Summary

Buy, $155 target: the data-center step-up and a held 9.9% ROE are not in the $135 price

InitiationBy Penmark Team
DTEBuy$155.16+15%
Page 1 of 25
Equity research | Initiation of coverage | United States
Utilities: regulated electric and gas | Coverage: initiated | Published 9 November 2026, 08:00 ET
Penmark Team | research@penmarkresearch.com
DTE Energy Co. (NYSE: DTE)

Buy, $155 target: the data-center step-up and a held 9.9% ROE are not in the $135 price

Rating
Initiation
Buy
12-month target
$155.16
Price, 6 Nov 2026
$135.08
Upside to target
+14.9%
Total return
+18.6%
Bull case
$162.92
Bear case
$122.21

We initiate on DTE Energy at Buy, low conviction, with a $155 target: +14.9% upside to target, +18.6% with dividends. DTE is a Michigan electric and gas utility whose earnings equal rate base × equity share × earned ROE. At 17.6x FY27E EPS it trades below the 18.4x peer median.

  • Data-center load lifts FY28E EPS 11.2% to $8.51. Oracle (1.4 GW) and Google (1 GW) are approved; the market extends 6.9%. Worth $2.90 a share.
  • A Feb 2027 order holding the 9.9% ROE is worth $3.72 a share. Staff backs 9.90%; we give a cut 25% odds.
  • The multiple is the swing, worth $6.44 a share. DTE trades at 17.6x FY27E against 18.4x for peers; a 10-year yield of 4.86% (6 Nov spot) caps it.

What the market is missing. Rebased on the $7.66 guide, FY28E consensus is $8.35, not July's $8.90; our $8.51 is 1.9% above. The price implies an 8.9% earned ROE against 9.9% allowed.

Catalysts. Michigan electric order (Feb 2027); third ~2 GW data-center deal (60% odds by Jun 2027); Vantage sale close (1H 2027).

Valuation and target. 18.4x FY28E EPS gives bull $162.92 (30%), base $149.91 (50%), bear $122.21 (20%). Weighted value $148.27 is +9.8% above the price; a Buy needs 5.1%. Cost of equity +1pt or beta 0.85 gives Hold.

Risks. ROE cut or LLTM rejected (−$9, 25%); yields near 5% (−$13.7, 35%); AI capex pullback (−$4.5, 20%).

Exhibit 1: EPS grows from $7.36 to $9.56 by FY29E as rate base rises 66%; the Vantage sale holds FY27E flat
US$m, Dec year-endFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29E
Utility rate base, US$bn32.235.740.646.653.5
Operating earnings1,5241,6111,6261,8702,169
Net income, FY26E PF1,4622,3511,6261,8702,169
Operating EPS ($)7.367.737.668.519.56
Growth y/y7.8%5.1%−1.0%11.2%12.2%
Dividend per share ($)4.434.664.995.315.66
Capex4,4296,7707,9409,54010,940
Free cash flow(1,020)(2,870)(3,555)(4,432)(5,010)
At $135.08FY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29E
P/E18.4x17.5x17.6x15.9x14.1x
P/B2.3x2.0x1.9x1.8x1.6x
FCF yield−3.6%−10.2%−12.6%−15.8%−17.8%
Dividend yield3.3%3.4%3.7%3.9%4.2%
Payout ratio60%60%65%62%59%
ROE12.7%12.3%11.2%11.5%11.9%
Net debt / equity2.1x1.9x2.0x2.0x2.1x
P/E at our $155 target21.1x20.1x20.3x18.2x16.2x

Source: Company filings; Signals; Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026. Operating EPS and earnings are non-GAAP; FY24A operating EPS of $6.83 per company release. Shaded columns are estimates. FY26E net income is pro forma (PF): it assumes the Vantage sale at 31 Dec 2026 (close expected 1H 2027; GAAP gain falls in FY27). ROE is operating earnings over average equity. No EV/EBITDA row: free cash flow is negative through FY31E. Ratios in Exhibits 8-9.

Base case is worth $149.91, +11.0% on the price: $27.84 of upside against $12.87 of downside, 2.2x

Exhibit 3: Weighted value rolls to the $155.16 target; only the bear case is below the $135.08 price
$120$130$140$150$160$170$180Jan-26Jul-26Jan-27Jul-27ActualEstimatesPrice $135.08Bull $170.49 (+26%)Base $156.87 (+16%)Bear $127.89 (−5%)Target $155.16 (+15%)

Source: Yahoo Finance, Signals; Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026. Scenario values are at 6 Nov 2026 and rolled 12 months at 4.65% (cost of equity less dividend yield).

Scenarios and price target basis
Bull$162.92+20.6%30% prob.

Allowed ROE edges to 10.0%; Oracle on schedule; equity issued 5% higher; 19.6x peer-high P/E on FY28E EPS $8.70.

Base$149.91+11.0%50% prob.

9.9% ROE held; third data-center deal in plan ($4.5bn capex); 18.4x peer-median P/E on FY28E EPS $8.51.

Bear$122.21−9.5%20% prob.

ROE cut to 9.6%; no third deal; equity issued 15% lower; 16.7x CMS multiple on FY28E EPS $7.65.

Probability-weighted value$148.27+9.8%
Upside to downside2.2x$27.84 up / $12.87 down
Exhibit 4: Operating earnings rise 42% to $2,169m by FY29E on Electric, offset by Vantage
US$mFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29E
DTE Electric1,2171,3401,5011,7712,112
DTE Gas295318339362383
DTE Vantage162200000
Energy Trading11458555555
Corporate, other(264)(305)(269)(318)(381)
Operating earnings1,5241,6111,6261,8702,169
Gain on Vantage sale–740–––
Net income (FY26E pro forma)1,4622,3511,6261,8702,169
Exhibit 5: Free cash flow stays negative to FY31E; debt and equity fund the plan
US$mFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29E
Cash from ops3,4093,9004,3855,1085,930
Capex(4,429)(6,770)(7,940)(9,540)(10,940)
Free cash flow(1,020)(2,870)(3,555)(4,432)(5,010)
Dividends(871)(971)(1,058)(1,166)(1,284)
Equity issued–1001,0001,1001,100
Vantage sale proceeds–2,750–––
Net debt issued–8833,6144,4985,194
FFO to debt–16.1%15.3%15.4%15.5%
Exhibit 6: Debt rises to $40.2bn by FY29E while FFO to debt holds near 15%
US$mFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29E
Cash208100100100100
Utility net PP&E32,20836,42842,26249,40857,600
Total assets54,06657,16463,29870,74479,236
Debt26,02326,90630,52035,01740,211
Parent debt9,9199,05910,23211,72913,484
Deferred tax, ITC3,4004,1345,0876,2327,545
Total equity12,30813,78915,35617,16019,145
Closing shares (m)207.7208.5215.7223.2230.3
Exhibit 7: Rate base grows 11–15% a year; the Vantage exit, not dilution, holds FY27E EPS at $7.66
Per share, KPIsFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29E
Diluted shares (m)207.0208.3212.3219.6226.9
Operating EPS ($)7.367.737.668.519.56
Reported EPS (FY26E pro forma)7.0311.297.668.519.56
Dividend/share ($)4.434.664.995.315.66
Book value/share ($)59.2566.1471.2176.8983.12
Rate base, US$bn32.235.740.646.653.5
Rate base growth–10.8%13.7%14.8%14.8%
Electric ROE–9.88%9.73%9.90%10.11%

Source: Company filings (10-K, 10-Q Q3 FY26); Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026. Operating basis (non-GAAP) unless stated; FY26E net income and EPS are pro forma: Vantage sale assumed 31 Dec 2026 with a $740m gain; close expected 1H 2027, GAAP gain falls in FY27. Reported EPS FY26E-29E is net income over diluted shares. Shaded columns are estimates (E). Bold = totals and thesis lines; italic = ratios and memo lines.

EPS growth of 11.2% in FY28E is 2.2pp above the 9% guidance floor, and the P/E sits 4% under peers despite faster guided growth

Exhibit 8: Rate base grows 11–15% a year to FY29E while earned ROE stays near the 9.9% allowed
%FY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29E
Growth y/y
Utility rate base–10.8%13.7%14.8%14.8%
Utility capex––29.7%20.2%14.7%
Operating earnings–5.7%0.9%15.0%16.0%
Operating EPS7.8%5.1%−1.0%11.2%12.2%
Dividend per share6.9%5.1%7.0%6.5%6.5%
Allowed and earned returns
Electric allowed ROE9.90%9.90%9.90%9.90%9.90%
Electric earned ROE–9.88%9.73%9.90%10.11%
Gas allowed ROE–9.80%9.80%9.80%9.80%
Gas earned ROE–9.30%9.30%9.30%9.30%
Payout ratio60%60%65%62%59%
Exhibit 9: Credit holds at 15% FFO to debt; the P/E falls from 17.6x to 14.1x on FY29E
RatiosFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29E
Returns and credit
ROE, operating12.7%12.3%11.2%11.5%11.9%
ROA, operating3.0%2.9%2.7%2.8%2.9%
Net debt / equity2.1x1.9x2.0x2.0x2.1x
FFO to debt–16.1%15.3%15.4%15.5%
Parent debt, US$bn9.99.110.211.713.5
Valuation at the $135.08 price
P/E, operating18.4x17.5x17.6x15.9x14.1x
P/B2.3x2.0x1.9x1.8x1.6x
FCF yield−3.6%−10.2%−12.6%−15.8%−17.8%
Dividend yield3.3%3.4%3.7%3.9%4.2%
P/E at our $155 target21.1x20.1x20.3x18.2x16.2x

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026. FY25A allowed ROE is the DTE Electric order (9.9% since 2023). ROE and ROA on operating earnings over average equity and assets. Multiples at the 6 Nov 2026 close except the last row. A regulated utility has no EBITDA or gross margin line that drives value; earned versus allowed ROE does. Shaded columns are estimates (E).

