 54%, pre-owned 45%, games 22.2% FY26E / 25% FY27E+ |
| US/AU store SG&A | n.d. | 271.5 | 292.7 | 564.2 | 558.1 | 563.3 | H1 actual + H2 model ($300k/store FY27E, +3%/yr) |
| US/AU corporate & SBC | n.d. | 66.0 | 70.0 | 136.0 | 140.0 | 144.2 | H1 actual + H2 model (head office + $32m–$33m SBC) |
| Exited Europe SG&A | n.d. | 51.2 | 0.0 | 51.2 | 0.0 | 0.0 | H1 actual before Q3 FY26 France exit |
| Total SG&A (% of sales) | 910.2 (25.1%) | 388.7 (23.9%) | 362.7 (20.9%) | 751.4 (22.3%) | 698.1 (23.6%) | 707.5 (26.0%) | Fixed-cost deleverage adds +236bp to SG&A/sales in FY28E |
| EBITDA before impairments | 300.5 | 305.7 | 321.7 | 627.4 | 543.3 | 440.5 | Margin: 18.6% FY26E, 18.4% FY27E, 16.2% FY28E |
Source: Company FY25 10-K and Q2 FY26 10-Q; Penmark Research model (FY26E games GM blends 25% H1 and 20% H2; store/corporate SG&A split is model-estimated).
| Metric & period | Penmark | Consensus / Guide | Gap | Source of difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q3 FY26E net sales ($m) | 741.5 | 722.5 (Zacks) | +2.6% | Model-derived seasonality allocation before tougher Q4/FY27 comps |
| Q3 FY26E diluted EPS ($, alloc.) | $0.22 | $0.20 (Zacks) | +10.0% | H2 seasonality allocation; lean Q2 total SG&A ($187m) plus interest |
| FY26E net sales ($m) | 3,364.5 | 3,360.0 (Zacks) | +0.1% | In line; holiday Q4 accounts for ~30% of annual sales |
| FY26E adjusted EBITDA ($m) | 677.4 | >650.0 (Co. guide) | +4.2% | H1 FY26A delivered $339.7m; H2 adds $337.7m |
| FY26E adj. diluted EPS ($) | $1.10 | $1.09 (Zacks) | +1.0% | Strips net H1 investment gains ($1.68 GAAP EPS) |
| FY27E diluted EPS ($) | $0.90 | $1.02 (MarketBeat) | −11.4% | Consensus misses −12% card cooling and lower cash interest |
Source: Zacks via Yahoo Finance (Q3 & FY26E, 6 Nov 2026) and MarketBeat via IBTimes (FY27E EPS, 2 Nov 2026; one EPS analyst and one sales analyst); Company 8-K (8 Sep 2026); Penmark Research model.
Group FCF totals $1.7bn in FY26E–28E (including interest), while $2.8bn of note puts cut cash by 40%
Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model cash-flow forecasts.
| Cash & balance sheet ($m) | FY25A | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E | FY29E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash from operations | 614.8 | 655.4 | 601.6 | 526.8 | 422.0 |
| Capital expenditure | (17.5) | (14.9) | (14.8) | (13.6) | (13.1) |
| Group FCF (incl. interest) | 597.3 | 640.5 | 586.9 | 513.2 | 408.9 |
| FCF excl. customer liab. | 631.3 | 653.7 | 609.1 | 525.7 | 414.8 |
| Unlevered retail FCF | n.a. | n.a. | 428.6 | 337.1 | 295.6 |
| Working cap. inflow (ex-CL) | 34.6 | 16.1 | 31.5 | 16.1 | 8.5 |
| Closing cash & securities | 9,013.8 | 4,948.8 | 5,535.6 | 3,248.8 | 3,657.8 |
| Conv. notes (carrying / par) | 4,164.3 | 2,800.0 | 2,800.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
| ROIC (model, incl. ROU) | n.d. | 175.9% | 159.2% | 131.8% | 120.5% |
Source: Penmark Research model (FY25A notes $4,164.3m carrying value on $4,200m par; FY26E–27E at $2,800m par).
Working capital, capex and interest
Year-end inventory release supports cash flow while capex stays under $15m a year. Inventory rose seasonally from $403m (FY25A) to $439m in H1 FY26 before falling to $333m by FY26E year-end. Core working capital adds $16m–$32m a year even as customer liabilities run off by $13m–$22m.
The 2028 note puts cut cash by 41% in FY28E and trim FY29E interest by $94m. Holders of the 0% 2030 ($1.1bn) and 2032 ($1.7bn) notes hold par puts in 2028 (conversion prices $29.85 and $28.91). Our base model repays $2.8bn in cash during FY28E, cutting closing cash from $5.5bn to $3.2bn.
