Summary

Initiate at Hold with a $50 target: e-gate gains are priced in and prepayments flatter cash flow

InitiationBy Penmark Team
YOUHold$49.63-9%
Page 1 of 26
Equity Research | Initiation of coverage | United States
Consumer Services & Identity Infrastructure | Coverage: Initiated | Published 20 November 2026, 08:00 ET
Penmark Team | research@penmarkresearch.com
Clear Secure, Inc. (NYSE: YOU)

Initiate at Hold with a $50 target: e-gate gains are priced in and prepayments flatter cash flow

Rating
Initiation
Hold
12-month target
$49.63
Price, 18 Nov 2026
$54.81
Price return
-9.5%
Total return
-8.3%
Bull case
$67.10
Bear case
$33.41

We initiate coverage of Clear Secure at Hold (Low conviction) with a $49.63 target (-8.3% total return including $0.66 of regular dividends). Clear Secure runs biometric airport fast-track lanes (CLEAR+) across 62 US airports and enterprise identity checks (CLEAR1). Our core metric, Active CLEAR+ members, is the number of paying annual subscribers; after a 57% one-year rally, the market treats member prepayments as permanent free cash flow (FCF).

  • Member prepayments are financing, not free cash flow (-$10/share). Upfront annual subscriptions add $89m to $124m a year to headline FCF and leave $604m of deferred revenue. Stripping prepayments yields a $47 base discounted cash flow (DCF) value.
  • A shutdown enrolment spike faces a May 2027 renewal test (-$1.06/share). Q1 FY26 added 551,000 net members during federal airport staffing gaps. As that cohort renews beside free TSA Touchless ID at about 65 airports, member growth slows to 7% in FY27E.
  • Automated e-gates lift margins (+$1.30/share if savings go further). E-gates at 53 of 62 airports (85%) held nine-month direct salaries flat on 25% revenue growth, lifting adjusted EBITDA margin toward 37% in FY27E.

What the market is missing. Our FY26E and FY27E revenue sit within 1% of consensus, and FY27E adjusted earnings per share (EPS) ($2.76) sits 1% below consensus ($2.79); FY26E adjusted EPS ($2.21) is 6% above. The $8 gap between our $47 base value and the $55 price splits into -$10 from treating prepayments as financing and +$2 from our faster member-growth path.

Catalysts. Late Feb 2027 Q4 FY26 results test FY27 cash-flow guidance and CLEAR1 demand. Early May 2027 Q1 FY27 results lap the 41% bookings surge. Jun-Jul 2027 tests the $10 price rise to $229 already in our base case.

Valuation and target. Primary 10-year DCF on unlevered FCF excluding prepayments (10.04% cost of equity, 3.0% terminal growth) gives $47 base, $62 bull (25%) and $31 bear (30%), or $46 weighted. Rolling forward less $0.66 dividend gives our $49.63 target; the Sell line sits near $56, only 2% above the current price.

Risks. Downside: Q1 FY27 renewal churn, free Touchless ID substitution, higher discount rates. Upside: large CLEAR1 wins, deeper e-gate savings, or valuing prepayments as working capital.

Exhibit 2: Key financials (left) and valuation multiples at $54.81 current share price (right), FY24A-FY28E
US$m, FY DecFY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Revenue770.5900.81,126.61,296.31,452.8
Revenue growth (%)25.6%16.9%25.1%15.1%12.1%
Adjusted EBITDA185.0260.0391.1478.3550.6
Adj. EBITDA margin (%)24.0%28.9%34.7%36.9%37.9%
Net income (exch. basis)225.3168.1257.5316.8365.9
EPS, diluted / exch. ($)1.561.121.932.442.92
EPS growth (%)*403.2%-28.2%n.m.*26.5%19.9%
Free cash flow (co. def.)283.7343.1498.8508.7590.6
Multiples at $54.81FY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
P/E (reported / exch.)35.1x48.9x28.5x22.5x18.8x
P/E (adjusted excl. SBC)n.a.n.a.24.8x19.9x16.6x
EV / Adjusted EBITDA35.9x25.6x17.0x13.9x12.1x
Price / Book (P/B)30.6x35.6x43.8x44.6x44.5x
FCF yield (company def.)3.9%4.7%6.9%7.0%8.1%
Regular dividend yield0.8%0.9%1.1%1.2%1.3%
Return on equity (ROE)94.7%82.3%154.9%194.2%223.7%
P/E at our target ($49.63)31.8x44.3x25.8x20.4x17.0x

Source: Company filings (FY24A-FY25A); Penmark Research model (FY26E-FY28E). EBITDA = earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation; SBC = stock-based compensation; DPS = dividend per share. *FY26E EPS shifts from reported Class A ($1.12) to fully exchanged basis ($1.93). No debt; net cash $633m.