Exhibit 10: Penmark is 4.4% below stale July consensus on FY28E EPS, but 1.9% above it rebased to $8.35
US$FY26EFY27EFY28E
Operating EPS ($)
Penmark estimate7.737.668.51
Consensus (July, stale)7.718.338.90
Consensus, rebased7.717.668.35
Prior-year period7.367.737.66
Diff. vs July+0.3%−8.0%−4.3%
Diff. vs rebased+0.3%0.0%+1.9%
Growth y/y
Penmark+5.1%−1.0%+11.2%
Consensus (July)+4.8%+8.0%+6.9%
Gap, pp+0.3pp−9.0pp+4.3pp
Exhibit 11: DTE trades 4% below the peer P/E and 23% below peers on PEG
Current priceDTEPeersDiff.
Valuation
P/E FY26E17.5x20.1x−13%
P/E FY27E17.6x18.4x−4%
PEG, FY27E P/E / LT growth1.96x2.55x−23%
Growth and returns
LT EPS growth guided9.0%7.5%+1.5pp
Dividend yield, trailing3.5%3.0%+0.5pp
12-month price return+0.7%+4.6%−3.9pp
Peers: FY27E P/E, LT growth, vs DTE P/E
CMS16.7x7.0%+5%
XEL18.0x7.0%−2%
WEC19.2x7.5%−8%
AEE19.6x7.7%−10%
AEP18.4x9.0%−4%

Source: Zacks, Barchart, KeyCorp (consensus, Jul 2026; FY27 consensus predates the 5 Nov 2026 rebase; FY28 extends it by 6.9%). Rebased consensus is the $7.66 FY27 guidance midpoint × 1.09 (the 9% guidance floor) = $8.35 FY28E; company guidance 5 Nov 2026; Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research model. Peers: CMS, XEL, WEC, AEE, AEP; peer FY27E EPS is guidance midpoint grown at the long-term rate. Difference in % for multiples and PEG, pp for ratios.

The cost of equity decides the rating, and the stock yields 0.7 sigma more than its own history

Exhibit 12: Five dated catalysts in the next 15 months
  • Nov 2026DTE files another gas rate case (notice given 10 Sep 2026); the last gas order gave 46% of the request.
  • Feb 2027Michigan electric order on the $474m request: we expect the 9.9% ROE held; no consensus.
  • By Jun 2027Third ~2 GW data-center deal: in our base capex ($4.5bn), 60% standalone odds; consensus none.
  • 1H 2027Vantage sale closes (~$3bn); $2bn of parent debt retired. In company baseline.
  • Late 2027Multiyear rate-plan legislation; ROE pressure from FY29 priced at 30% odds.

Source: Company Q3 FY26 release and call, 5 Nov 2026; Penmark Research.

Exhibit 13: Three risks cost $4.50-13.70 a share; a 1pt higher cost of equity turns Buy into Hold
  • Feb 2027 order cuts ROE or rejects the large-load tariff. Gas order gave DTE 46% of its request. Likelihood 25%; −$9.00/share.
  • Yields near 5% de-rate utilities. 10-year at 4.84% after a 5.36% peak; equity issued 15% lower. Likelihood 35%; −$13.70/share.
  • AI capex pullback delays Oracle. Earned spread lags 0.3pt in FY28E. Likelihood 20%; −$4.50/share.
  • Against our Buy: cost of equity +1pt or beta 0.85. Hold; upside −6.6% or −2.1%.

Source: Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026; values per share at the price date.

Exhibit 14: Dividend yield of 3.45% is 0.7 sigma above its five-year mean of 3.23%
2.0%2.5%3.0%3.5%4.0%4.5%20222023202420252026Mean 3.2%; bands ±1σ, ±2σ3.5%

Source: Yahoo Finance; weekly, Nov 2021 to Nov 2026. Mean 3.23%, sigma 0.31pp.

Exhibit 15: Peers pay 0.5x of P/E per point of growth (R² 0.12), and DTE sits 1.4x below the line
16x17x18x19x20x7.0%7.5%8.0%8.5%9.0%P/E on FY27ELong-term EPS growth, % a yearDTECMSXELWECAEEAEPR² 0.12, n=5

Source: Company guidance; Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research model. Five peers, DTE excluded from fit; no uncovered global competitors included.

Exhibit 16: Five indicators confirm or break the thesis
IndicatorThesis confirmed ifThesis broken ifDate
DTE Electric allowed ROEOrder holds 9.9% and approves the large-load mechanismROE set at 9.6% or below, or a new case is forced in 2027Feb 2027
Third data-center agreement~2 GW signed by Jun 2027, adding $4.5bn capex FY28-31Load signs with a faster utility; no deal in 2027Jun 2027
Oracle 1.4 GW rampLoad energised on schedule; spread lag near 0.4ptRamp slips; earned spread 0.3pt worse in FY28E2027
FY27 operating EPSInside the $7.59-7.73 guide; our $7.66Below $7.59 after Vantage closeFeb 2028
10-year Treasury yield (6 Nov spot 4.86%)Back below 4.5%; equity issued at or above $139Above 5%; issue price 15% lower12 months
What would change our viewCost of equity +1pt (10-year near 5%) or beta 0.85 turns the Buy into Hold. A 9.6% ROE with the tariff rejected leaves $122.21, −5.3% to target: also Hold. No case reaches Sell.

Source: Company filings and guidance; Penmark Research.

PART 1 · SUMMARY · 3 THE THESIS IN CHARTS

Rates set the stock; rate base, data centers and a 9.9% ROE set the value, and the target sits 14.9% above price

Exhibit 17: The stock moves inversely to the 10-year yield: correlation -0.90 over six months
DTE share price ($)10-year Treasury yield (%, right)$120$130$140$150$1604.24.44.64.85.05.25.4May-26Jul-26Sep-26Nov-26

Source: Yahoo Finance; weekly closes, May to Nov 2026. Level correlation -0.90.

Exhibit 18: Rate base grows from $32.2bn to $53.5bn by FY29E, 13.5% a year
$0bn$20bn$40bn$60bnFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29EActualEstimates$32.2bn$35.7bn$40.6bn$46.6bn$53.5bn

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026. Rate base proxy is DTE Electric net plant plus calibrated Gas.

Exhibit 19: 2.4 GW is contracted (bars in GW); a third 2 GW deal is in our base case and not in the plan
Oracle, approvedGoogle, approvedThird deal, advanced talks1.41.02.0

Source: DTE Q3 FY26 call and deck, 5 Nov 2026. Further pipeline of 5-6 GW not in the base case.

Exhibit 20: We are 4.4% below stale July consensus on FY28E but 1.9% above it rebased to $8.35
Consensus (July, stale)Rebased consensus$0$2$4$6$8$10FY26EFY27EFY28E$7.73$7.66$8.51

Source: Zacks, Barchart, KeyCorp (Jul 2026); July FY27 predates 5 Nov rebase. Rebased: $7.66 × 1.09 = $8.35 FY28E. Penmark model.

Exhibit 21: DTE trades at 17.6x FY27E EPS, below four of five peers
AEEWECAEPXELDTECMS19.6x19.2x18.4x18.0x17.6x16.7x

Source: Company guidance; Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research model. Prices 6 Nov 2026.

Exhibit 22: $14.83 between price and base value: $13.05 comes from three debates
$0$50$100$150PriceFeb orderMichigandiscountFY28step-upOtherBasevalue$135.08+$3.72+$6.44+$2.90+$1.78$149.91

Source: Penmark Research model, Market Check tab, 8 Nov 2026. Other is the unassigned gap.

Exhibit 23: P/E expansion carried the 3-year return; dividends carried the last year
EPS growthP/E changeDividends−40−200204060801 year3 years5 years45036

Source: Yahoo Finance; reported EPS, last four quarters (Signals). Points of total return: 4.2%, 50.2%, 36.3%.

Exhibit 24: Buy rests on 14.9% upside; cost of equity +1pt or beta 0.85 gives Hold
What supports the BuyWhat moves it to Hold
Feb 2027 order holds 9.9% ROE and the tariff: +$3.72Order cuts ROE to 9.6% or lower: $122.21, −5.3% to target
Third ~2 GW deal: in base capex, 60% odds, +$110-year above 5%: cost of equity +1pt gives $119.36, −6.6%
Price below $134.13, the bottom of our value rangeBeta 0.85, top of utility betas: $125.52, −2.1%

Source: Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026 (Market Check, Sensitivities).

PART 1 · SUMMARY · 4 KEY DEBATES

We are on the other side of the market on four debates; three are worth $13.05 of the $14.83 gap to base value

The rating turns on the February 2027 order and on yields. Each debate maps to one thesis chapter and one stock driver in section 9.

Exhibit 25: We differ from the market on four debates; three are worth $13.05 a share
DebateMarket viewPenmark viewEvidenceWhat would change our viewResolves
1. FY28 step-upEPS growth at the +9% floor of guidance; consensus FY28E $8.90 (6.9%)+11.2% to $8.51; FY29E +12.2%Rate base +14.8% in FY28E; Oracle 1.4 GW ramps 2027; guide "well above 9%" for 2028-29Oracle ramp slips; FY28 growth below 9%Feb 2028
2. Michigan discountDTE deserves 17.6x FY27E P/E, 0.8x under the peer median18.4x, the peer median; growth premium offsets the Michigan discountGuided growth 9% vs peer 7.5%; electric bills +12.5% since 2021 vs 29.4% USOrder cuts ROE; commission signals affordability limitsFeb 2027
3. February 2027 orderAllowed ROE trimmed by 25bp on a $474m request9.9% ROE held; large-load tariff approvedStaff backs 9.90%; 9.9% since 2023; Attorney General seeks $134.5mROE set at 9.6% or below; tariff rejectedFeb 2027
4. Yields and equity10-year near 5% de-rates utilities; $1bn a year of equity dilutes8.34% cost of equity is priced; +1pt gives $119.36, upside to target −6.6%: HoldStock-to-yield correlation -0.90 over six months; 5-year yield mean 3.23% vs 3.45% now10-year above 5% for a quarter12 mths

Source: Company Q3 FY26 call and deck, 5 Nov 2026; Zacks, Barchart, KeyCorp consensus; Michigan Attorney General, Aug 2026; Penmark Research model.