Driver sensitivity on FY27E EPS and FCF
Every 10pp swing in FY27E collectibles growth moves FY27E EBITDA by $76m, EPS by $0.09 (600.4m accounting shares) and base value by $0.99 a share. A 2pp shift in estimated collectibles gross margin moves FY27E EBITDA by $25m, EPS by $0.03 and base value by $0.30 a share.
Sum of the parts and DCF agree within about 6%, anchoring our $22 target
Source: Penmark Research model (valuation, scenarios and specialty-retail peers).
Source: Peer SEC filings; Yahoo Finance (non-US peers: JB Hi-Fi, Fnac Darty, Currys).
Why SOTP beats P/E and why DCF is our cross-check
Two-thirds of equity value sits in cash, eBay and bitcoin, making group P/E misleading. Our SOTP values retail stores at 7.3x mid-cycle EBITDA ($489m) plus $6.9bn of net non-operating assets.
Retail DCF EV ($2.9bn) sits 18% below primary retail EV ($3.6bn). Our 7.3x multiple reflects low-growth peers (−0.2% to +2.0% growth), whereas the 10-year DCF models secular game shrinkage through FY35E. That yields a 6% lower equity value ($19.48 vs $20.76).
| Valuation component ($m unless stated) | Primary (EV/EBITDA) | Cross-check (DCF) | At $25.36 price | Basis and source in Penmark model |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mid-cycle EBITDA ($2,953.4m FY27E sales × 16.56% margin) | 489.1 | n.a. | 489.1 | FY26E–30E mean margin after expensing SBC |
| Target / implied EV / mid-cycle EBITDA (x) | 7.26x | 5.94x | 12.01x | Low-growth peer median (BBY 8.94x, ASO 7.26x, BBWI 4.74x) |
| Retail operations enterprise value (EV) | 3,551.2 | 2,907.6 | 5,875.1 | DCF = $1,958.0m PV FCF + $874.6m PV TV × 1.0265 roll-fwd |
| Cash after 3 Sep 2026 exchange ($4.7bn) | 4,701.9 | 4,701.9 | 4,701.9 | $5,060.3m at 1 Aug less $358.4m exchange cash |
| 43.4m-share eBay stake net of 24% deferred tax | 4,963.4 | 4,963.4 | 4,963.4 | Market value $5,145.7m ($118.59/sh) less $182.2m tax |
| Spot bitcoin (4,710 BTC) | 306.2 | 306.2 | 306.2 | Market value at 17 Nov 2026 ($500.0m cost basis) |
| Less: customer liabilities (gift cards, store credit) | (244.9) | (244.9) | (244.9) | Operating cash encumbrance at 1 Aug 2026 |
| Convertible notes at face value (2028 note puts) | (2,800.0) | (2,800.0) | (2,800.0) | Conversion prices $28.91–$29.85 exceed value & $25.36 price |
| Net non-operating value (notes as debt) | 6,926.6 | 6,926.6 | 6,926.6 | $13.72 per share across 504.8m diluted shares |
| Total base equity value ($m) / per share ($) | 10,477.8 / $20.76 | 9,834.3 / $19.48 | 12,801.7 / $25.36 | 504.8m diluted shares (449.1m basic + 55.7m exch./RSU) |
| Probability-weighted spot value (30% Bear / 50% Base / 20% Bull) | $20.05 | $19.02 | −20.9% return to value | Scenario skew = −$0.71/sh ($20.05 vs $20.76) |
| 12-month price target (rolled forward at 9.24% CoE; $0 div.) | $21.90 | $20.78 | −13.6% return | Implies −13.6% total return vs $25.36 (Sell) |
| Implied EV / FY26E EBITDA & Adj. FY26E P/E | 6.58x / 19.9x (at target) | n.a. | 9.36x / 23.0x (at price) | Target multiple moving rating to Hold: above ~8x (8.1x) |
Source: Penmark Research model (market close 17 Nov 2026).
The price implies 35% collectibles growth in FY27E; neither sensitivity grid reaches $23
Source: Penmark Research model (target multiple moves with cost of equity).
Source: Penmark Research model (terminal value is 30.9% of DCF EV).
WACC, cost of equity and terminal growth
Weighted average cost of capital (WACC) is the blended annual return debt and equity investors require to fund operating assets. Retail stores carry zero operating debt because the 0% notes are deducted at par in the equity bridge. Retail WACC therefore equals our 9.24% cost of equity (5.10% 10-year US Treasury plus 1.00 beta times a 4.14% equity risk premium).