Base-case DCF is $47 a share; bull and bear targets give 0.6x upside to downside

Exhibit 3: Scenarios span $33 to $67; weighted target of $50 implies -8% total return
$30$40$50$60$70Jan-26Jul-26Jan-27Jul-27ActualEstimatesPrice $54.81Bull $67.10 (+22%)Base $50.74 (−7%)Bear $33.41 (−39%)Target $49.63 (−9%)

Source: Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research model (fan % labels show price returns; table beside shows total returns incl. $0.66 dividend)

Scenarios and price target basis (Low conviction)
Bull$67.10+23.6% TR25% prob.

Large CLEAR1 contracts, 10% FY27E member growth, +8.5% revenue per member, and full e-gate savings (direct salaries 13.5% of revenue). Value today: $61.58.

Base$50.74-6.2% TR45% prob.

Growth slows to 15.1% in FY27E (7.0% members, +6.0% revenue per member); e-gates cut direct salaries to 15.0% by FY29E and lift operating margin to 32.1% by FY30E. Value today: $46.71.

Bear$33.41-37.8% TR30% prob.

Q1 FY26 surge cohort churns, Touchless ID slows member growth to 3.0%, pricing stalls (+2.0%), and direct salaries stay at 16.8%. Value today: $30.96.

12m price target (prob.-weighted)$49.63-8.3% total return = Hold (Low)
Upside to downside (targets)0.6x+$12.29 up / -$21.40 down
Exhibit 4: Operating income triples from FY24A to FY27E on e-gate leverage
Income statement, US$mFY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Revenue770.5900.81,126.61,296.31,452.8
Revenue share & direct salaries-281.2-320.5-359.8-395.4-435.8
R&D, S&M and G&A-339.7-359.2-425.8-478.3-528.8
Adj. EBITDA (adds back SBC)185.0260.0391.1478.3550.6
Operating income (EBIT)123.2186.5313.9390.2451.8
Net interest & other-56.619.636.332.236.0
Income tax & member tax dist.158.6-37.9-92.8-105.6-122.0
Net income (cons. / exch.)225.3168.1257.5316.8365.9

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model. FY24A other includes an $89.1m Tax Receivable Agreement (TRA) charge.

Exhibit 5: Customer prepayments boost company FCF by $89m to $124m a year
Cash flow, US$mFY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Net income (cons. / exch.)225.3168.1257.5316.8365.9
D&A and equity-based comp.61.873.677.288.198.8
Change in deferred revenue86.976.4124.498.289.2
Other working cap. & non-cash-78.354.369.540.574.4
Operating cash flow (OCF)295.7372.5528.6543.7628.4
Capital expenditure (CapEx)-12.0-29.3-29.8-35.0-37.8
Free cash flow (co. def.)283.7343.1498.8508.7590.6
FCF excl. prepaymentsn.a.266.7381.8416.2506.5

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model. FY26E-FY28E unlevered FCF valued is after SBC.

Exhibit 6: Cash and securities largely offset deferred revenue and TRA obligations
Balance sheet, US$mFY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Cash & marketable securities609.5700.2806.0900.91,009.7
Property, leases & goodwill235.0224.8224.2226.8228.3
Deferred tax & other assets350.4378.4402.0386.5372.4
Total assets1,194.91,303.41,432.31,514.21,610.4
Deferred revenue439.8516.2640.6738.9828.1
Accrued partner & TRA liab.377.4408.1442.4418.0414.2
Other & lease liabilities139.8174.7183.0194.2204.5
Total equity (incl. NCI)237.9204.4166.2163.1163.6

Source: Company filings (FY24A-FY25A); Penmark Research model. NCI = non-controlling interest. No debt across all periods.

Exhibit 7: Active CLEAR+ members reach 9.9m and revenue per member hits $152 by FY28E
Per share & KPIsFY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
EPS, diluted / exch. ($)1.561.121.932.442.92
Adjusted EPS excl. SBC ($)n.a.n.a.2.212.763.30
Regular dividend / share ($)0.420.500.600.660.73
Diluted shares, exch. (m)*139.0135.0133.7130.0125.3
Active CLEAR+ members (m)7.197.628.659.259.86
Member growth (%)n.a.6.0%13.6%7.0%6.5%
Rev. per avg. member ($)n.a.122.86136.61144.80152.05
Total bookings ($m)857.4977.21,251.11,394.51,542.1

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model. *FY25A share count is year-end; FY26E-FY28E are averages of year ends.

Margins widen 8 points by FY27E; revenue is within 1% of consensus and FY27E EPS 1% below

Exhibit 8: Growth slows after FY26E while operating margin crosses 30%
Growth & margins (%)FY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Growth y/y
Revenue25.6%16.9%25.1%15.1%12.1%
Adjusted EBITDA133.9%40.6%50.4%22.3%15.1%
Operating income (EBIT)511.7%51.4%68.3%24.3%15.8%
EPS (reported / exch.)*403.2%-28.2%n.m.*26.5%19.9%
Regular DPSn.a.20.5%20.0%10.0%10.0%
Margins & intensity
Gross margin (ex-rev share & sal.)63.5%64.4%68.1%69.5%70.0%
Adjusted EBITDA margin24.0%28.9%34.7%36.9%37.9%
Operating margin (EBIT)16.0%20.7%27.9%30.1%31.1%
FCF margin (co. definition)36.8%38.1%44.3%39.2%40.7%
FCF margin (excl. prepayments)n.a.29.6%33.9%32.1%34.9%
CapEx / revenue1.6%3.3%2.6%2.7%2.6%

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model. *FY26E EPS shifts from reported Class A to fully exchanged basis. FY24A DPS was $0.415 unrounded.