Exhibit 26: Our view adds $2.90 to $6.44 a share on each debate
Market viewPenmark viewMichigan discountFebruary 2027 orderFY28 step-up$143.47$149.91$146.19$149.91$147.01$149.91

Source: Penmark Research model, Market Check tab, 8 Nov 2026. Base value at price date; each debate flexed alone.

How the debates map to the thesis

Three debates sit in two chapters. Debate 1 is chapter 1, data-center load ($2.90). Debates 2 and 3 are chapter 2, the Michigan order ($6.44 and $3.72; $10.15 unrounded). Debate 4 is chapter 3, yields and financing, where the downside sits.

Why conviction is low

The debates add up to $13.05 of a $14.83 gap; weighted value is 9.8% above the price against 5.1% needed for a Buy. A 20% bear case at $122.21 and yields near 5% thin the margin.

Exhibit 27: Four of five dated events resolve by mid-2027; the gas filing comes first, in November
Nov 2026Gas rate case filedNotice given 10 Sep 2026Feb 2027Michigan electric order$474m request; debates 2and 31H 2027Vantage sale closes$2bn parent debt retiredJun 2027Third deal: goal Dec 2026,our 60% by JunDebate 1Feb 2028FY27 results, FY28 guideDebate 1 resolves

Source: DTE Q3 FY26 call, 5 Nov 2026; Penmark Research. Dates for the order and results are approximate (month stated by the company).

PART 2 · BUSINESS · 5 HOW THE COMPANY MAKES MONEY

DTE is a rate-base compounder: regulators set the return, so earnings grow with capital invested

Earnings equal average rate base times equity share times earned return, divided by shares. Everything below is built from that equation.

Exhibit 28: DTE earns 80% of operating profit on a rate base of $32.2bn that regulators let it grow

1 Customers

2.3melectric customers, SE Michigan~1.4mgas customers (company)2.4 GWcontracted data-center load: Oracle 1.4, Google 1.0

2 Offerings

Electricgeneration and distribution; 7.6 GW renewables, 2.1 GW gas, 2.7 GW storage plannedGasdistribution to ~1.4m homes and businessesVantage, Tradingrenewable gas, power and gas marketing

3 Operating earnings, FY25A

DTE Electric $1,217m80% of operating earningsDTE Gas $295m19% of operating earningsDTE Vantage $162m11% of operating earningsEnergy Trading $114m7% of operating earningsCorporate and other -$264m

4 Channels

Regulated tariffsMichigan commission sets rates and 9.9% / 9.8% allowed ROELarge-load contractsdata-center customers pay incremental grid costRate cases$474m electric order due Feb 2027

5 Cost to serve, FY25A

$11.6bnfuel, power, operations: 73% of $15.8bn revenue$1.8bndepreciation, 12%$1.1bninterest, 7%$4.4bncapex, above $3.4bn operating cash flow

6 What is left

$1,462mreported net income, 9.2% of revenue$7.36operating EPS, $7.03 reported$871mdividends paid-$1.0bnfree cash flow, funded by debt and equity

Source: Company filings (10-K FY25; Q4 FY25 and Q3 FY26 calls); Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026. Segment earnings are operating (non-GAAP); revenue by segment is not used.

Exhibit 29: Five numbers set the earnings path: rate base, allowed ROE, plan, load and credit
$32.2bn+10.8% FY26EUtility rate base FY25A9.9%unchanged since 2023Electric allowed ROE$44.2bnmodel $48.7bn with thirddealUtility capex FY27-312.4 GW2 GW more in advancedtalksContracted data-centerload15.4%target about 15%FFO to debt FY28E

Source: Company filings and Q3 FY26 deck; Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026.

Exhibit 30: Of each $100 of revenue, $15 is operating income and $9 reaches shareholders
Revenue $15,814m$15,814mOperating income$2,374m$2,374mOther income $232m$232mPre-tax pool $2,606m$2,606mFuel, power, operations $11,599m$11,599mDepreciation $1,841m$1,841mInterest $1,056m$1,056mTax $88m$88mNet income $1,462m$1,462m

Source: Company 10-K FY25 (via Signals); FY25A reported GAAP. Other income is the balance between operating income less interest and tax and net income.

PART 2 · BUSINESS · 5 HOW THE COMPANY MAKES MONEY

Earnings are rate base times earned ROE: 9.9% on the 50% equity share of a $35.8bn base gives $1.77bn in FY28E

Exhibit 31: FY28E operating EPS of $8.51 is rate base times 9.9% ROE, less dilution from $1.1bn of new equity
Avg rate base$35.8bnEquity share50%Earned ROE9.90%DTE Electric$1,771mAvg rate base$7.8bnEarned ROE9.3%DTE Gas$362mTrading less corporate-$263mOperating earnings$1,870mOpening shares215.7mEquity issued$1,100m at $146Diluted shares219.6mOperating EPS FY28E$8.51

Source: Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026 (Rate Base, Earnings, Financial Statements tabs). Highlighted boxes are the stock drivers in section 9.

Exhibit 32: Electric earnings double to $2.4bn by FY30E as electric rate base grows 12-17% a year
DTE Electric operating earnings, $mElectric rate base growth, % (right) (right)$0m$500m$1,000m$1,500m$2,000m$2,500m121314151617FY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EActualEstimates

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026. FY25A rate base growth not modelled.

Exhibit 33: Utility capex rises from $6.1bn to $10.9bn; the third deal adds $4.5bn
Electric and Gas, company plan basisThird data-center deal$0m$2,500m$5,000m$7,500m$10,000m$12,500mFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31E

Source: Company Q3 FY26 deck (US$44.2bn FY27-31 plan); Penmark Research model. Model utility capex FY27-31 $48.7bn including the third deal.

Why customers pay

Electricity and gas are regulated monopolies, so volume matters less than capital invested. The commission sets rates to recover costs plus a return on rate base; residential bills rose 12.5% from 2021 to 2026 against 29.4% for the US average (company deck).

Cash versus profit

Operating cash flow of $3.4bn funds under half of $4.4bn of FY25 capex. Free cash flow stays negative to FY31E, so debt and equity fill the gap.

Fixed against variable cost

Fuel and purchased power pass through to customers; the fixed base is depreciation ($1.8bn FY25A, 5.9% of opening rate base in the model) and interest ($1.1bn). Earnings therefore track return on equity, not sales.

PART 2 · BUSINESS · 6 THE MARKET: REGULATION AND LOCAL DEMAND

Michigan is the market: regulators, 2.4 GW of new load and bills 17pp below the US trend set the growth runway

Exhibit 34: DTE earns its return in generation, grid and gas delivery, where regulators set a 9.9% ROE
Fuel and purchased powerPass-through to customersNo marginGenerationDTE: 7.6 GW solar, wind;2.1 GW gas; 2.7 GWstorage plannedEarns ROE on rate baseGrid and distributionDTE Electric, ~2.3mcustomers$35.8bn average ratebase FY28EGas deliveryDTE Gas, ~1.4m customers$7.8bn average rate baseFY28ECustomersHomes, business, datacenters2.4 GW large loadcontractedAllowed ROE 9.9% electric, 9.8% gas, on 50% equity

Source: DTE Q3 FY26 deck and call, 5 Nov 2026; Michigan Public Service Commission; Penmark Research model.

Exhibit 35: Contracted data-center load is 2.4 GW against a 5-6 GW pipeline
Contracted (Oracle,Google)Advanced talksPipeline beyond plan,midpoint2.42.05.5

Source: DTE Q3 FY26 call, 5 Nov 2026. Pipeline is 5-6 GW beyond the plan and includes the 2 GW in advanced talks; midpoint 5.5 GW shown.

Exhibit 36: Michigan bills rose 12.5% in 2021-26 against 29.4% nationally, leaving room for rates
US averageDTE residential29.412.5

Source: DTE Q3 FY26 deck, p9 (residential bill growth, 2021 to 2026, %).

Exhibit 37: Q3 FY26 electric sales were 13.6m MWh; the contracted load starts to ramp from 2027
13.6m MWhincl. interconnection salesDTE Electric sales Q3 FY269.84%DTE 9.9%US average allowed ROE 1H2630+order Feb 2027Intervenors in electric case20322026 resource planPlanned end of coal use

Source: Signals (Q3 FY26); company 2026 integrated resource plan; S&P Global (Sep 2026) for allowed ROE.

Demand and cycle

Load growth, not weather, is the cycle. Contracted data-center load of 2.4 GW and a 5-6 GW pipeline drive a plan that is nearly $10bn larger than the last one. The AI-capex cycle is the risk: Bear 3 (Oracle ramp delayed) costs $4.50 a share at 20% odds.

Regulation and threats

One commission sets 80% of earnings. The February 2027 order on a $474m request will test the 9.9% ROE and the large-load tariff; the Attorney General wants $134.5m, 71% less. Legislation on multi-year rate plans (Bear 5, $2.00 a share, 30%) is likely toward end 2027.

Exhibit 38: The Attorney General backs $134.5m of a $474.3m electric request
DTE requestAttorney General position$474.3m$134.5m

Source: DTE newsroom, 2026; Michigan Attorney General, 28 Aug 2026. A recommendation, not an order; MPSC decision expected late Feb 2027.

Exhibit 39: DTE's 9.9% electric ROE sits 6bp above the US average; the request is 10.25%
DTE requestDTE Electric allowedUS average 1H26DTE Gas allowed10.259.909.849.80

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model, Assumptions tab; S&P Global (Sep 2026). ROE in %; MPSC order U-21973 (gas), 10 Sep 2026.