Terminal growth is the perpetual annual growth rate assumed for retail cash flows after FY35E. We set terminal growth at −1.5%, matching the FY30E–FY35E sales compound annual growth rate (CAGR) as store closures offset per-store cost inflation.
What the price implies
A reverse discounted cash flow (reverse DCF) works backward from the $25.36 share price to find the operating assumptions needed to justify it. Subtracting $6.9bn of net non-operating value leaves $5.9bn ($11.64 a share) of implied retail EV.
Reaching $25.36 requires +35% FY27E collectibles growth on top of FY26E’s $1.4bn record. Holding base cash flows fixed, $5.9bn of retail EV implies 12.0x mid-cycle EBITDA or perpetual FCF growth of roughly +6.5% a year forever after FY35E instead of −1.5%. Neither sensitivity grid above reaches $23.
Bull, Base and Bear cases tied to confirmed stock drivers
- Bear case (30% weight; $14.15 SOTP / $12.18 DCF; $15.45 target, −39.1%): Collectibles +2% H2 FY26E and −30% FY27E; collectibles gross margin −3pp; eBay −15%; 10% capital-allocation haircut ($1.7bn retail EV).
- Base case (50% weight; $20.76 SOTP / $19.48 DCF; $22.67 target, −10.6%): Collectibles +12% H2 FY26E and −12% FY27E; 7.26x low-growth peer multiple; eBay and bitcoin at market ($3.6bn retail EV).
- Bull case (20% weight; $27.13 SOTP / $28.14 DCF; $29.64 target, +16.9%): Collectibles +25% H2 FY26E and +20% FY27E; collectibles gross margin +2pp; eBay monetized at $125 offer ($6.6bn retail EV).
- Probability-weighted (100%; $20.05 SOTP / $19.02 DCF; $21.90 target, −13.6% total return, Sell): Probability-weighted value sits $0.71 below Base, rolled forward at 9.24% cost of equity.
Five checkpoints to April 2028 test the card cycle (about +$3 a share) against deal dilution (about −$2)
Source: Penmark Research model catalyst value impacts (Q4 GTA VI code/console mix is a model assumption).
| Window / date | Catalyst event | Penmark expectation | Consensus / market view | Value / rating impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 2026 (Unconfirmed) | Q3 FY26 10-Q & earnings release (no call held) | Sales $741.5m; EPS $0.22 (alloc.); H2 card growth slows toward +12% | Zacks: sales $722.5m, EPS $0.20; FY26 guide >$650m | Card beat & guide raise adds +$0.58/sh; miss backs cooling |
| Late Mar 2027 | Q4 & FY26 Form 10-K + initial FY27 EBITDA outlook | FY26E sales $3,364.5m, adj. EBITDA $677.4m, adj. EPS $1.10; modeled Q4 console/code lift | Zacks FY26E sales $3,360m, EPS $1.09; MarketBeat FY27E EPS $1.02 | FY27 EBITDA guide <$580m backs −11.4% EPS gap & peak-to-mid-cycle reset (−$1.99/sh) |
| Jun 2027 | Q1 FY27 10-Q (laps +65.0% Q1 FY26 card surge) | Collectibles growth turns negative (−12% FY27E base) vs $348.9m Q1 FY26 comp | Share price ($25.36) implies +35% FY27E card growth | +20% FY27E collectibles growth adds $3.15/sh & moves us to Hold |
| May–Nov 2027 | 13D / 8-K filings on 43.4m-share eBay stake or buyback | Base holds eBay at $118.59 ($5.1bn market) & $0 buybacks | Optionality priced in after non-binding $125/sh May 2026 bid | Cash sale at $125 = +$0.42/sh; stock bid = −$1.91/sh; −15% = −$1.17/sh |
| Apr 2028 | 2028 note puts ($1,100m 2030 notes; $1,700m 2032 Dec) | Holders put at par unless GME tops $28.91–$29.85 conversion prices | GAAP EPS includes 95.6m shares; bulls treat cash as unencumbered | $2.8bn cash repayment in FY28E cuts cash ~40% & interest $93.9m |
Source: Company SEC filings; Zacks via Yahoo Finance and MarketBeat via IBTimes; Penmark Research model.
Monitoring framework across our three debates and stock drivers
1. Card normalization
Watch: Q3 FY26 collectibles ($286.8m modeled) & FY27E card growth (−12% base).
Confirmed if: H2 FY26 card growth slows near +12% and FY27E cards contract.
Broken if: +20% FY27E collectibles growth adds $3.15 a share and moves us to Hold.
2. Retail multiple
Watch: US segment EBIT margin & peer EV/EBITDA (7.26x target vs 8.8x US median).
Confirmed if: Physical games shrink (−7% to −12% total sales), capping retail at 7.26x.