Exhibit 9: Thin book equity lifts ROE above 150% from FY26E; multiples reflect net cash
Returns, leverage & valuationFY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Returns & leverage
Return on equity (ROE)94.7%82.3%154.9%194.2%223.7%
Return on assets (ROA)18.9%12.9%18.0%20.9%22.7%
EBIT / total assets10.3%14.3%21.9%25.8%28.1%
Net debt / equityNet cashNet cashNet cashNet cashNet cash
Net cash / Adjusted EBITDA3.3x2.7x2.1x1.9x1.8x
Valuation at $54.81 current price
P/E (reported / exch.)35.1x48.9x28.5x22.5x18.8x
P/E (adjusted excl. SBC)n.a.n.a.24.8x19.9x16.6x
EV / Adjusted EBITDA35.9x25.6x17.0x13.9x12.1x
FCF yield (co. def.)3.9%4.7%6.9%7.0%8.1%
Regular dividend yield0.8%0.9%1.1%1.2%1.3%
P/E at our target ($49.63)31.8x44.3x25.8x20.4x17.0x

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model. ROE is inflated by thin book equity ($163m-$238m). EV uses $633m cash; zero debt.

Exhibit 10: Penmark vs Yahoo Finance consensus: revenue within 1%, FY27E adjusted EPS 1% below
Penmark vs consensusQ4 FY26E Rev ($m)FY26E Rev ($m)FY27E Rev ($m)FY26E Adj. EPS ($)FY27E Adj. EPS ($)
Penmark estimate303.01,126.61,296.32.212.76
Consensus (Yahoo Finance)301.21,120.01,290.02.082.79
Prior-year period240.8900.81,126.6n.a.2.21
Penmark vs consensus (%)+0.6%+0.6%+0.5%+6.1%-1.1%
Penmark projected y/y growth+25.9%+25.1%+15.1%n.a.+25.0%

Source: Company filings; Yahoo Finance consensus (20 Nov 2026, 3 EPS estimates); Penmark Research model. Consensus EBITDA not published at cut-off.

Exhibit 11: Revenue grows 25% in FY26E and slows to 15% in FY27E, close to consensus
Consensus$0m$500m$1000m$1500mFY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EActualEstimates$770m$901m$1127m$1296m$1453m

Source: Company filings; Yahoo Finance consensus; Penmark Research model

YOU trades 28% below peers on headline P/FCF, in line with its own average of about 16x

Exhibit 12: Clear Secure vs five consumer subscription and identity peers
Latest reported / TTMYOUPeer med.Diff.
Valuation (at 18 Nov 2026 prices)
Trailing P/FCF (co. def.)15.9x22.1x-28.1%
Trailing P/FCF (adj. ex-prep./SBC)26.3x22.1x+19.0%
Trailing P/FCF peer range15.9x18.1-65.8xBelow min
Growth & profitability
Latest-quarter rev. growth27.8%13.7%+14.1pp
Operating margin (TTM)26.5%12.4%+14.1pp
Net debt / EBITDANet cashn.a.No debt
Market value (US$bn)7.312.7-42.7%
Deferred rev. / TTM rev.56.7%n.a.Prepaid

Source: Company filings (rescaled to 18 Nov 2026 closes); Penmark Research model. Peers: Netflix, Duolingo, Grindr, Okta, SailPoint. Forward peer FCF was unavailable at cut-off. Diff in % for multiples, pp for ratios.

Exhibit 13: Four catalysts over the next 12 months
  • Late Feb 2027Q4 FY26 results & FY27 FCF guide: we model $303m Q4 rev (vs $299-$302m guide) and watch CLEAR1 bookings.
  • Early May 2027Q1 FY27 results: laps 41% bookings surge (551,000 net adds) and shows first quarterly American Express settlement cadence.
  • Jun-Jul 2027CLEAR+ list-price review: our base case assumes a $10 rise to $229; holding price flat would cost about $0.73/sh.
  • Aug 2027Q2 FY27 results: e-gate margin run-rate and initial renewal tracking after the July price rise.

Source: Company filings, Penmark Research (estimated windows).

Exhibit 14: Main downside and upside risks to our Hold rating
  • Surge-cohort renewal churn. Q1 FY26 shutdown sign-ups lapse at higher rates in Q1 FY27. Med (50%); -$1.06/sh.
  • Price elasticity fatigue. Four $10 hikes in four years push non-Amex renewals lower. Med (35%); -$1.10/sh.
  • Touchless ID substitution. Free TSA biometrics at about 65 airports erode CLEAR+ speed edge. Med (35%); -$0.71/sh.
  • Upside risk: Large CLEAR1 wins & e-gates. CMS/VA expansion (+$1.46/sh) and extra e-gate savings (+$1.30/sh).
Rating triggers (Hold, Low conviction): Under our rule, shares above about $56 trigger Sell and below about $46 trigger Buy. Fundamentally, Sell if FY27E member growth falls below 4%, discount rates rise 100bp, or beta reaches 1.44; Buy on CLEAR1 disclosure above 5% of bookings (~$60m+ annual recurring revenue) or strong May 2027 renewals.

