Methodology

How we research and rate stocks

Every Penmark report follows the same process and the same structure, so you can see how we reached our view and compare it across companies.

From the business to a value

  1. 1

    Start with the business

    How the company makes money, what drives its growth and margins, and where it stands against its competitors.

  2. 2

    Build the model

    A full financial model with our own forecasts for revenue, margins, earnings and cash flow, compared with consensus estimates and with management’s guidance.

  3. 3

    Value it

    With the method that fits the company, such as a discounted cash flow, earnings multiples or a sum of the parts, cross-checked against its peers.

  4. 4

    Set the value first

    We set our value before we look at the share price, so the price doesn’t anchor the call.

Scenarios and the price target

Each report sets out a bull, a base and a bear case, each with its key assumptions and a value per share. We weight the three by how likely we think they are. The probability-weighted value sets our 12-month price target, and the bear and bull values show the range of outcomes we see.

Ratings

Buy
We expect a total return of more than 10% over the next 12 months: the move to our price target, plus dividends.
Hold
We expect a total return of between −10% and +10% over the next 12 months.
Sell
We expect a total return worse than −10% over the next 12 months: a fall of more than 10%, after dividends.

We set the rating in each report, against the share price on the day it’s published. The price, target and implied return on our pages are as of our latest report, so the return to our target at today’s price may differ. Browse stocks by rating

What every report contains

Deep dives

Initiations of coverage and thematic reports, usually 20 to 40 pages: the business, the competitive position, our forecasts against consensus, the valuation, the scenarios and the risks. Every one opens with the same two pages: the call, the key numbers and the takeaways.

Earnings updates

A three-page update after each company’s results, with the key takeaways first and the numbers against our estimates and consensus, and what changes in our view. Before results, a preview when there’s a call to make.

Keeping research current

A company’s stock page always shows the rating, price target, valuation and estimates from its latest report. When we correct a published report, it shows the date it was updated.

Sources and independence

Our research is built from company filings, results releases and earnings calls, with consensus estimates for comparison. Penmark isn’t part of a bank or a broker. We don’t trade securities, and no one on our team holds positions in the companies we cover.

Sign in to Penmark