Broken if: Evidence supports a target multiple above about 8x EBITDA (8.1x = Hold).
3. Scenario skew & M&A
Watch: Form 8-K / 13D on 43.4m-share eBay stake & 10-Q buyback table ($0 to 1 Aug).
Confirmed if: Stock-funded bid (−$1.91/sh, 25% risk) or eBay slips (−15% bear).
Broken if: Cash eBay sale near $125 (+$0.42/sh) funds buybacks below $20.05 value.
No single upside risk takes value above about $24; it would take several at once
Source: Penmark Research model sensitivities (each bar varies one driver while holding others at base).
| Risk factor & direction | Likelihood | Value / sh | Mechanism and what would end our Sell thesis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trading-card boom extends into FY27E Upside to Sell | Medium (20% Bull) | +$3.15 | PSA intake and Pokémon releases sustain +20% FY27E collectibles growth instead of −12%, lifting base value to $23.91 and moving us to Hold. |
| Target multiple rises to all-peer median Upside to Sell | Medium (Low conv.) | +$1.48 | Supporting a target multiple above about 8x mid-cycle EBITDA (8.1x; 8.8x US peer median = $22.24 base value) would move our rating to Hold. |
| Cash eBay sale at $125 + buybacks <$20 Upside to Sell | Low–Med | +$0.42 | Selling the 43.4m-share eBay stake near $125 adds $0.42/sh after tax; using the $2.0bn buyback authorization below $20.05 lifts per-share value. |
| Retail squeeze / non-fundamental rally Upside to Sell | Medium | Price spike | 89.4% of weekly return variance is company-specific, and FINRA short interest sits at 42.4m shares (5.25 days to cover); retail flows can lift price above value. |
| Stock-funded eBay bid / M&A dilution Downside | Medium (25% risk) | −$1.91 | Authorized Class A shares rose from 1.0bn to 2.5bn in Jul 2026. Bidding for eBay (about $52bn market cap) with cash and stock risks dilution. |
| eBay takeover premium & bitcoin swings Downside | Medium (30% risk) | −$1.17 | The 43.4m-share eBay stake ($4.96bn after tax) equals 47% of base equity; a 15% eBay pullback cuts $1.17/sh, and 4,709 BTC are pledged. |
| Faster card cooling & pre-owned decay Downside | High (55% risk) | −$2.12 | A −30% FY27E card drop (−$1.79/sh) plus 18% annual pre-owned decay (−$0.33/sh) deleverage semi-fixed store payroll and rent; the bear case also cuts collectibles gross margin by 3pp. |
Source: Company FY25 10-K, Q2 FY26 10-Q and 2026 Proxy; Penmark Research model.
Key-person, margin-loan & related-party risks
Treasury and M&A policy rest on Ryan Cohen (Chairman since June 2021, CEO since September 2023), who holds 8.4% of shares. Per the May 2026 proxy, 38.35m of Mr. Cohen’s shares were held in a margin account capped at 50% loan-to-value, creating forced-sale risk in a deep sell-off.
PSA grading relies on a related-party partner. Director Nat Turner leads Collectors (parent of PSA, ~65% major grading volume) and is non-independent due to $39.8m of FY25 PSA collaboration volume, including $18.3m of Power Packs.
Supplier concentration, legal & ESG factors
Three vendors supply most new merchandise. Nintendo, Sony and The Pokémon Company represented over 50% of FY25 new-product purchases; tighter Pokémon card allocations or digital-only console releases directly cut store gross profit.
Governance and workforce carry tangible value risk, while environmental risk is minor. Concentrated investment control, zero earnings calls, a 2.5bn share authorization and reliance on 11,000–16,000 part-time store associates ($17.4k median pay) shape execution and deal risk.
Index funds and a large retail base support $203m of daily trading as short interest falls 36%
Source: FINRA short-interest settlements (15 Jan to 30 Oct 2026).
Source: Benzinga (Yorkville Ives, 7 Oct 2026; Wedbush, last published 11 Jun 2025); MarketBeat via IBTimes (StoneX, 2 Nov 2026); Penmark Research.