Source: Penmark Research model.

Exhibit 15: At 16x trailing P/FCF, YOU sits in line with its 3.9-year mean
10x15x20x25x30x35x202420252026Mean 15.7x+1 SD 20.4x−1 SD 10.9x15.9x, <0.1 SD

Source: Company filings; Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research

Exhibit 16: YOU trades below all five subscription and identity peers on trailing P/FCF
0x20x40x60x80x10%15%20%25%30%Trailing P/FCF (x)Latest-quarter revenue growth (%)YOUNFLXDUOLGRNDOKTASAIL

Source: Company filings (18 Nov 2026 closes); Penmark Research model

PART 1 · SUMMARY · 3 THE THESIS IN CHARTS

Bookings move the stock and e-gates lift margins to 38%, but prepayments explain the $8 gap

Four charts frame our Hold call (Low conviction). Quarterly bookings track the share price across eight quarters (r = 0.80) and e-gates lift margins sharply, yet treating member prepayments as financing subtracts $10 a share and leaves base value at $47.

Exhibit 17: Quarterly bookings track the share price across eight quarters (r = 0.80)
Total bookings ($m)Quarter-end price ($) (right)$0m$100m$200m$300m$400m$20$30$40$50$60Q4 24AQ2 25AQ4 25AQ2 26A

Source: Company quarterly releases; Yahoo Finance

Exhibit 18: Prepayments cut value by $10 and growth adds $2, explaining the $8 gap
$0$20$40$60Share priceGrowth vs pricePrepaymentsBase DCF$54.81+$2.32−$10.43$46.71

Source: Penmark Research model (base DCF vs 18 Nov 2026 close)

Exhibit 19: E-gates lift adjusted EBITDA margin 9 points from FY25A to 38% in FY28E
Adj. EBITDA ($m)Adj. EBITDA margin (%) (right)$0m$200m$400m$600m20%25%30%35%40%FY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EActualEstimates

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model

Exhibit 20: Company FCF exceeds valued unlevered cash flow by $260m in FY26E
Company FCFFCF excl. prepaymentsUnlevered FCF valued$0m$200m$400m$600mFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EActualEstimates

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model

Reading the four panels together: Top left shows quarterly total bookings moving closely with the stock across eight quarters. Top right splits the $8 gap between our $47 base DCF and the $55 share price: once prepayments count as cash, our member-growth path actually sits $2.32 a share above what the price implies, but treating prepayments as financing deducts $10.43 a share. Bottom left shows e-gates lifting adjusted EBITDA from $185m (FY24A) to $551m (FY28E). Bottom right shows the $261m FY26E gap between headline company FCF ($499m) and valued unlevered FCF ($238m). Our -8.3% total return sits inside the -10% to +10% Hold band, with Low conviction: the Sell line is near $56, and three stress tests (discount rate +1pt, beta 1.44, or prepayments as cash) flip the call.
PART 1 · SUMMARY · 4 KEY DEBATES

Four debates decide the next 12 months; how to treat prepayments is worth $10 a share

Our revenue and FY27E adjusted EPS sit close to consensus, so the real divide is structural. Each debate below ties to a clear catalyst window and resolves by August 2027.

DebateMarket viewPenmark viewKey evidenceWhat changes our viewResolves
Member prepayments: cash or financing Counts annual prepayments inside FCF (15.9x trailing P/FCF), worth $57 a share on our base forecast. Deferred revenue ($604m) is a service liability, not equity cash; stripping it yields $47 a share (-$10.43). Deferred revenue equals 57% of sales; Q3 cash outflow ($104m) reflects annual partner settlements. Sustained 10%+ member growth making deferred revenue a permanent net cash source. FY27 FCF guide (Late Feb 2027)
Post-surge CLEAR+ renewals Price implies FY27E member growth of 6.4% if prepayments are cash (-0.6pt/yr shift) or 9.3% if financing (+2.3pt/yr shift); Street sees +15.2% FY27E sales. Q1 FY26 federal staffing surge (551,000 net adds) creates a steep lap; member growth slows to 7.0% in FY27E. Q4 bookings guide slows to +18% vs +41% in Q1; TSA Touchless ID covers about 65 airports for free. Q1 FY27 total bookings staying above +12% y/y with stable member retention after the surge lap. Q1 FY27 results (Early May 2027)
E-gate labour leverage Consensus FY27E EPS ($2.79) is within about 1% of ours ($2.76), so the Street already assumes margin gains close to ours. E-gates cut direct salaries from 21.4% (FY25A) to 15.8% (FY27E) and lift EBIT margin to 30.1%; well reflected. 9M FY26 direct salaries fell $0.8m y/y on 25% revenue growth; e-gates run at 53 of 62 airports (85%). Direct salaries falling below 14% of revenue without hurting lane service or requiring extra staff. Q4 FY26 & Q2 FY27 results
CLEAR1 enterprise & federal scaling Bulls treat enterprise identity (Medicare.gov, Veterans Affairs, CrowdStrike) as a high-multiple second leg. Strong momentum (Q3 bookings ~3x y/y), but undisclosed revenue and ID.me incumbency limit credit today. ID.me already verifies 70m+ Americans across federal portals; CLEAR1 excluded from Q4 guidance. Standalone CLEAR1 revenue disclosure above 5% of total bookings (~$60m+ annual recurring revenue) with federal rollout. Q4 FY26 results & FY27 deals
Exhibit 21: Prepayments cut value by $10 a share while growth adds $2 if prepayments are cash
Market viewOur viewPrepayments: cash vs debtPost-surge membergrowthE-gate labour margin$46.71$57.13$54.81$57.13$46.71, no change