PART 2 · BUSINESS · 7 COMPETITIVE POSITION

DTE has no direct competitors in its franchise; the threats are the regulator and utilities that win data centers faster

Exhibit 40: DTE guides 9% growth, tied with AEP and 1.5pp above the peer median
AEPDTEAEEWECXELCMS9.09.07.77.57.07.0

Source: Company guidance (CMS, XEL, WEC, AEP); Zacks (AEE); Penmark Research model, Peers tab. Long-term EPS growth, % a year.

Exhibit 41: DTE pays the second-highest yield, 3.45% against a 3.00% median
CMSDTEWECAEPXELAEE4.083.453.243.002.952.62

Source: Yahoo Finance, trailing dividend yield at 6 Nov 2026 close; Penmark Research. Percent.

Exhibit 42: DTE lags peers by 3.9pp over 12 months despite faster guided growth
AEEAEPWECDTEXELCMS+10.6+5.9+4.6+0.7−1.1−4.4

Source: Penmark Research model, Peers tab; prices 6 Nov 2025 to 6 Nov 2026, % price return.

Exhibit 43: On growth, DTE should trade near AEP; it trades 0.8x below at 17.6x
16x17x18x19x20x7.07.58.08.59.0P/E FY27ELT EPS growth, % a yearDTEAEEWECAEPXELCMS

Source: Company guidance; Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research model. No fitted line: five peers, R-squared 0.12 (Exhibit 15).

Exhibit 44: DTE leads on franchise, affordability and load; the balance sheet and regulator are the weak links
Source of advantageEvidence that it lastsRank
Exclusive franchise~2.3m electric and ~1.4m gas customers in Southeast Michigan; no competing distributorStrong
Allowed return9.9% electric ROE since 2023 vs 9.84% US average; gas 9.8%At par
AffordabilityResidential bills +12.5% 2021-26 vs +29.4% US average, so room for rate casesStrong
Large-load wins2.4 GW contracted (Oracle, Google); customers pay incremental grid costStrong
Balance sheetFFO to debt 15.4% FY28E vs ~15% target; $44bn plan funded with $1bn a year of equityThin
Regulatory climateGas order U-21973 granted 46% of the request; 30+ intervenors in the electric caseWatch

Source: Company filings and Q3 FY26 deck; Michigan Public Service Commission; S&P Global (Sep 2026); Penmark Research. Rank is a Penmark judgement.

The competitor is the regulator and the alternative is a faster-moving utility, not another distributor. Customers cannot switch; data-center load can. Bear 4 ($1.00 a share at 40% odds) is the 2 GW pipeline landing with a utility in another state. Behind-the-meter supply is the substitute, so the large-load tariff in the February order matters.

Counter-evidenceDTE trails peers by 3.9pp over 12 months and yields 0.45pp above their median: the market may be pricing risk, not missing growth.
PART 2 · BUSINESS · 8 MANAGEMENT, GOVERNANCE AND CAPITAL ALLOCATION

Capex is 88% of $63bn of uses; debt and equity fund 43%, so shares rise 15% by FY31E

Exhibit 45: Capex is 88% of $63bn of uses; debt and equity fund 43%
Operating cash $32,897m$32,897mVantage sale $2,750m$2,750mNet new debt $22,030m$22,030mNew equity $5,100m$5,100mCash drawn $108m$108mFunds FY26E-31E $62,886m$62,886mCapex $55,470m$55,470mDividends $7,416m$7,416m

Source: Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026 (Financial Statements tab), six forecast years FY26E-FY31E. FY25A capex is in Exhibit 5.

Exhibit 46: Dividend per share grows 7% in 2027 then 6.5%, with payout held near 60%
Dividend per share ($)Payout ratio, % (right)$0$2$4$6$85860626466FY26EFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31E$4.66$4.99$5.31$5.66$6.02$6.41

Source: Company Q3 FY26 deck (+7% in 2027); Penmark Research model. Payout on operating EPS.

Exhibit 47: FY26E EPS of $7.73 is at the top of guidance; Vantage runs above its range
ActualGuidanceConsensusOperating EPS, $Vantage earnings, $mElectric earnings, $m$7.73 vs guide $7.59–$7.73$200 vs guide $180–$190$1,340 vs guide $1,340–$1,360

Source: Company Q3 FY26 deck, 5 Nov 2026; Penmark Research model. Consensus Zacks. The company reports meeting or beating guidance in 18 of 19 years.

Record and pay

Management has met or beaten EPS guidance in 18 of 19 years and FY25 operating EPS of $7.36 finished above the top of the range (Q4 FY25 call). Our base case sits inside every guide except Vantage and the $4.5bn third data-center deal.

Insiders

Insider activity is small and routine. The Vice Chairman sold 5,000 shares ($678,560) on 1 Sep 2026 and an officer sold 1,000 shares at $143.72 on 14 May 2026; other filings are director grants of 294 shares at $123.27 (Signals Form 4 data).

Capital allocation

The plan is funded by borrowing and about $1bn a year of new shares. Diluted shares rise from 207m to 239m by FY31E (+15%) while rate base doubles; we model issuance at the price grown at the cost of equity less yield. The $3bn Vantage sale cuts the equity need by about $1bn and parent debt by $2bn.

Governance

Dilution, not control, is the governance question. The largest holders are index and long-only funds with no controlling shareholder (section 18).

PART 2 · BUSINESS · 9 WHAT MOVES THE STOCK

The stock trades on rates and the utility sector first; data centers and the February order are what we think it is missing

We tested eight candidates with four tests and kept three drivers. Each links to a numbered debate (section 4) and ends with a number to watch.

Exhibit 48: Rates and the sector explain most of the move; data centers and the order explain most of the debate
DriverWhat moves the stockTests confirmedMarket reaction vs our model valueDebateNext number to watch
A. Rates and the utility sector10-year yield and the XLU index; earnings matter less3 of 4: factor, event-day, decompositionStock 0.9 weekly beta to XLU; price implies 16.6x vs our 18.4x: $14.83 gap2, 410-year at 4.86% (6 Nov spot); each +0.5pt of cost of equity is -$15.95
B. Data-center loadContracted GW and the capex plan behind FY28-29 EPS2 of 4: call Q&A, decomposition (EPS +8.6pp over 3 years)Market at +9% growth floor: $147.01; we say $149.91, +$2.901Third ~2 GW deal by Dec 2026 (our 60% by Jun 2027)
C. Michigan order and ROEAllowed ROE and the large-load tariff2 of 4: call Q&A, event-day (weak)Market at ROE -25bp: $146.19; we say $149.91, +$3.723Feb 2027 order: ROE 9.9% held (staff 9.90%)

Source: Yahoo Finance (prices, XLU, 10-year, Nov 2023 to Nov 2026); Signals earnings-call transcripts (8 calls); Penmark Research model, Market Check tab.

Exhibit 49: DTE moved with XLU on results days; the average move was 1.3%, 0.96pp from the sector
DTEXLU−20+2+4Q4 24Q1 25Q2 25Q3 25Q4 25Q1 26Q2 26Q3 26

Source: Yahoo Finance; results-day close-to-close %, 13 Feb 2025 to 5 Nov 2026. Correlation with XLU 0.70, R-squared 0.50.

Exhibit 50: The market underprices each driver by $2.90 to $6.44 a share
Market viewModel valueA. Target P/E 17.6x vs18.4xB. FY28 step-up, +9% vs11.2%C. Order ROE -25bp vs9.9%$143.47$149.91$147.01$149.91$146.19$149.91

Source: Penmark Research model, Market Check tab, 8 Nov 2026. Base value at price date, each debate flexed alone; price $135.08.

Exhibit 51: Four tests: the sector and yield carry the variance, data centers carry the questions
67%157 weeks, Nov 2023-Nov 2026Weekly variance explained by XLU-0.906-month price levelCorrelation with 10-year yield54%57 analyst paragraphs, 8 callsQuestions on data centers+28.3ppEPS growth +8.6ppP/E change in 3-year total return

Source: Yahoo Finance; Signals call transcripts; Penmark Research.

DTE trades on rates and the sector, not on its own earnings. The S&P 500 explains 0.03% of weekly variance, XLU 67%. Over three years P/E change added 28.3pp of a 50.2% total return while EPS growth added 8.6pp (Exhibit 23). The earnings story is real but unpriced, which is why conviction on our $155.16 Buy is low: the model's gap to price is $14.83, but the stock does not close it on EPS alone.

PART 2 · BUSINESS · 9 WHAT MOVES THE STOCK (CONTINUED)

Yields move the price now; data-center demand dominates the questions; the order is the one dated test

Exhibit 52: XLU explains 67% of weekly variance; the S&P 500 explains none
SPY only10-year yield onlyXLU onlySPY + XLU + yield<1136770

Source: Yahoo Finance; 157 weekly returns, 6 Nov 2023 to 2 Nov 2026; R-squared in %.

Exhibit 53: 54% of analyst questions on eight calls touch data centers; 5% touch rates
Data centers, large loadRegulation, ROEVantage, tax creditsCapital plan, EPSFinancing, equityRates, macro54282323215

Source: Signals call transcripts; 57 analyst paragraphs on the Q1 FY25 to Q3 FY26 calls, coded by topic (multi-topic allowed); % of paragraphs.

Driver A: rates and the sector

The stock is a bond proxy this year. The 6-month correlation with the 10-year yield is -0.90: DTE fell from $154.43 to $135.08 as the yield rose from 4.37% to 4.86% (6 Nov spot). The dividend yield of 3.45% is 0.7 sigma above its five-year mean. Our model says each +0.5pt of cost of equity is worth -$15.95 and a -0.5pt move +$20.11 (weighted value). Debate 4. Next: the 10-year, 4.86% at the 6 Nov spot; above 5% takes value toward $120 and the rating to Hold.