Short interest fell 36% in 2026 to 42.4m shares (5.25 days to cover). The 3 September note exchange retired $1.4bn of convertibles for 55.5m shares and $358.4m of cash, cutting arbitrage shorts by 29% in September.
| Reported institutional holder (13F) | Profile | Q3 2026 sh (m) | % of basic | Q2 2026 sh (m) | Q/Q change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Vanguard Group | Passive index / ETF complex (Total Stock Market) | 45.44m | 9.0% | 39.21m | +6.23m (+15.9%) |
| BlackRock Inc. | iShares Core S&P Mid-Cap (IJH) & Russell 1000 ETFs | 37.44m | 7.4% | 35.24m | +2.20m (+6.3%) |
| State Street Corp | SPDR ETF complex (incl. XRT retail ETF) | 15.99m | 3.2% | 12.82m | +3.17m (+24.7%) |
| Susquehanna International Group | Options market-making & convertible arbitrage | 12.88m | 2.6% | 4.49m | +8.38m (+186.6%) |
| Geode Capital Management | Passive index sub-advisor (Fidelity index suite) | 10.69m | 2.1% | 9.09m | +1.60m (+17.6%) |
| Renaissance Technologies | Quantitative equity strategies | 5.39m | 1.1% | 7.08m | −1.69m (−23.9%) |
| UBS Group AG | Global wealth & prime-brokerage custody | 4.47m | 0.9% | 6.02m | −1.55m (−25.7%) |
| Reported 13F holdings | Matched reporting filers in Q2 & Q3 2026 | 176.00m | 34.9% | 159.41m | +16.59m (+10.4%) |
Source: SEC Form 13F filings as of 30 September 2026 (% of 504.6m basic shares; compares matched reporting institutions across Q2 and Q3 2026; incomplete institutional coverage).
Trading liquidity, insider stake & overhangs
GME trades $203m a day on average (8.0m shares), backed by S&P MidCap 400 and Russell 1000 membership and an active retail base. Insiders bought $98.4m gross ($97.5m net across 4.20m shares bought) in September and October 2026, led by Ryan Cohen’s $97.1m purchase to 42.5m shares (8.4%).
October warrant expiry cleared one overhang, while note dilution sits near $29. All 59.1m $32.00 warrants expired unexercised on 30 October 2026, leaving $2.8bn of 0% convertible notes (95.6m shares at $28.91–$29.85 conversion prices) and 2.5bn authorized Class A shares.
Street ratings, targets & retail base
Three published broker targets (2 Buy, 0 Hold, 1 Sell) average $26.17. Yorkville Ives ($32.00, 7 Oct 2026) and StoneX ($33.00, 2 Nov 2026) anchor the high end, while Wedbush’s $13.50 Sell target was last published in June 2025.
Direct-registered and retail holders own roughly half the register. Matched 13F filers (34.9%) plus insiders (8.5%) leave ~57% across uncaptured institutions and retail accounts, explaining why 89% of weekly return variance is company-specific.
Operating cash flow stays positive through FY30E as EBITDA falls from about $630m to $370m
| Income statement & margins | FY24A | FY25A | H1 26A | H2 26E | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E | FY29E | FY30E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net sales | 3,823.0 | 3,629.9 | 1,625.5 | 1,739.0 | 3,364.5 | 2,953.4 | 2,722.1 | 2,613.5 | 2,561.2 |
| Collectibles revenue | 717.9 | 1,060.2 | 705.2 | 695.6 | 1,400.8 | 1,232.7 | 1,171.1 | 1,194.5 | 1,218.4 |
| Gross profit | 1,113.9 | 1,196.1 | 685.3 | 675.6 | 1,360.9 | 1,223.8 | 1,131.5 | 1,096.7 | 1,082.8 |
| Gross margin (%) | 29.1% | 33.0% | 42.2% | 38.9% | 40.4% | 41.4% | 41.6% | 42.0% | 42.3% |
| SG&A (incl. D&A and SBC) | −1,130.4 | −910.2 | −388.7 | −362.7 | −751.4 | −698.1 | −707.5 | −717.1 | −726.9 |
| GAAP operating income (EBIT) | −26.2 | 232.1 | 303.5 | 312.9 | 616.4 | 525.8 | 424.0 | 379.5 | 355.8 |
| Net interest & inv. gains/(losses) | 163.4 | 151.9 | 623.1 | 101.1 | 724.2 | 198.0 | 207.6 | 113.7 | 128.0 |