Source: Penmark Research model

Exhibit 22: Four catalysts resolve our core debates by August 2027
Late Feb 27Q4 FY26 & FY27 FCFguidePrepayments & CLEAR1Early May 27Q1 FY27 resultsLaps +41% bookings surgeJun-Jul 27CLEAR+ list price review$229 rise is in base caseAug 27Q2 FY27 resultsE-gate margin run-rate

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research (estimated reporting windows)

Why the four debates keep conviction Low: Our -8.3% total return sits inside the -10% to +10% Hold band, and the current price sits about 2% below the ~$56 Sell line. Treating prepayments as financing (-$10/share) more than explains the $8 gap between our $47 base value and the $55 share price, while three model stress tests (discount rate +1pt, beta 1.44, or prepayments as working capital) flip the call.
PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 5 THE STORY

Members pay a year upfront, leaving $600m of deferred revenue on the balance sheet

Clear Secure operates biometric fast-track lanes across 62 US airports and is expanding its verified identity network into hospitals, employers and federal agencies. Behind the rapid cash build sits a sharp tension: member prepayments flatter headline cash flow just as a free government biometric lane reaches about 65 airports.

16 yearsOperating since 2010
46.7mTotal CLEAR members
$901mFY25A revenue
62 / 53Airports / e-gate sites
$7.3bnDiluted market cap

The scene

At 53 US airports today, a Clear Secure subscriber steps up to an automated e-gate, pauses for a facial scan and walks straight toward bag screening. Management noted on the Q3 FY26 earnings call that over 96% of travellers clear the lane in under five minutes. That predictability is the product. Clear Secure has spent 16 years building airport lanes, winning local concessions and training 3,708 ambassadors and field managers (FY25 Form 10-K) for 8.5 million paying subscribers.

What it actually does

Clear Secure does not replace Transportation Security Administration (TSA) screening; it verifies identity before the belt. Its consumer subscription, CLEAR+, links biometrics to government identification across 62 airports covering nearly 80% of US air traffic. A second product, CLEAR1, lets enterprises, hospitals and federal portals such as Medicare.gov verify digital identity using the same member network.

How the money comes in

Members pay an entire year upfront, creating a high-margin subscription pool backed by credit-card partners. CLEAR+ carries a $219 annual list price, though partner discounts, family plans and American Express statement credits bring realised revenue per member to about $137 in FY26E.

Airports collect 14.5% of FY26E revenue as a variable share fee (rising to 14.7% from FY27E). Once ambassador wages and overhead are paid, about 28 cents of every FY26E revenue dollar becomes operating profit, while upfront billing lifts headline free cash flow to 44% of sales.

Where the story turns

Two events in 2026 reshaped the business. In February 2026, Clear Secure renewed its multi-year American Express deal just as federal airport staffing lapses sparked a 551,000-member Q1 enrolment surge, about 5x the trailing four-quarter average. Meanwhile, deploying automated e-gates across 53 of its 62 airports (85%) held nine-month direct labour flat on 25% revenue growth, lifting adjusted EBITDA margins above 35%.

Why it works, and why it might not

Card-funded renewals and faster e-gate throughput keep frequent flyers sticky. What could break the loop sits inside our core debates: post-surge renewals face a steep test in May 2027 beside free TSA PreCheck Touchless ID at about 65 airports, while upfront prepayments make headline cash flow run well ahead of recurring operating earnings.