Driver B: data-center load

Contracted load drives the FY28-29 step-up. 54% of questions concern it; 3-year EPS growth added 8.6pp to returns, the rest of the 50.2% coming from P/E and dividends. The market holds growth at the +9% floor ($147.01); we model 11.2% and $149.91, +$2.90, with the third 2 GW deal in base capex at +$1.00 and 60% standalone odds. Debate 1. Next: a third agreement by Dec 2026; consensus FY28E $8.90 against our $8.51 is a rebase gap, not a miss.

Driver C: the Michigan order

The ROE decision is the one dated event. 28% of questions, and the Q3 FY26 results day (-1.93%, -1.22pp vs XLU) followed a call centred on the February order. The market prices ROE -25bp ($146.19); we say 9.9% held, +$3.72 at 75% odds. Debate 3. Next: the Feb 2027 order; a 9.6% ROE leaves $122.21 (bear).

LimitsEight results days and 157 weekly points are short samples; transcripts are coded by Penmark and are not a statistical survey. Driver C passes only weakly and is kept because it carries the dated catalyst. Factor R-squared describes the past three years, not causation.
Exhibit 54: Five candidates fail the tests, including the market factor most investors assume matters
Candidate droppedTest resultReason
S&P 500 (market)R-squared 0.03% on 157 weekly returnsNo explanatory power
Weather2 of 57 questions; no results-day linkFails all tests
Vantage sale, RNG and tax credits13 of 57 questions; closes 1H 2027, in the FY27 baselineEvent, not a driver
Multi-year rate plans2 of 57 questions; legislation likely end 2027Too early to test
Coal and gas plants2 of 57 questionsFails all tests

Source: Yahoo Finance; Signals call transcripts; Penmark Research.

PART 3 · THE THESIS · 10 THREAD ONE: DATA-CENTER LOAD
THE CLAIM · RESTS ON DRIVER BData-center load makes FY28-29 the growth years: EPS up 11.2% and 12.2%, above the 9% floor

What the market believes

Consensus FY28E of $8.90 is 6.9% growth on a $8.33 FY27 that predates the 5 Nov rebase. At $135.08 the price implies 16.6x our FY28E EPS, or an earned ROE of 8.9% against the 9.9% allowed.

The evidence

  • Reported data. Oracle 1.4 GW and Google 1.0 GW are approved, 2.4 GW contracted; Oracle ramps in 2027 and Google reaches full load by end 2028
  • Company statements. Plan up nearly $10bn to $44.2bn; EPS growth well above 9% in 2028-29; 31 of 57 analyst questions are on data centers
  • Model. Rate base rises from $32.2bn to $53.5bn by FY29E; earned ROE 9.90% in FY28E
Exhibit 55: EPS growth of 11.2% in FY28E and 12.2% in FY29E clears the 9% guidance floor
−5051015FY26EFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31E5.1−1.011.212.28.76.5Guide floor 9%

Source: Company Q3 FY26 call (growth 'well above 9%' in 2028-29, 'at least 9%' 2030-31); Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026.

Exhibit 56: We are 4.4% below stale July consensus on FY28E and 1.9% above it rebased to $8.35
Operating EPS, $FY26EFY27EFY28E
Penmark7.737.668.51
Consensus (July, stale)7.718.338.90
Consensus, rebased7.717.668.35
Guidance midpoint7.667.66>9% growth
Growth, Penmark+5.1%−1.0%+11.2%
Growth, July consensus+4.8%+8.0%+6.9%

Source: Zacks, Barchart, KeyCorp (Jul 2026), July FY27 predates the 5 Nov rebase; FY28 extends it by 6.9%. Rebased: $7.66 × 1.09 = $8.35 FY28E. Penmark Research model.

What it is worth

Moving from the +9% floor to our 11.2% is worth +$2.90 a share (debate 1). A third 2 GW deal adds $4.5bn of capex and +$1.00, at 60% odds, and is outside the company plan.

Signposts

  • Dec 2026. Third deal signed (company goal) confirms; none by Jun 2027 disproves
  • Feb 2027. Q4 FY26 results and 2027 guide confirm the $7.66 base
  • Feb 2028. FY27 results: FY28 guide above 9% confirms
Exhibit 57: Rate base growth of 14.8% a year in FY28-29E is diluted by 3.3-3.5% share growth in FY28-29E
Utility rate base growth, %Diluted share growth, % (right)05101501234FY26EFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30E1114151512

Source: Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026 (Rate Base, Earnings tabs).

Exhibit 58: The third deal would add 2.0 GW, more than either approved contract
Oracle 1.4 GWGoogle 1.0 GWThird deal ~2 GW1.41.02.0

Source: DTE Q3 FY26 call; Penmark Research model. Third deal capex $4.5bn FY28-31 outside plan; value +$1.00 a share at 60% odds.

Strongest evidence againstEquity issuance lifts shares 3.5% in FY28E, so operating earnings growth of 15.0% becomes EPS growth of 11.2%; if the Oracle ramp slips, Bear 3 costs $4.50 a share (20% odds).
PART 3 · THE THESIS · 11 THREAD TWO: THE MICHIGAN ORDER
THE CLAIM · RESTS ON DRIVER CThe February 2027 order holds the 9.9% ROE and approves the large-load tariff: worth $3.72 a share, at 75% odds

What the market believes

The market prices a 25bp ROE trim, which gives $146.19. Michigan has cut requests before: the gas order gave DTE 46% of what it asked.

The evidence

  • Regulatory filings. Staff backs 9.90%; the Attorney General seeks $134.5m of the $474.3m request, a 71% cut, but a recommendation is not an order
  • History. Electric ROE has been 9.9% since 2023, 6bp above the 9.84% US average; a gas ROE of 9.8% was set on 10 Sep 2026
  • Call statements. Management sees early indications positive on the large-load mechanism and a stay-out
Exhibit 59: Each 25bp of allowed ROE is worth $3.72 a share; a 50bp cut leaves $142.47
$0$50$100$150$200−50bp−25bpBase 9.9%+25bp+50bp$142.47$146.19$149.91$153.62$157.34Price $135.08

Source: Penmark Research model, Sensitivities tab, full re-runs, 8 Nov 2026; other inputs held.

Exhibit 60: Three signals favour 9.9%, but the last two orders gave 42% and 46%
SignalReadingDirection
Commission staffBacks 9.90% ROE (S&P)Holds
Allowed ROE history9.9% since 2023; US avg 9.84%Holds
Attorney GeneralSeeks $134.5m of $474.3mCuts
Gas order U-2197346% granted, 9.8% ROECuts
Last electric order (Feb 2026)$242.4m of $574.1m requested, 42%Cuts

Source: S&P Global (Sep 2026); Michigan Attorney General, 28 Aug 2026; MPSC order U-21973, 10 Sep 2026; company Q3 FY26 call.

What it is worth

Our base holds 9.9% from FY27E; the order alone is +$3.72 against the market view. If ROE falls to 9.6% with the tariff rejected, value is $122.21 (Bear 1, -$9.00).

Signposts

  • Nov 2026. Gas case filed; end 2027 multi-year plan law
  • Feb 2027. Order: 9.9% held and tariff approved confirms; 9.6% or below disproves
  • 2027. Oracle ramp covers the stay-out through 2028
Exhibit 61: A 20% bear case holds weighted value to +9.8% over price; a Buy needs 5.1%
$0$50$100$150$200$122.21$149.91$162.92Bear20%Base50%Bull30%Weighted $148.27

Source: Penmark Research model, Scenarios tab; values at price date. Weighted $148.27.

Exhibit 62: The bear case ROE of 9.6% costs $9.00 a share at 25% odds; the bull case adds $3.72
Bull 1: 9.9% held, tariffBear 1: ROE trimmed, tariffrejected+3.72−9.00

Source: Penmark Research model, Thesis tab: Bull 1 75% probability; Bear 1 25%.

Strongest evidence againstThe Attorney General argues existing cost allocation may let data-center costs shift to other customers, and the commission granted only 46% of the gas request; a 9.6% ROE is a live outcome, not a tail.
PART 3 · THE THESIS · 12 THREAD THREE: RATES AND FINANCING
THE CLAIM · RESTS ON DRIVER AYields cap the multiple: at a 4.84% 10-year the 8.34% cost of equity gives 18.4x, and 1pt more gives a Hold

What the market believes

At $135.08 the stock yields 3.45%, above its five-year mean, and the correlation with the 10-year is -0.90 over six months. The market already treats DTE as a bond proxy.

The evidence

  • Market data. Weekly returns: XLU explains 67% of variance, the yield 13%, the S&P 500 none (157 weeks)
  • Filings and guidance. Equity of about $1bn a year FY27-31 and FFO to debt of about 15%; dividend +7% in 2027
  • Model. FFO to debt 15.4% in FY28E and parent debt $11.7bn; free cash flow negative to FY31E
Exhibit 63: Weighted value falls from $148.27 to $132.32 per 0.5pt of cost of equity, and to $119.36 at +1pt
$0$50$100$150$2007.34%7.84%8.34% base8.84%9.34%$195$168$148$132$119

Source: Penmark Research model, Market Check tab (probability-weighted value, target P/E moves with the cost of equity), 8 Nov 2026.

Exhibit 64: The 10-year sits at 4.86%, 0.5pt below its 5.36% peak; DTE's yield is 0.7 sigma above its mean
IndicatorNowReference
10-year Treasury, 6 Nov spot4.86%12m range 4.1-5.36%; model 4.84%
DTE dividend yield3.45%5-yr mean 3.23%
Cost of equity8.34%Beta 0.70, ERP 5.0%
Beta, regression0.38Blume-adjusted 0.59
Equity issued FY27-31$5.0bn~$1bn a year

Source: Yahoo Finance (10-year 4.86% at 6 Nov close); FRED (4.84% on 5 Nov, used in the model); Penmark Research model, Assumptions tab.