| Income tax (expense) / benefit | −5.9 | 34.4 | −238.3 | −103.5 | −341.8 | −180.9 | −157.9 | −123.3 | −121.0 |
| GAAP net income | 131.3 | 418.4 | 688.3 | 310.5 | 998.8 | 542.8 | 473.7 | 369.9 | 362.9 |
| Adjusted net income (ex-marks) | n.a. | n.a. | 345.5 | 310.5 | 656.0 | 542.8 | 473.7 | 369.9 | 362.9 |
| EBITDA before imp. (Penmark) | 22.4 | 300.5 | 305.7 | 321.7 | 627.4 | 543.3 | 440.5 | 395.1 | 370.5 |
| EBITDA margin (%) | 0.6% | 8.3% | 18.8% | 18.5% | 18.6% | 18.4% | 16.2% | 15.1% | 14.5% |
| Adjusted EBITDA (co. def.) | n.d. | 345.4 | 339.7 | 337.7 | 677.4 | 575.3 | 473.5 | 429.0 | 405.5 |
| GAAP diluted EPS ($) | $0.33 | $0.77 | $1.17 | $0.52 | $1.68 | $0.90 | $0.84 | $0.73 | $0.72 |
| Adjusted diluted EPS ($) | n.a. | n.a. | $0.58 | $0.52 | $1.10 | $0.90 | $0.84 | $0.73 | $0.72 |
| Diluted shares (m, GAAP EPS) | 394.7 | 549.1 | 592.5 | 599.1 | 595.8 | 600.4 | 562.5 | 504.8 | 504.8 |
| Ending US & AU stores (#) | 2,699 | 1,898 | n.d. | 1,879 | 1,879 | 1,841 | 1,805 | 1,769 | 1,733 |
| BS, CF & ratios | FY24A | FY25A | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E | FY30E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash & sec. | 4,774.9 | 9,013.8 | 4,948.8 | 5,535.6 | 3,248.8 | 4,059.1 |
| eBay & bitcoin | 0.0 | 368.4 | 5,241.0 | 5,241.0 | 5,241.0 | 5,241.0 |
| Inv. & rec. | 545.2 | 448.3 | 399.9 | 346.2 | 318.5 | 296.6 |
| Other assets | 555.3 | 557.9 | 305.9 | 299.0 | 293.8 | 287.8 |
| Total assets | 5,875.4 | 10,388.4 | 10,895.5 | 11,421.8 | 9,102.1 | 9,884.6 |
| Debt & notes | 16.9 | 4,164.3 | 2,800.0 | 2,800.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
| Other liab. | 928.7 | 779.7 | 618.2 | 569.7 | 543.4 | 524.1 |
| Total equity | 4,929.8 | 5,444.4 | 7,477.3 | 8,052.1 | 8,558.7 | 9,360.5 |
| Oper. CF | 145.7 | 614.8 | 655.4 | 601.6 | 526.8 | 414.1 |
| Capex | −16.1 | −17.5 | −14.9 | −14.8 | −13.6 | −12.8 |
| Group FCF | 129.6 | 597.3 | 640.5 | 586.9 | 513.2 | 401.3 |
| ROE (adj.) | n.a. | n.a. | 10.2% | 7.0% | 5.7% | 4.0% |
| ROA (adj.) | n.a. | n.a. | 6.2% | 4.9% | 4.6% | 3.7% |
| ROIC (model) | n.d. | n.d. | 175.9% | 159.2% | 131.8% | 114.7% |
| ND / EBITDA | n.m. | −16.1x | −3.4x | −5.0x | −7.4x | −11.0x |
| Quarters | Q3 FY25 | Q4 FY25 | Q1 FY26 | Q2 FY26 | Q3 FY26E | Q4 FY26E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reported actuals & model-derived H2 seasonality split | ||||||
| Net sales | 821.0 | 1,104.3 | 835.3 | 790.2 | 741.5 | 997.5 |
| Collectibles | 256.1 | 365.0 | 348.9 | 356.3 | 286.8 | 408.8 |
| Collectibles (%) | 31.2% | 33.1% | 41.8% | 45.1% | 38.7% | 41.0% |
| Adj. EBITDA | n.d. | n.d. | 165.7 | 174.0 | 144.0 | 193.7 |
| Gross profit | 273.4 | 386.8 | 340.3 | 345.0 | 288.2 | 387.4 |
| Gross margin | 33.3% | 35.0% | 40.7% | 43.7% | 38.9% | 38.9% |
| SG&A | −221.4 | −241.9 | −201.6 | −187.1 | −154.8 | −207.9 |
| GAAP EBIT | 41.3 | 135.2 | 143.3 | 160.2 | 133.4 | 179.5 |
| GAAP net inc. | 77.1 | 127.9 | 389.6 | 298.7 | 132.4 | 178.1 |
| Adj. EPS ($) | n.a. | n.a. | $0.28 | $0.30 | $0.22 | $0.30 |
| Consensus EPS | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. | $0.20 | $0.31 |
| Diff. vs cons. | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. | +10.0% | −3.2% |
Source: Company 10-K and 10-Q filings (A); Penmark Research model (E). FY24A–25A have no adjusted net income/EPS or ROIC in the model (GAAP ROE 4.2%/8.1%, GAAP ROA 3.1%/5.1%); Group FCF includes cash interest. Q1 FY26A–Q4 FY26E adjusted EPS and Q3/Q4 FY26E P&L lines allocate H1 ($0.58) and H2 ($1,739.0m sales, $0.52 EPS); Q3/Q4 FY26E collectibles ($286.8m / $408.8m) use H2 FY25A collectibles seasonality (+12.0% y/y each).