$604mDeferred revenue, Q3 FY26
Upfront annual billing equals 57% of sales, creating a prepaid liability that adds $89m to $124m a year to headline free cash flow in FY26E to FY28E.Source: Q3 FY26 Form 10-Q; Penmark Research model. Treating prepayments as financing rather than equity cash reduces DCF value by $10 a share.
1 · HOW THEY FIND IT
62 airports + AmexMost sign-ups occur at airport lanes or via American Express Platinum credits.
2 · WHAT THEY BUY
CLEAR+ annual passBiometric lane access, optional Concierge and TSA PreCheck enrolment.
3 · WHAT THEY PAY
$219 list / $137 revenueBilled upfront annually; realised revenue per member reflects partner and family pricing.
4 · WHAT CLEAR KEEPS
27.9% EBIT marginFY26E operating margin after 14.5% airport fee and 17.4% direct ambassador wages.
Why the story explains our Hold call: Clear Secure has built a valuable airport network with real e-gate cost savings, yet at $55 the market treats customer prepayments as permanent free cash flow. With total return at -8.3%, the stock sits inside our Hold band with Low conviction.
PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 5 HOW CLEAR SECURE MAKES MONEY

Prepaid airport memberships drive revenue while e-gates cut the cost to serve

Exhibit 23: Sixteen years from 2010 relaunch to 47m members and e-gate automation
2010CLEAR relaunchedCaryn Seidman Beckerbuys assets2019Amex partnershipCard credit scales CLEAR+2021NYSE IPO at $3138 airports; $254m FY21Asales2024EnVe & PreCheck5x faster pods; 285 retailsites2025E-gates & CMSAutomated lanes;Medicare.gov2026Amex & sunsetMulti-year deal; 1-votesharesNowToday: $558.5m CLEAR+; 53 e-gateairports

Source: Company filings (Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, DEF 14A)

Exhibit 24: Business model map: 8.5m paying subscribers fund $1.13bn FY26E revenue and $391m adjusted EBITDA
1 · Customers
US air travellers8.47m activePaying CLEAR+ base (+14.5% y/y, Q3 26)
Free / B2B users38.3m non-paidTotal platform 46.7m (+30.7% y/y)
Enterprises & govCMS, VA, Epic~10% of US health systems
2 · Offerings
CLEAR+ Lanes62 airports166+ lanes; 53 e-gate airports
Concierge & TSA43 / 285 sitesEscort service; PreCheck enrolment
CLEAR1 Digital~3x y/y bkgsWorkforce, patient & federal ID
3 · Revenue
Annual upfront$1,126.6mFY26E total revenue (+25.1%)
Total bookings$1,251.1mFY26E billings (+28.0% y/y)
Deferred pool$640.6mFY26E year-end prepaid liability
4 · Channels
In-airport podsPrimary3,708 staff & EnVe pods
Card partnersAmex renewedMulti-year Feb 26; quarterly Q1 27
Digital & B2BApp & Okta1m+ calendar syncs; CrowdStrike
5 · Cost to serve
Airport rev share$163.6m14.5% of FY26E rev (variable)
Direct salaries$196.2m17.4% of FY26E rev (falling)
G&A, R&D, S&M$425.8m37.8% of FY26E rev incl. SBC
6 · What is left
Adj. EBITDA$391.1m34.7% margin (+585bp y/y)
Operating profit$313.9m27.9% GAAP EBIT margin
Unlevered FCF$237.8mValued ex-prepayments & post-SBC
8.47mActive CLEAR+ (Q3 26)+14.5% y/y
$136.61Rev per member (FY26E)+11.2% y/y
$1,251mTotal bookings (FY26E)+28.0% y/y
53 / 62e-gate / total airports85% of airports
$603.6mDeferred rev. (Q3 26)57% of TTM rev

Source: FY25 Form 10-K, Q3 FY26 Form 10-Q and earnings call (4 Nov 2026), Penmark Research model. CLEAR1 is not broken out separately in filings.

Single-segment recurring business with an enterprise identity option. Clear Secure reports one operating segment because its airport lanes and enterprise CLEAR1 service share one verified identity network. Enrolling a traveller once in an airport lane creates a verified credential reusable across Medicare.gov, VA.gov and healthcare portals at very low marginal cost.

Concentration sits in the US airport network and American Express. All 62 CLEAR+ airports operate inside the United States under individual airport authority concessions and TSA oversight. American Express is the main distribution partner, funding statement credits for eligible cardmembers. On its Q3 FY26 call, management noted settling roughly $315m of accrued partnership liabilities in Q3 before moving to quarterly settlements in Q1 FY27.

PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 5 UNIT ECONOMICS AND REVENUE ENGINE

Each revenue dollar made 21 cents of operating profit in FY25A, rising to 28 cents in FY26E

Exhibit 25: Each FY25A revenue dollar ($901m) kept 21 cents of operating profit
Revenue$900.8mCost of revenue$320.5mGross profit$580.3mG&A$232.4mR&D$72.4mSales & mktg$54.4mD&A$34.6mOperating profit$186.5m

Source: FY25 Form 10-K; Penmark Research model (Cost of revenue = $127.8m rev share + $192.6m direct salaries)

Exhibit 26: FY26E revenue of $1.13bn (+25%) pairs 8.2m average members with $137 per member
Year-end members8.65m (+13.6%)Airport network62 airports (53 e-gates)Avg Active CLEAR+8.25m (+12.5%)CLEAR+ list price$219 (+$10 Jul 2026)CLEAR1 & ConciergeBookings ~3x y/y in Q3Revenue per member$136.61 (+11.2%)Revenue FY26E$1,126.6m (+25.1%)

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model

Fixed vs variable cost

Airport revenue share is purely variable at 14.5% to 14.7% of sales. Direct ambassador salaries, historically Clear Secure's largest cost of revenue, are decoupling from sales as e-gates automate identity checks, falling from 21.4% of revenue in FY25A to 17.4% in FY26E and 15.8% in FY27E.