What it is worth

A 1pt higher cost of equity gives $119.36 (upside to target −6.6%, a Hold); 1pt lower gives $194.52 (weighted value basis). The base uses beta 0.70 against a 0.38 regression, so the rate cushion is built in.

Signposts

  • Monthly. 10-year above 5% for a quarter breaks the thesis; below 4.5% confirms
  • 2027. Vantage closes, $2bn parent debt retired
  • Feb 2028. FY27 FFO to debt at or above 15%
Exhibit 65: New equity of $0.9-1.1bn a year lifts shares 15% by FY31E
$0m$250m$500m$750m$1,000m$1,250mFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31E$100m$1,000m$1,100m$1,100m$900m$900m

Source: Company Q3 FY26 deck (about $1bn a year FY27-31); Penmark Research model.

Exhibit 66: FFO to debt holds at 15.2-16.1%, around the 15% target
15.0015.2515.5015.7516.0016.25FY26EFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31E15.2Target ~15%

Source: Company Q3 FY26 deck (target about 15%); Penmark Research model, Financial Statements tab.

Strongest evidence againstThe rating is sensitive: cost of equity +1pt or beta 0.85 gives Hold (upside to target −6.6% and −2.1%); cost of equity −1pt, beta 0.59 or the base case alone keep the Buy. That is why conviction is low.
PART 4 · NUMBERS · 13 TRACK RECORD AND QUALITY OF REPORTED NUMBERS

Net income compounded 12.7% a year to $1,462m, but free cash flow has been negative and the gap to operating EPS has widened

Exhibit 67: Revenue swings with fuel costs; net income grew 12.7% a year to $1,462m
Revenue, $mNet margin, % (right) (right)$0m$5,000m$10,000m$15,000m$20,000m4681012FY21AFY22AFY23AFY24AFY25A

Source: Company 10-K FY21-FY25 (via Signals). Reported (GAAP).

Exhibit 68: Reported EPS rose 10.8% a year to $7.03; return on equity at 11-13%
Diluted EPS, reported, $ROE, reported, % (right)$0$2$4$6$811.011.512.012.513.0FY21AFY22AFY23AFY24AFY25A$4.67$5.52$6.76$6.77$7.03

Source: Company 10-K FY21-FY25 (via Signals); ROE is net income over average total equity, Penmark calculation. FY21 not shown (no FY20 equity).

Exhibit 69: Operating EPS runs $0.06-0.33 above reported EPS; the FY26E gap is the $740m Vantage gain
Per share, $FY24AFY25AFY26E pro forma
Operating EPS6.837.367.73
Reported (GAAP) EPS6.777.0311.29
Gap: operating less reported0.060.33−3.56
Gap, % of reported0.9%4.7%−31.5%

Source: Company Q4 FY24 and Q4 FY25 releases; 10-K; Penmark Research model. FY26E reported is model net income of $2,351m over 208.3m shares and includes the $740m gain on the Vantage sale, assumed at 31 Dec 2026; close is expected 1H 2027 and the GAAP gain falls in FY27.

Exhibit 70: Operating cash flow covers 77% of capex in FY25A and 58% in FY26E
Cash from operationsCapex$0m$2,000m$4,000m$6,000m$8,000mFY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EActualEstimates

Source: Company 10-K (via Signals); Penmark Research model. FY24-25 capex and operating cash flow as reported.

Exhibit 71: Four accounting choices flatter earnings; the largest is the low tax rate on tax credits
ChoiceWhat it doesSize
Operating vs reportedOperating EPS excludes non-recurring items and mark-to-market$0.33 in FY25A
Tax creditsIncome tax of $88m is 5.7% of pre-tax income vs 25% marginal in the modelAbout $1.4 per share vs 25%
AFUDC on capexCapital cost earned before assets enter rate base lifts earned ROE$44m above allowed ROE FY29E
Rate base proxyNet plant stands in for commission rate baseGas base calibrated

Source: Company 10-K FY25 (income tax and net income via Signals); Penmark Research model, Methodology and Earnings tabs. Tax effect is a Penmark calculation: pre-tax income of about $1,550m at 25% less $88m, over 207m shares.

Reported earnings are clean but flattered by credits; cash is the weak point. Net income has compounded 12.7% a year, yet free cash flow was negative $0.9bn in FY24A and $1.0bn in FY25A. Debt rose from $18.2bn to $26.0bn over FY21-25 while equity rose from $8.7bn to $12.3bn. The gap between operating and reported EPS widened from $0.06 to $0.33, which is why we value on operating EPS but model reported net income separately.

PART 4 · NUMBERS · 14 FORECASTS

Our forecasts follow the guided path with one addition, the third data-center deal; cost of equity matters most to value

Exhibit 72: Our base sits inside every company guide except Vantage and the $4.5bn third-deal capex
MetricGuidancePenmarkWhy we differ
Operating EPS FY26$7.59-7.73$7.73Top of range; company expects the high end
Pro forma EPS FY27$7.59-7.73$7.66At the $7.66 midpoint after Vantage
EPS CAGR FY27-31At least 9%9.6%Above 9%, below 12% cap
Electric earnings FY26$1,340-1,360m$1,340mAt the low end
Vantage earnings FY26$180-190m$200mYear to date already above range
Utility capex FY27-31$44.2bn$48.7bnAdds $4.5bn third deal (60% odds)
External equity FY27-31About $5bn$5.0bnIn line
FFO to debtAbout 15%15.4% FY28EIn line

Source: Company Q3 FY26 release, deck and call, 5 Nov 2026; Penmark Research model, Guidance tab.

Exhibit 73: Value per share is most sensitive to the cost of equity: $119.36 at +1pt, $194.52 at -1pt
Cost of equity +/-1ptTarget P/E +/-1xElectric allowed ROE+/-50bpFY28E EPS +/-$0.40Base $149.91−$30.55+$44.61−$8.14+$8.13−$7.44+$7.43−$7.05+$7.04

Source: Penmark Research model, Scenarios and Sensitivities tabs, 8 Nov 2026; cost-of-equity bar is on probability-weighted value ($148.27 base), the others on base value ($149.91); other inputs held.

Exhibit 74: Funding need is $5-6bn a year from FY27E: debt covers 80%, equity 20%
Net debt issued, $mEquity issued, $m$0m$2,000m$4,000m$6,000m$8,000mFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31E

Source: Penmark Research model, Financial Statements tab, 8 Nov 2026.

Exhibit 75: Operating earnings reach $2,643m in FY31E; Electric supplies 102% as Gas, Trading and corporate net out
US$mFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31E
DTE Electric1,3401,5011,7712,1122,4212,683
DTE Gas318339362383403422
Corporate and other(305)(269)(318)(381)(455)(517)
Operating earnings1,6111,6261,8702,1692,4242,643
Diluted shares, m208.3212.3219.6226.9233.3238.8
Operating EPS, $7.737.668.519.5610.3911.07

Source: Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026. Vantage ($200m FY26E) and Trading ($55-58m) are in operating earnings but omitted here; they sum to the total.

Costs and margins

Costs are mostly pass-through, so margin is the allowed return. Fuel and purchased power recover from customers; depreciation runs at 5.9% of opening rate base. Interest on parent debt of $9.1bn rising to $15.7bn takes corporate cost from $269m in FY27E to $517m by FY31E.

Cash and balance sheet

Free cash flow is negative to FY31E, so FFO to debt is the constraint. Cash from operations rises from $3.9bn to $7.0bn; capex peaks at $10.9bn in FY29E; FFO to debt stays at 15.2-16.1% only with $5bn of equity.

PART 4 · NUMBERS · 15 VALUATION

Base value is $149.91 on 18.4x FY28E EPS; the dividend model gives $130.20, and the 13% gap is within tolerance

Exhibit 76: Every method but the dividend model lands above the $135.08 price; the target is $155.16
P/E on FY28E, bear to bullP/E on FY28E, target P/E ±1xDividend discount modelCost of equity ±0.5pt, weightedThesis rangeStreet targets (15 analysts)$120$140$160$180$122$163$142$158$130$132$168$134$164$135$168Price $135Target $155

Source: Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026 (Valuation, Scenarios, Thesis tabs); Street targets from Yahoo Finance (Oct 2026), mean $148.03. Values at price date except the target.

Exhibit 77: Value is $142.86 to $156.95 across ±$0.40 of FY28E EPS at 18.4x
$127$130$134$137$140$135$138$142$145$148$143$146$150$153$157$151$154$158$162$165$158$162$166$170$174FY28E EPS$8.11$8.31$8.51$8.71$8.91Target P/E16.4x17.4x18.4x19.4x20.4x

Source: Penmark Research model, Scenarios tab, closed form, base case; base value $149.91 is the centre.

Exhibit 78: DTE is the cheapest peer on FY27E after CMS, and has the second-highest dividend yield
CompanyP/E FY26P/E FY27ELT growthYield12m return
DTE17.5x17.6x9.0%3.45%+0.7%
CMS Energy17.9x16.7x7.0%4.08%−4.4%
Xcel Energy19.3x18.0x7.0%2.95%−1.1%
WEC Energy20.6x19.2x7.5%3.24%+4.6%
Ameren21.1x19.6x7.7%2.62%+10.6%
AEP20.1x18.4x9.0%3.00%+5.9%
Peer median20.1x18.4x7.5%3.00%+4.6%

Source: Company guidance; Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research model, Peers tab; prices 6 Nov 2026. Peer FY27E EPS is FY26 guidance midpoint grown at long-term growth.

Why these two methods

A utility is valued on earnings and dividends, not free cash flow. The primary method is P/E on FY28E operating EPS, $8.51 at the peer-median 18.4x, discounted 12 months at 4.65% (8.34% cost of equity less 3.69% dividend yield) to $149.91. The cross-check is a dividend discount model at 8.34% cost of equity, giving $130.20. We reject EV/EBITDA and a free-cash-flow DCF because cash flow is negative through FY31E on a $44bn plan.