H1 FY26 investment marks account for the $343m gap between GAAP and adjusted profit
| Reconciliation line | FY25A | H1 FY26A | H2 FY26E | FY26E | FY27E | FY28E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GAAP operating income (EBIT) | 232.1 | 303.5 | 312.9 | 616.4 | 525.8 | 424.0 |
| (+) Asset impairments / (benefit) & D&A | 68.4 (53.8 + 14.6) | 2.2 (−6.9 + 9.1) | 8.8 | 11.0 | 17.5 | 16.5 |
| Penmark EBITDA (after stock-based comp) | 300.5 | 305.7 | 321.7 | 627.4 | 543.3 | 440.5 |
| (+) Stock-based comp & transformation/other items | 44.9 (26.7 + 18.2) | 34.0 (15.8 + 18.2) | 16.0 | 50.0 | 32.0 | 33.0 |
| Adjusted EBITDA (company definition) | 345.4 | 339.7 | 337.7 | 677.4 | 575.3 | 473.5 |
| GAAP net income / GAAP diluted EPS ($) | 418.4 / $0.77 | 688.3 / $1.17 | 310.5 / $0.52 | 998.8 / $1.68 | 542.8 / $0.90 | 473.7 / $0.84 |
| (−) Net non-operating investment/bitcoin marks (after tax) | n.a. | −342.8 | 0.0 | −342.8 | 0.0 | 0.0 |
| Adjusted net income / Adjusted diluted EPS ($) | n.a. | 345.5 / $0.58 | 310.5 / $0.52 | 656.0 / $1.10 | 542.8 / $0.90 | 473.7 / $0.84 |
Source: Company Q2 FY26 release Schedule II; Penmark Research model. FY25A GAAP net income includes a $131.6m bitcoin loss; the model reports no FY24A–25A adjusted net income. H1 FY26A $18.2m add-back = $2.6m transformation + $15.6m other income; $462.3m pre-tax investment gains ($342.8m after tax) = $434.7m eBay derivative + $72.1m eBay unrealized − $73.9m bitcoin + $29.4m other.
Glossary of company and sector terms
Collectibles: Trading cards (led by Pokémon), PSA grading intake, apparel, toys and pop-culture merchandise; 45.1% of Q2 FY26 net sales.
PSA & Power Packs: Professional Sports Authenticator (Collectors Holdings, led by GME director Nat Turner) grades trading cards; Power Packs are mystery graded packs ($18.3m within FY25’s $39.8m PSA volume).
Code-in-box / digital-only: Physical game boxes holding a download code rather than a disc, or console downloads; neither creates a pre-owned disc.
Customer liabilities: Deferred revenue from gift cards, trade-in credit, loyalty and warranties ($244.9m at 1 Aug 2026).
2028 note puts: Right of 0% convertible-note holders to require cash repayment at par ($1.1bn in Apr 2028; $1.7bn modeled in FY28E).
Notation & ratio definitions
Table notation: n.a. = not available or not applicable; n.d. = not disclosed; n.m. = not meaningful (negative or near-zero denominator).
Retail EV / EBITDA: Diluted market cap ($12,801.7m at $25.36 × 504.8m shares) less net non-operating assets ($6,926.6m) = $5,875.1m retail EV, divided by Penmark EBITDA (after stock-based comp and rent).
ROE, ROA & ROIC: ROE and ROA divide GAAP (FY24A–25A) or adjusted (FY26E+) net income by average equity or assets; model ROIC divides taxed EBIT (25%) by retail invested capital.
P/B conventions: Point-in-time 3-year P/B (1.85x vs 2.65x mean, SD 1.16x) uses filing-date equity and basic shares; summary-table P/B divides $12,801.7m diluted market cap by year-end equity (2.60x FY24A, 2.35x FY25A).
Methodology, peer set & scope
Archetype: Multi-site specialty retailer (about 1,900 US/Australian stores) plus a liquid treasury ($4.7bn cash, $5.1bn eBay stake and $0.3bn bitcoin) and thin coverage.
Fiscal calendar: Fiscal years end near 31 January (FY25 ended 31 Jan 2026; FY26 ends 30 Jan 2027); we use issuer fiscal labels (Q2 FY26 / H1 FY26A).
Peer sets: Six US specialty retailers calendarized to Jan–Feb 2026: low-growth target set (<5% growth: Best Buy 8.94x, Academy 7.26x, Bath & Body Works 4.74x; median 7.26x), growth peers (Five Below 17.99x, Dick’s 8.64x, Ollie’s 15.77x; US median 8.79x) and non-US peers (JB Hi-Fi, Fnac Darty, Currys; 9-peer median 8.94x).
