GameStop Corp. (NYSE: GME), initiation of coverage, Nov 20, 2026
Peak card profits and a rich store multiple leave GameStop worth about $22
GameStop is now a card and collectibles shop chain sitting on about $14 a share of cash, eBay stock and bitcoin net of its notes. The market prices peak card profits as lasting and pays 12 times profit for shrinking stores; we expect cards to cool.
- Our rating
- Sell
- 12-month target
- $21.90
- Price, Nov 17, 2026
- $25.36
- Expected return, with dividend
- −14%
By Penmark Team
What GameStop is now
Trading cards now drive a shrinking video-game chain sitting on a cash pile
GameStop runs about 1,900 shops in the US and Australia that buy and resell games, consoles and graded trading cards. Collectibles reach 41.6% of FY26E sales, ahead of new games at 36.5% and pre-owned gear at 21.9%.
Cards earn an estimated 54% gross margin against 20% to 25% on new consoles and games. Two-thirds of what the company is worth sits outside its stores, in cash, bitcoin and a 43.4m-share eBay stake.
GameStop’s fiscal year ends near 31 January (FY26 ends 30 January 2027). Source: company filings, Penmark Research estimates.
GameStop’s fiscal year ends near 31 January (FY26 ends 30 January 2027). Source: company filings, Penmark Research estimates.
What you are really buying
Cash and eBay stock cover over half the price; the stores carry the rest
At $25.36 a share, cash, eBay stock and bitcoin less the convertible notes and customer liabilities are worth $13.72. That leaves $11.64 a share, or $5.9bn, as the price of the stores.
We value the stores at $3.6bn, or $7.03 a share, on 7.3 times a normal year’s operating profit. With the same $13.72 of other assets, that gives our base value of $20.76.
Per share on 504.8m diluted shares. The stores are the retail operations’ enterprise value; other assets are net non-operating value. Source: company filings, Penmark Research estimates.
Where we disagree: the store multiple
Shrinking shops deserve about 7 times profit, not the 12 the price implies
Take out the other assets and the price values the stores at 12.0 times a normal year’s operating profit. Peers earn that only when opening stores and growing sales.
Low-growth US chains trade at 4.7 to 8.9 times; Bath & Body Works trades under 5 times despite a 19% margin. Paying 7.3 times instead of 9.4 times on FY26E profit cuts $2.62 a share.
Retail enterprise value divided by mid-cycle EBITDA, after stock compensation; peers on FY25 EV/EBITDA. Source: peer SEC filings, Yahoo Finance, Penmark Research estimates.
Where we disagree: trading cards
Card sales peak this year, leaving next year’s profit 11% below forecasts
Collectibles rose 61% in H1 FY26, and investors treat that as lasting. Pokémon chase cards fell 60% to 75% in the 30 days to November, and H2 laps a base 42% above H1 FY25.
We expect collectibles to fall 12% in FY27E, so our $0.90 earnings per share sits 11% below analysts’ $1.02. Valuing a normal year rather than the peak cuts $1.99 a share.
Adjusted diluted EPS. GameStop’s fiscal year ends near 31 January (FY26 ends 30 January 2027). Analysts’ forecasts: Zacks (FY26E) and MarketBeat (FY27E). Source: Penmark Research estimates.
Where we disagree: deal risk
The cash pile sets a floor, but deals and note repayments tilt risks down
Bulls see the $4.7bn of cash, $5.1bn eBay stake and bitcoin as a free option on deals. GameStop bid $125 a share for eBay in May and raised its authorized shares to 2.5bn.
A stock-funded bid would cost $1.91 a share, and $2.8bn of notes can be put back in 2028. In our bad case the other assets fall to $10.76 a share, while our good case adds only $0.42.
Net non-operating value per share on 504.8m diluted shares; the bad case takes eBay down 15% and a 10% capital-allocation haircut. Source: Penmark Research estimates.
The odds
Downside to our bad case is more than twice the upside to the good
Only our good case sits above today’s price, at $29.64 in 12 months. The middle case gives $22.67 and the bad case $15.45, a fall of 39.1%.