The 13% gap

The dividend model is 13.1% below the P/E value, inside our 15% tolerance. 67% of it is terminal value, and a 4.0% terminal growth rate with a 6.5% dividend growth path understates a company growing earnings 9.6% a year to FY31E.

PART 4 · NUMBERS · 15 VALUATION (CONTINUED)

The target of $155.16 is the weighted value of $148.27 rolled forward; the price implies an 8.9% earned ROE

Exhibit 79: DDM value of $130.20: 67% comes from terminal value after FY36
$0$50$100$150PV dividendsFY27-36PV terminal valueDDM value+$43.21+$87.00$130.20

Source: Penmark Research model, Valuation tab. Dividends $4.99 FY27E to $8.19 FY36E; terminal growth 4.0%, cost of equity 8.34%.

Exhibit 80: From base value to the $155.16 target: weighting costs $1.64, the 12-month roll adds $6.89
$0$50$100$150$200Base valueProbabilityweightingWeightedvalue12-monthrollTarget$149.91−$1.64$148.27+$6.89$155.16

Source: Penmark Research model, Valuation tab. Roll factor 1.0465 = 1 + 8.34% cost of equity − 3.69% dividend yield; the 12-month discount rate is 4.65%.

Exhibit 81: Bull, base and bear tie to the three drivers: the order, data centers and rates
CaseValueProb.FY28E EPSP/EWhat has to happen
Bull$162.9230%$8.7019.6xROE 10.0%, Oracle on schedule, ITCs safe-harboured to 2029 (driver C, B)
Base$149.9150%$8.5118.4xROE 9.9% held, third deal signs, FY28-29 on plan (all drivers)
Bear$122.2120%$7.6516.7xROE 9.6%, no third deal, equity issued 15% lower as yields rise (A, C)
Weighted$148.27100%Weighted value +9.8% on price; upside to target +14.9%: Buy

Source: Penmark Research model, Scenarios tab, 8 Nov 2026. Probabilities are Penmark judgements: company has met or beaten EPS guidance in 18 of 19 years; staff backs 9.90% ROE. They carry no statistical confidence interval. Catalyst odds are standalone; scenario weights bundle outcomes (e.g. a 25% ROE-cut chance sits partly in the 20% bear and partly in the base).

Exhibit 82: The price implies 16.6x FY28E EPS, or an earned ROE of 8.9% against the 9.9% allowed
16.6xmodel target 18.4xPrice-implied P/E on FY28E8.9%allowed 9.9%Implied FY28E electric earned ROE−1.0ptFY27E-31E, full re-runImplied earned-spread shift$135.08error 0%Plug-back value

Source: Penmark Research model, Market Check tab, 8 Nov 2026 (reverse valuation; plug-back reproduces the price).

Exhibit 83: Upside to target is −5.3% in the bear case, +16.1% in the base and +26.2% in the bull: weighted +14.9%
Bear (20%)Base (50%)Bull (30%)Probability-weighted−5.3+16.1+26.2+14.9

Source: Penmark Research model, Scenarios tab, 8 Nov 2026. Scenario value rolled 12 months against $135.08; Buy above +10%, Sell below -10%.

What the price implies

The market pays for an earned ROE of 8.9%, 1.0pt below the allowed 9.9%. That is the bear case on returns without the bear case probability: Michigan would have to cut ROE and deny the tariff for the price to be right.

Reconciling to page 1

The $155.16 target is the $148.27 weighted value rolled forward 12 months. Weighted value is +9.8% above the price against 5.1% needed for a Buy; upside to target is +14.9%, above the +10% line. Catalyst odds are standalone; scenario weights bundle outcomes (a 25% ROE-cut chance sits partly in the 20% bear, partly in the base).

PART 4 · NUMBERS · 16 CATALYSTS AND 17 RISKS

Seven dated events decide the call; the order and the 10-year yield each move value by $9-14 a share

Exhibit 84: Seven dated events in the next 15 months decide the rating; the gas filing comes first, then the February order
Nov 2026Gas rate case filedNotice given 10 Sep 2026Dec 2026Third data-center dealPenmark 60% by JunFeb 2027Michigan electric orderPenmark: 9.9% ROE held1H 2027Vantage sale closesPro forma baseline $7.662027Oracle 1.4 GW rampPenmark: on scheduleLate 2027Multi-year plan bill30% ROE riskFeb 2028FY27 resultsPenmark EPS $7.66

Source: DTE Q3 FY26 call and deck, 5 Nov 2026; Penmark Research model. Month-level dates are company statements; day placement is illustrative.

Exhibit 85: Four upside catalysts are worth $1.00 to $3.72 a share each; the $7.00 Vantage close is already in base value
EventDatePenmark vs consensus$/shareOdds
Vantage sale closes, $2bn debt retired1H 2027In baseline; consensus predates rebase+7.00 (in base)90%
Order holds 9.9% ROE and tariffFeb 2027Penmark 9.9%; market prices −25bp+3.7275%
Oracle 1.4 GW ramps on schedule2027On schedule+3.0075%
ITC safe harbour through 20292027-29Not in consensus+1.8080%
Third ~2 GW deal signedJun 2027In base capex; market 0%+1.0060%

Source: Penmark Research model, Thesis tab (bull catalysts 1-5), 8 Nov 2026. Odds are Penmark judgements and standalone, not scenario weights. Next number to watch for drivers A-C is in section 9.

Exhibit 86: Five downside risks cost $1.00 to $13.70 a share; a 1pt higher cost of equity turns Buy into Hold
RiskLikelihood$/shareEvidence
Rising yields de-rate utilities; equity issued lower35%−13.7010-year 4.86%; correlation −0.90 with DTE
Order trims ROE or rejects large-load tariff25%−9.00Gas order gave 46% of request
AI capex pullback delays Oracle ramp20%−4.5054% of call questions on data centers
Michigan moves to performance-based multi-year plans30%−2.00Legislation likely end 2027
2 GW pipeline lands with faster utilities40%−1.00No contract signed yet
Against our Buy: cost of equity +1pt or beta 0.85Overlaps Bear 2$119.36 / $125.52Upside to target −6.6% / −2.1%: Hold

Source: Penmark Research model, Thesis tab (bear catalysts 1-5), 8 Nov 2026. Likelihoods are Penmark judgements and carry no confidence interval.

Exhibit 87: Next numbers to watch: each driver has a date, our estimate and a likely move
DriverNext numberDatePenmarkConsensusLikely move
A. Rates10-year Treasury yieldMonthlyBelow 4.9%n/a±$16 per 0.5pt
B. Data centersThird ~2 GW agreementDec 2026Signed (60% by Jun 2027)None priced+$1.00
C. Michigan orderAllowed electric ROEFeb 20279.9%−25bp priced+$3.72 / −$9.00
FY27 EPSOperating EPSFeb 2028$7.66$8.33 (stale)Guide at midpoint

Source: Penmark Research model, Market Check and Thesis tabs, 8 Nov 2026; consensus Zacks, Barchart (Jul 2026).

What would end the thesisA February order at 9.6% ROE or below with the tariff rejected leaves $122.21 (Bear 1). Cost of equity +1pt leaves $119.36, a Hold. Regulatory risk is the main one; ESG matters through the 2032 coal exit and its rate-base cost.
PART 4 · NUMBERS · 18 OWNERSHIP AND TRADING

Ten funds hold 51% and the Street is split; $1bn a year of new equity is the overhang

Exhibit 88: Ten holders own 51% of shares; Vanguard and BlackRock hold 12% each
VanguardBlackRockCapital Research GlobalState StreetCapital WorldGeodeAmeripriseJupiter TopcoInvescoBank of America12.412.36.05.44.82.82.71.51.41.3

Source: Signals 13F filings, 30 Jun 2026; % of 208.1m shares outstanding. 13F coverage 81% of shares. A single quarter does not show exits.

Exhibit 89: Short interest is 5.9m shares, 2.8% of shares, up 14% from the August low
4.04.55.05.56.0Jul-26Aug-26Sep-26Oct-265.9

Source: Signals short-interest series, 30 Jun to 15 Oct 2026. Days to cover 3.93 at 15 Oct.

Exhibit 90: Street is split: 10 of 19 analysts rate Buy, 9 Hold, none Sell
Strong BuyModerate BuyHoldRatings919

Source: Yahoo Finance, Nov 2026.

Exhibit 91: Street mean target $148.03 sits below our $155.16 and above the $135.08 price
Street low $135Street mean $148Street high $168Price $135Penmark target $155

Source: Yahoo Finance (Oct 2026), 15 analysts; Penmark Research.

Exhibit 92: Insider activity is routine: two sales totalling $0.82m in six months and small director grants
DateInsiderActionSharesPrice
1 Sep 2026Vice Chairman, Group PresidentSale5,000$135.71
1 Oct 2026Director (B. David)Grant294$123.27
1 Oct 2026Director (G. Torgow)Grant294$123.27
14 May 2026OfficerSale1,000$143.72

Source: Signals Form 4 filings, May to Oct 2026. Missing 10b5-1 flags are not treated as intent.

Exhibit 93: Liquidity is deep: $201m a day, a $28.1bn market value and 81% institutional ownership
$201m3 monthsAverage daily traded value$28.1bn208.2m sharesMarket value$154.43low $120.8352-week closing high3.9315 Oct 2026Days to cover

Source: Yahoo Finance; Signals; Penmark Research model, Thesis tab.

Ownership is index-heavy and stable, so flows follow the sector. Vanguard, BlackRock and State Street hold 30% of shares, which fits the finding that XLU explains two-thirds of weekly moves. Equity issuance of about $1bn a year adds supply of about 3.5% of shares annually; there are no lock-ups or controlling holders.