Key boundaries: Category gross margins are model-calibrated to H1 FY26A. Consensus comes from Zacks (FY26E) and MarketBeat (FY27E EPS). May 2026’s $125/sh eBay approach was non-binding, and GameStop holds no earnings calls.
Data sources & cut-off dates
Valuation model: Penmark Research workbook, dated 20 Nov 2026 on 17 Nov 2026 closes ($25.36 GME; $118.59 EBAY; $65,017 bitcoin; 7,348 S&P 500).
Filings & market data: SEC 10-K, 10-Q, 8-K, DEF 14A (filed 22 May 2026; ownership as of 20 May 2026), Form 4, Form 13F (30 Sep 2026 matched filers) and FINRA short interest (30 Oct 2026); Yahoo Finance; Circana (2025 US games) and GemRate/PSA (Jul–Oct 2026).
Analyst certification and important disclosures
Ratings
Ratings are based on the total return from the share price to our 12-month price target, including dividends. The price target is weighted across bull, base and bear scenarios.
| Buy | Total return to price target above +10% |
| Hold | Total return to price target from −10% to +10%, inclusive |
| Sell | Total return to price target below −10% |
We review ratings at each set of results and whenever the facts change materially. A share price can move outside its band before the rating changes, and targets may not be reached.
Analyst certification
The Penmark Team certifies that (1) the views in this report accurately reflect its views about the subject company and its securities, and (2) no part of its compensation was, is or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific ratings, price targets or views in this report.
Contact
Penmark Research
Questions about our research:
research@penmarkresearch.com
All our research and coverage:
penmarkresearch.com
Basis of preparation
This report uses information publicly available up to its publication date. Share prices are closing prices on the trading day before the publication date, unless stated otherwise. Forecasts, valuations and price targets are Penmark Research’s own, and forecast periods are marked E. Sources are shown beneath each exhibit.
Valuation and price targets
Price targets are based on the valuation methods set out in each report and are weighted across bull, base and bear scenarios. The main risks to each rating and price target are described in the report. Penmark Research updates its coverage after each set of results but is not obliged to update a report at any other time.
Independence and conflicts of interest
Penmark Research is independent. It does not provide investment banking, brokerage, market-making or asset management services, does not trade securities, and does not accept payment from any company for research coverage. Companies do not see or review Penmark Research reports before publication.
No member of the Penmark Team holds a long or short position, directly or through derivatives, in the securities of any company Penmark Research covers.
Regulatory status
Penmark Research publishes general, impersonal investment research on a regular basis. It is not registered as an investment adviser with the US Securities and Exchange Commission or any state securities authority, is not a registered broker-dealer and is not a member of FINRA. Penmark Research does not give advice tailored to any person’s circumstances.
Not investment advice or an offer
This report is for information only. It is not personalized investment advice and is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or other financial instrument. It does not take into account any reader’s objectives, financial situation or needs. Readers should make their own investment decisions and seek independent professional advice where appropriate.
Forward-looking statements and risk
Forecasts, valuations and price targets are estimates based on assumptions that may prove wrong, and they may not be achieved. Opinions are current as of the publication date and may change without notice. Investing in equities involves risk, including the loss of capital. Share prices can be volatile, and past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.
Data and sources
Company financials, operating data and filings come from company filings and earnings releases (GameStop holds no earnings calls). Market data and any consensus estimates come from third-party sources named beneath the relevant exhibit; consensus figures from aggregators are unofficial. Penmark Research does not use other brokers’ research. Third-party data belong to their providers and may not be extracted from this report.
Accuracy and liability
Information is taken from sources believed to be reliable, but Penmark Research makes no representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. To the fullest extent permitted by law, Penmark Research accepts no liability for any loss arising from use of this report. Descriptions of litigation and regulatory matters reflect allegations and public records, not findings, unless stated. If a published report is corrected, the corrected version carries an “Updated” date at penmarkresearch.com.
Distribution and access
Penmark Research reports are available to registered users of penmarkresearch.com. Downloads and programmatic access are governed by the Penmark Research subscription terms. This report is not directed at, or intended for, any person in Singapore or India, and access from those countries is blocked. It is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any person in any jurisdiction where that would be contrary to law or regulation or would subject Penmark Research to registration or licensing requirements there.
Copyright and permitted use
© Penmark Research. All rights reserved. Penmark Research is a trade name of Brightriver Labs. Readers may share a link to this report but may not copy, reproduce, redistribute, sell or use its content, including for text and data mining, without written consent. Contact: research@penmarkresearch.com.