DTE Energy Co. (NYSE: DTE), initiation of coverage, Nov 9, 2026
DTE’s data-center growth and a held 9.9% return are not in the price
DTE is a Michigan electric and gas utility whose earnings grow with the assets regulators let it build. At 17.6 times next year’s earnings it trades below peers, though data centers lift its growth above theirs.
- Our rating
- Buy
- 12-month target
- $155.16
- Price, Nov 6, 2026
- $135.08
- Expected return, with dividend
- +19%
By Penmark Team
What DTE is now
A Michigan utility whose earnings grow with the grid regulators let it build
DTE supplies electricity to 2.3m customers and gas to about 1.4m in southeast Michigan. Its electric business earned $1,217m of operating earnings last year, 80% of the total.
Regulators set the return, so earnings grow with the assets DTE invests in, called rate base. We expect it to rise from $32.2bn to $53.5bn by 2029, helped by data centers.
Operating earnings are non-GAAP, before corporate and other costs of $264m. Source: company filings, Penmark Research.
Rate base is the net plant on which regulators allow a return. Source: company filings, Penmark Research estimates.
What you are really buying
The price misses about $15 of value, mostly the multiple and the Michigan order
Our middle-case value is $149.91 a share, $14.83 above the $135.08 price. Three disagreements with the market explain $13.05 of that gap.
The biggest is the multiple: we pay the peer median of 18.4 times earnings, not 17.6. Then a February rate order that holds the 9.9% return, and faster data-center growth. The price implies DTE earns only 8.9% on equity.
Each step flexes one debate alone in our model; other is the unassigned gap. Source: Penmark Research estimates.
Where we disagree: the multiple
DTE grows faster than its peers, so it deserves at least their multiple
DTE trades at 17.6 times next year’s earnings against 18.4 for five peer utilities, even though it guides to 9% yearly growth against their 7.5%.
Michigan bills rose 12.5% from 2021 to 2026, against 29.4% nationally, leaving room for rate increases. Investors apply a Michigan discount that we think the growth premium offsets. Paying the peer median is worth $6.44 a share.
Times earnings is the P/E on FY27E operating EPS at 6 Nov 2026 prices. Source: company guidance, Yahoo Finance, Penmark Research model.
Where we disagree: the February order
We expect Michigan to keep DTE’s allowed return at 9.9% in February
DTE asked for $474m of higher electric rates. Commission staff backs a 9.90% return, the level since 2023, while the Attorney General seeks only $134.5m.
The market prices a quarter-point cut, worth $146.19 a share. We expect 9.9% held and the data-center tariff approved, worth $3.72 more, at 75% odds. The last gas order granted only 46% of the request.
Allowed return is the electric return on equity set in the rate order. Source: S&P Global, Michigan Attorney General, Penmark Research model.
Where we disagree: data-center growth
Data centers push earnings growth above 11% in 2028, past the 9% floor
Oracle, with 1.4 GW, and Google, with 1.0 GW, are approved, and Oracle ramps in 2027. A third deal of about 2 GW is in our base, at 60% odds.
We expect earnings per share to rise 11.2% to $8.51 in 2028 and 12.2% in 2029. The market holds growth at the 9% floor, so our path is worth $2.90 a share.
Operating EPS is non-GAAP. The 9% floor applies 9% growth to the $7.66 FY27 guidance midpoint, as analysts’ forecasts rebased. Source: company guidance, Penmark Research estimates.
The odds
Only the bad case, a cut allowed return, sits below today’s price
Our middle case, 50% likely, holds the 9.9% return and signs a third data-center deal: $149.91. The good case, 30% likely, edges the return to 10.0% at a peer-high multiple: $162.92.
The bad case, 20% likely, cuts the return to 9.6% with no third deal: $122.21. Weighted, they give $148.27, which rolls to our $155.16 target, 14.9% above the price.
- Good, 30%The allowed return edges to 10.0%, Oracle arrives on schedule and shares are issued 5% higher; 19.6 times 2028 earnings of $8.70: $162.92.
- Middle, 50%The 9.9% return holds and a third data-center deal joins the plan; 18.4 times 2028 earnings of $8.51: $149.91.
- Bad, 20%The return is cut to 9.6%, there is no third deal and shares are issued 15% lower; 16.7 times 2028 earnings of $7.65: $122.21.
Circle size shows how likely we think each case is. The target weights all three and adds 12 months of expected return. Source: Penmark Research.
What would change our mind
Higher bond yields or a cut allowed return would move us to Hold
Conviction is low. A 1-point higher cost of equity, with 10-year yields near 5%, gives $119.36 and a Hold. So does a 9.6% allowed return with the tariff rejected, at $122.21.
No case reaches Sell. The February order is the one dated test, and a third data-center deal by June 2027 would confirm the growth path. Watch the 10-year yield monthly.
The last gas order gave DTE 46% of what it asked, a guide to the commission’s mood.
A 9.9% return held with the tariff approved confirms our view; 9.6% or below breaks it.
About $3bn of proceeds retire $2bn of parent debt.
A deal of about 2 GW adds $4.5bn of capex; none by June 2027 disproves our growth case.
Inside the full report
What each page covers after the summary on pages 1 and 2. Each opens the full report at that page.
See all 19 pages
- 3EPS growth of 11.2% in FY28E is 2.2pp above the 9% guidance floor, and the P/E sits 4% under peers despite faster guided growth
- 4The cost of equity decides the rating, and the stock yields 0.7 sigma more than its own history
- 5Rates set the stock; rate base, data centers and a 9.9% ROE set the value, and the target sits 14.9% above price
- 6We are on the other side of the market on four debates; three are worth $13.05 of the $14.83 gap to base value
- 7DTE is a rate-base compounder: regulators set the return, so earnings grow with capital invested
- 8Earnings are rate base times earned ROE: 9.9% on the 50% equity share of a $35.8bn base gives $1.77bn in FY28E
- 9Michigan is the market: regulators, 2.4 GW of new load and bills 17pp below the US trend set the growth runway
- 10DTE has no direct competitors in its franchise; the threats are the regulator and utilities that win data centers faster
- 11Capex is 88% of $63bn of uses; debt and equity fund 43%, so shares rise 15% by FY31E
- 12The stock trades on rates and the utility sector first; data centers and the February order are what we think it is missing
- 13Yields move the price now; data-center demand dominates the questions; the order is the one dated test
- 17Net income compounded 12.7% a year to $1,462m, but free cash flow has been negative and the gap to operating EPS has widened
- 18Our forecasts follow the guided path with one addition, the third data-center deal; cost of equity matters most to value
- 19Base value is $149.91 on 18.4x FY28E EPS; the dividend model gives $130.20, and the 13% gap is within tolerance
- 20The target of $155.16 is the weighted value of $148.27 rolled forward; the price implies an 8.9% earned ROE
- 21Seven dated events decide the call; the order and the 10-year yield each move value by $9-14 a share
- 22Ten funds hold 51% and the Street is split; $1bn a year of new equity is the overhang
- 23Operating earnings rise from $1,524m to $2,643m by FY31E while debt rises from $26.0bn to $48.1bn
- 24Operating EPS is $0.33 above reported EPS in FY25A; the model, method and sources are set out below
Penmark Research. This summary draws on our initiation report on DTE Energy Co., published Nov 9, 2026. It is not investment advice. Analyst certification, rating definitions and important disclosures are in the full report.