Cash vs accounting profit

Annual prepayments drive a wide gap between profit and headline cash flow. Subscribers pay 12 months upfront, booked to deferred revenue ($604m at Q3 FY26) and recognised monthly. Capital expenditure stays light at 2.6% to 2.7% of revenue ($30m to $38m a year in FY26E to FY28E), even during the EnVe pod and e-gate rollout.

Amex payment cadence shift

Quarterly cash flows smooth out starting Q1 FY27. Historically, Q3 posted negative FCF (-$103.8m in Q3 FY26, per the Q3 Form 10-Q) due to the ~$315m annual partnership liability settlement disclosed on the Q3 call. Under the February 2026 renewed card agreement, quarterly settlements begin in Q1 FY27.

PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 6 THE MARKET

US airports screen about 900m travellers a year; identity verification spend doubles to $33bn by 2031

Clear Secure operates in two distinct markets: a mature US airport checkpoint market and a fragmented $16.5bn global digital identity verification market. Near-term earnings come mainly from travel, while long-term multiple expansion depends on winning enterprise and government identity share.

Exhibit 27: CLEAR monetises identity checks across airports, credit cards and enterprises
Enrolment & HardwareEnVe pods, e-gates, 3,708 staffCapEx 2.6% of revIdentity NetworkCLEAR (47m), ID.me (70m+verified)29-35% Adj. EBITDAChannel & PartnersAmex Platinum, 62 airports, Epic,Okta14.5% FY26E feeEnd CheckpointsTSA lanes, CMS/VA portals,employersRegulated / enterprise

Source: FY25 Form 10-K; TSA; Penmark Research

Exhibit 28: Global identity verification spend doubles from $16.5bn in 2026E to $33bn by 2031E
$0bn$10bn$20bn$30bn$40bn2025A2026E2027E2028E2029E2030E2031EActualEstimates$14.3bn$16.5bn$33.4bn

Source: MarketsandMarkets (2026); 15.1% CAGR (2026E-2031E); intermediate years unpublished

Exhibit 29: Market sizing across travel and digital identity
Market segmentLatest scaleGrowth / driverCLEAR position
US TSA screenings~905m / yr (2025)2.49m/day YTD 202662 airports (~80% traffic)
Active CLEAR+ member base8.47m active+14.5% y/y (Q3 26)Low single-digit % of flyers
Global ID verification$16.5bn (2026E)15.1% CAGR to 2031ECLEAR1 early innings
Healthcare digital auth.$3.64bn (2026E)13.6% CAGR to 2034E~10% of US health systems
Federal improper payments$186bn (FY25)64 federal programs*CMS live; VA.gov pilot
AI-enabled breaches1 in 4 US breaches$6m avg breach costCrowdStrike Falcon partner

Source: TSA (Nov 2026), MarketsandMarkets (2026), Fortune Business Insights, Q3 FY26 call. *Total improper payments, not all fraud.

US air travel demand is steady, though Clear Secure's airport footprint is mature. TSA screened roughly 905 million passengers in 2025 (2.48m/day) and averaged 2.49m/day through August 2026, though September 2026 throughput dipped 2% y/y. With 62 airports already covering nearly 80% of US commercial traffic, future CLEAR+ growth depends mainly on deeper penetration at existing airports, TSA PreCheck bundling across 285 retail sites, and corporate channels.

AI-driven impersonation lifts enterprise identity verification demand. MarketsandMarkets estimates global identity verification spend at $16.5bn in 2026, reaching $33.4bn by 2031 (15.1% CAGR). Federal pressure to curb $186bn of annual improper payments (which include errors as well as fraud) and rising workforce impersonation create real tailwinds for CLEAR1, though specialists (ID.me, Socure, Persona) and Okta already hold entrenched positions.

PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 7 COMPETITIVE POSITION

CLEAR leads in airport hospitality, but free Touchless ID and ID.me narrow its edge

Clear Secure no longer competes only against manual ID queues. In travel, TSA PreCheck Touchless ID expanded from 15 airports to about 65 airports by spring 2026 across five participating airlines, at no extra fee. In digital identity, ID.me already verifies more than 70 million Americans across 21 federal agencies.