PART 5 · APPENDIX · 19 FINANCIAL MODEL

Operating earnings rise from $1,524m to $2,643m by FY31E while debt rises from $26.0bn to $48.1bn

Exhibit 94: Operating earnings rise 73% from FY25A to FY31E; free cash flow stays negative throughout
US$mFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31E
Earnings (operating basis)
DTE Electric1,2171,3401,5011,7712,1122,4212,683
DTE Gas295318339362383403422
DTE Vantage16220000000
Energy Trading114585555555555
Corporate and other(264)(305)(269)(318)(381)(455)(517)
Operating earnings1,5241,6111,6261,8702,1692,4242,643
Operating EPS, $7.367.737.668.519.5610.3911.07
Dividend per share, $4.434.664.995.315.666.026.41
Cash flow
Cash from operations3,4093,9004,3855,1085,9306,5557,020
Capex(4,429)(6,770)(7,940)(9,540)(10,940)(10,640)(9,640)
Free cash flow(1,020)(2,870)(3,555)(4,432)(5,010)(4,085)(2,620)
Dividends(871)(971)(1,058)(1,166)(1,284)(1,405)(1,532)
Equity issued–1001,0001,1001,100900900
Net debt issued–8833,6144,4985,1944,5903,252
Balance sheet
Debt26,02326,90630,52035,01740,21144,80148,053
Total equity12,30813,78915,35617,16019,14521,06423,075

Source: Company filings (10-K FY25); Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026. FY25A operating cash flow, capex and dividends as reported; FY25A net income $1,462m reported. Vantage sold at 31 Dec 2026 (pro forma).

Exhibit 95: Ratios: P/E falls from 17.5x to 12.2x as EPS compounds at 9.6% to FY31E
RatiosFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31E
Growth and returns
Operating EPS growth7.8%5.1%−1.0%11.2%12.2%8.7%6.5%
Rate base growth–10.8%13.7%14.8%14.8%11.6%8.3%
Electric earned ROE–9.88%9.73%9.90%10.11%10.11%10.11%
Payout ratio60%60%65%62%59%58%58%
Leverage and valuation at $135.08
FFO to debt–16.1%15.3%15.4%15.5%15.3%15.2%
Diluted shares, m207.0208.3212.3219.6226.9233.3238.8
Book value per share, $59.2566.1471.2176.8983.1289.2995.66
P/E, operating18.4x17.5x17.6x15.9x14.1x13.0x12.2x
P/B2.3x2.0x1.9x1.8x1.6x1.5x1.4x
Dividend yield3.3%3.4%3.7%3.9%4.2%4.5%4.7%

Source: Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026; multiples at the $135.08 close of 6 Nov 2026. FY25A payout and growth from company data.

Exhibit 96: Quarterly operating EPS: Q4 FY26E of $2.16 completes FY26E at $7.73
Operating EPS, $Q1Q2Q3Q4Year
FY25A2.101.362.251.657.36
FY26 (Q4E)1.951.322.302.167.73

Source: Company quarterly releases (FY25 Q1 and Q4 derived from nine-month and full-year figures); Penmark Research model for Q4 FY26E (full-year less nine months of $5.58).

PART 5 · APPENDIX · 20 REFERENCE

Operating EPS is $0.33 above reported EPS in FY25A; the model, method and sources are set out below

Exhibit 97: Operating EPS of $7.36 exceeds reported EPS of $7.03 by $0.33 in FY25A; FY26E pro forma reverses on the Vantage gain
US$FY24AFY25AFY26E pro forma
Operating EPS6.837.367.73
Reported diluted EPS (GAAP)6.777.0311.29
Net income, reported, $m1,4041,4622,351
Diluted shares, m207207208.3

Source: Company releases and 10-K (via Signals); Penmark Research model, 8 Nov 2026. FY24A operating EPS from the company Q4 FY24 release. FY26E assumes the Vantage sale at 31 Dec 2026; close is expected 1H 2027 and the GAAP gain falls in FY27. Operating earnings are non-GAAP and exclude non-recurring items, mark-to-market adjustments and discontinued operations.

Exhibit 98: Glossary and ratio definitions
TermMeaning
Rate baseNet plant on which regulators allow a return; proxy here is DTE Electric net plant plus calibrated Gas
Allowed / earned ROEReturn on equity set in a rate order, against the return the company actually earns
FFO to debtFunds from operations divided by total debt; credit metric with a company target of about 15%
Stay-outCommitment not to file a new rate case for a stated period
LLTMLarge-load transition mechanism: tariff terms for data-center customers
AFUDC, ITCCapital cost earned during construction; investment tax credit on renewables
VantageDTE Vantage, the non-utility segment being sold for about $3bn
P/E at our targetTarget price divided by FY28E operating EPS: 18.2x ($155.16 / $8.51)
Upside to 12-month targetTarget over price, less 1; Buy above +10%, Sell below −10%

Source: Company filings and Penmark Research.

Methodology

Archetype: regulated asset base. Earnings equal average rate base times equity share times earned ROE, less parent interest, over diluted shares. Primary method is P/E on FY28E operating EPS at the peer-median FY27E multiple (18.4x), discounted 12 months at 4.65% (8.34% cost of equity less 3.69% dividend yield); the cross-check is a dividend discount model (FY27-36, 4.0% terminal growth). Target is the weighted value rolled forward by cost of equity less dividend yield. Rating on upside to target (±10%); Buy needs value 5.1% above price. Departures: no EBITDA rows; derived peer and consensus figures are labelled.

Peer set

CMS Energy, Xcel Energy, WEC Energy, Ameren and American Electric Power: regulated utilities chosen on business model and guided growth of 7.0-9.0%. Five peers; no uncovered global competitors.

Data sources and as-of dates

Model and prices as of 8 Nov 2026; prices at the 6 Nov 2026 close. Company financials: 10-K FY21-FY25 and 10-Q Q3 FY26 (SEC EDGAR via Signals). Guidance: Q3 FY26 release, deck and call, 5 Nov 2026. Consensus: Zacks, Barchart and KeyCorp, July 2026; FY27 predates the 5 Nov 2026 rebase. Market data: Yahoo Finance. Ownership, insiders and short interest: Signals (13F 30 Jun 2026; short interest 15 Oct 2026). Regulation: Michigan Public Service Commission and Attorney General releases, 2026. Rating, target, scenarios and probabilities are Penmark Research estimates and judgements.

PART 5 · APPENDIX · 21 DISCLOSURES

Analyst certification and important disclosures

Ratings

Ratings reflect upside to our 12-month price target, weighted across bull, base and bear scenarios. Buy above +10%, Hold between −10% and +10%, Sell below −10%.

BuyUpside to target above +10%
HoldUpside to target between −10% and +10%
SellUpside to target below −10%

We review ratings at each set of results and whenever the facts change materially. A share price can move outside its band before the rating changes, and targets may not be reached.

Analyst certification

The Penmark Team certifies that (1) the views in this report accurately reflect its views about the subject company and its securities, and (2) no part of its compensation was, is or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific ratings, price targets or views in this report.

Contact

Penmark Research

Questions about our research:
research@penmarkresearch.com

All our research and coverage:
penmarkresearch.com

Basis of preparation

This report uses information publicly available up to its publication date. Share prices are closing prices on the trading day before the publication date, unless stated otherwise. Forecasts, valuations and price targets are Penmark Research’s own, and forecast periods are marked E. Sources are shown beneath each exhibit.

Valuation and price targets

Price targets are based on the valuation methods set out in each report and are weighted across bull, base and bear scenarios. The main risks to each rating and price target are described in the report. Penmark Research updates its coverage after each set of results but is not obliged to update a report at any other time.

Independence and conflicts of interest

Penmark Research is independent. It does not provide investment banking, brokerage, market-making or asset management services, does not trade securities, and does not accept payment from any company for research coverage. Companies do not see or review Penmark Research reports before publication.

No member of the Penmark Team holds a long or short position, directly or through derivatives, in the securities of any company Penmark Research covers.

Regulatory status

Penmark Research publishes general, impersonal investment research on a regular basis. It is not registered as an investment adviser with the US Securities and Exchange Commission or any state securities authority, is not a registered broker-dealer and is not a member of FINRA. Penmark Research does not give advice tailored to any person’s circumstances.

Not investment advice or an offer

This report is for information only. It is not personalised investment advice and is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or other financial instrument. It does not take into account any reader’s objectives, financial situation or needs. Readers should make their own investment decisions and seek independent professional advice where appropriate.

Forward-looking statements and risk

Forecasts, valuations and price targets are estimates based on assumptions that may prove wrong, and they may not be achieved. Opinions are current as of the publication date and may change without notice. Investing in equities involves risk, including the loss of capital. Share prices can be volatile, and past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.

Data and sources

Company financials, operating data and filings come from company filings, earnings releases and earnings calls. Market data and any consensus estimates come from third-party sources named beneath the relevant exhibit; consensus figures from aggregators are unofficial. Penmark Research does not use other brokers’ research. Third-party data belong to their providers and may not be extracted from this report.

Accuracy and liability

Information is taken from sources believed to be reliable, but Penmark Research makes no representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. To the fullest extent permitted by law, Penmark Research accepts no liability for any loss arising from use of this report. Descriptions of litigation and regulatory matters reflect allegations and public records, not findings, unless stated. If a published report is corrected, the corrected version carries an “Updated” date at penmarkresearch.com.

Distribution and access

Penmark Research reports are available to registered users of penmarkresearch.com. Downloads and programmatic access are governed by the Penmark Research subscription terms. This report is not directed at, or intended for, any person in Singapore or India, and access from those countries is blocked. It is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any person in any jurisdiction where that would be contrary to law or regulation or would subject Penmark Research to registration or licensing requirements there.

Copyright and permitted use

© Penmark Research. All rights reserved. Penmark Research is a trade name of Brightriver Labs. Readers may share a link to this report but may not copy, reproduce, redistribute, sell or use its content, including for text and data mining, without written consent. Contact: research@penmarkresearch.com.

Keep reading

Sign in to Penmark