Weighting the three at 20%, 50% and 30% gives our $21.90 target, a 13.6% fall. Even the middle case alone clears our Sell line of a fall of more than 10%.
- Good, 20%Collectibles grow 25% in H2 FY26E and 20% in FY27E, and the eBay stake is sold at the $125 offer.
- Middle, 50%Collectibles grow 12% in H2 FY26E then fall 12% in FY27E, with the stores at 7.26 times profit.
- Bad, 30%Collectibles fall 30% in FY27E, eBay drops 15% and a dilutive deal takes 10% off the other assets.
Circle size shows how likely we think each case is. The target weights all three and rolls forward 12 months at a 9.24% cost of equity. Source: Penmark Research.
What would change our mind
Card sales through next June decide whether the boom has peaked
The next three results show whether card sales are cooling as we expect. Filings on the eBay stake and the notes then show how the cash pile is used.
Two things would move us to Hold: card sales still growing 20% in FY27E, or evidence that the stores deserve more than about 8 times a normal year’s profit.
Card growth should slow toward 12%. We expect sales of $741.5m against analysts’ $722.5m.
The first FY27 profit outlook. A guide below $580m would back our view that cards have peaked.
GameStop laps a 65.0% card jump. We expect collectibles growth to turn negative.
A cash sale near $125 adds $0.42 a share; a stock-funded bid costs $1.91.
Holders can put $1.1bn of 2030 notes back at par if the shares are below $29.85.
Inside the full report
What each page covers after the summary on pages 1 and 2. Each opens the full report at that page.
See all 25 pages
- 3EBITDA margin peaks near 19% in FY26E, and our FY27E EPS is 11% below consensus
- 4GME trades 65% above low-growth peers on mid-cycle EBITDA despite falling sales
- 5Six charts show why we value GME about $5 a share below the price
- 6Three debates explain the $5 gap between the price and our value
- 7A video-game chain now gets 45% of sales from collectibles and holds about $10bn of cash, eBay stock and bitcoin
- 8Collectibles make up 42% of FY26E sales and over half of gross profit across about 1,900 shops
- 9Each dollar of FY26E sales leaves 40 cents of gross profit, 18 cents of EBIT and 19 cents of group FCF (incl. interest)
- 10Content is 86% of $61bn of US game spending; GameStop’s growth now comes from collectibles
- 11GameStop leads on walk-in trade-ins and PSA card intake, but only two of seven moat sources are strong
- 12Ryan Cohen takes no salary, bought $97m of stock in September and October and controls how the cash is used
- 13Share and note sales built a $9.9bn cash pool; $4.3bn went into eBay and none into buybacks
- 14Three drivers move the stock; shares swung twice as much on deal and debt filings as on 10-Qs
- 15Market factors explain only about a tenth of weekly moves; company news drives the rest
- 17Cooling cards pull EBITDA from a $630m peak to mid-cycle, cutting about $2 a share
- 20Weighting bear 30% and bull 20% takes about 70 cents a share off our base value
- 21Group FCF reached about $600m in FY25A (including interest), while investment gains doubled H1 GAAP profit
- 22FY26E adjusted EBITDA of about $680m beats guidance, while FY27E EPS sits 11% below consensus
- 23Group FCF totals $1.7bn in FY26E–28E (including interest), while $2.8bn of note puts cut cash by 40%
- 24Sum of the parts and DCF agree within about 6%, anchoring our $22 target
- 25The price implies 35% collectibles growth in FY27E; neither sensitivity grid reaches $23
- 26Five checkpoints to April 2028 test the card cycle (about +$3 a share) against deal dilution (about −$2)
- 27No single upside risk takes value above about $24; it would take several at once
- 28Index funds and a large retail base support $203m of daily trading as short interest falls 36%
- 29Operating cash flow stays positive through FY30E as EBITDA falls from about $630m to $370m
- 30H1 FY26 investment marks account for the $343m gap between GAAP and adjusted profit
Penmark Research. This summary draws on our initiation report on GameStop Corp., published Nov 20, 2026. It is not investment advice. Analyst certification, rating definitions and important disclosures are in the full report.