Exhibit 30: CLEAR leads in airport speed but faces free PreCheck biometrics and ID.me
CLEARTSA IDID.meOktaAirport lane speedCard & airline ecosystemFederal & healthcare reachZero-cost traveller accessEnterprise identity linksNoneWeakFairStrongLeader

Source: Company filings; TSA; CMS; Penmark Research assessment

Exhibit 31: Touchless ID expanded to about 65 airports, matching CLEAR's 62-airport network
TSA Touchless ID (5airlines)CLEAR+ total airportsCLEAR e-gate airportsCLEAR Concierge airports65625343

Source: TSA (Jan 2026); Clear Secure Q3 FY26 call and filings

Exhibit 32: Competitive landscape across airport screening and enterprise digital identity
CompetitorCore arenaScale & backingEdge vs CLEARLimitation vs CLEAR
TSA PreCheck Touchless IDUS airport lanesAbout 65 airports by spring 2026 across five participating airlines (per TSA Jan 2026).Zero incremental fee for PreCheck flyers; airline boarding-pass opt-in.Airline- and checkpoint-specific; no dedicated hospitality or non-PreCheck lane.
ID.meFederal & healthcare156m platform users; 70m+ verified Americans; 21 federal agencies; $1bn IRS contract ceiling.Incumbent on VA.gov and IRS; live on Medicare.gov (Mar 2026) and Epic Toolbox.No physical airport consumer flywheel; raised $615m private funding in 2025.
Login.govFederal portalsUS government-operated sign-in (GSA); live on Medicare.gov.Zero cost to federal agencies and taxpayers; direct federal mandate.Slower product iteration; narrower commercial verification feature set.
Persona / Socure / OktaEnterprise identitySocure $5.2bn val (Aug 26); Persona $2.0bn (Apr 25); Okta $35.4bn market value.Deep developer tools, fraud scoring and workforce sign-in reach (Okta partner/rival).No 47m reusable consumer biometric network; often complementary to CLEAR1.

Source: TSA (Jan 2026), CMS Medicare & You 2027, Clear Secure FY25 Form 10-K, Penmark Research.

Where Clear Secure's advantage is durable. Physical checkpoint real estate at 62 airports takes years of local authority concessions and federal certification to replicate. Combined with 114 issued US patents (expiring 2032 to 2042), 5x-faster EnVe enrolment pods, automated e-gates across 53 airports, and the renewed multi-year American Express statement-credit subsidy, CLEAR+ holds strong switching insulation among premium cardholders and non-PreCheck travellers.

Where the edge is vulnerable. Non-Amex flyers paying $219 out of pocket, after four consecutive $10 annual increases, now have a zero-cost biometric alternative at about 65 airports if they hold TSA PreCheck and fly a participating carrier. In CLEAR1, Clear Secure's reusable 47m member network lowers friction, yet winning Medicare.gov, VA.gov and health systems means sharing sign-in screens directly beside ID.me and Login.gov.

PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 8 MANAGEMENT, GOVERNANCE AND CAPITAL ALLOCATION

Founder owns $1.1bn (15%), dual-class votes ended in July 2026, and buybacks keep shrinking the share count

Exhibit 33: Key executives own $1.1bn combined; annual bonuses tie 70% to bookings and unlevered FCF
ExecutiveTenureHow they are paid (FY25, DEF 14A)What they own (at $54.81)
Caryn Seidman BeckerFounder, Chair & CEO 16.0 yrsFounder; CEO since 2010. Board: Home Depot. $11.56m total, FY25
Salary $0.60m; annual bonus cash $0.96m (94% of target); equity $10.00m. Bonus tied 70% to Total Bookings and unlevered FCF, 30% individual.
$1,062m 14.6%19.38m shares (Alclear Inv., Apr 26 proxy); 1,770x salary. Nov 26: sold 176k sh ($10.7m, 10b5-1).
Jennifer HsuChief Financial Officer 1.7 yrsIn role since Mar 2025. Prior: Chewy, J.P. Morgan. $3.25m total, FY25*
$0.50m annual salary ($0.38m partial yr + $50k reloc.); $0.52m cash; $2.30m equity. Same Bookings and unlevered FCF bonus plan.
$0.53m <0.1%9.7k shares held (excl. unvested RSUs, Apr 26 proxy); 1.1x salary. No recent Form 4 sales.
Jonathan SchlegelChief Security Officer 2.2 yrsIn role since Sep 2024. Prior: DuPont CISO, NSA. n.d. (not named in FY25 proxy)
Pay not disclosed in FY25 proxy; leads cybersecurity, federal security compliance and CLEAR1 trust controls.
$0.24m <0.1%4.4k shares (Apr 26 proxy, excl. unvested RSUs). No Form 4 open-market sales reported.
Recent exits (Oct 2026)President & EVP Aviation TransitionM. Barkin (7 yrs) & K. McLaughlin (4 yrs). $13.52m / $2.69m FY25
President M. Barkin moved to advisor ($300k/mo to Dec 26) & left Board Oct 15; EVP Aviation K. McLaughlin left Oct 2.
$8.6m / $2.1m <0.2%157.7k / 37.5k shares (Apr 26 proxy). McLaughlin sold 4.5k sh ($0.2m, 10b5-1) Sep 26.

Source: 2026 DEF 14A (filed 22 Apr 2026), SEC Form 8-K (16 Sep 2026), SEC Form 4 filings. Holdings valued at $54.81 (18 Nov 2026); excludes unvested awards. *Partial year.

Governance milestone & remaining overhang

Dual-class voting ended on 2 July 2026. All 20-vote Class B and Class D shares automatically converted one-for-one into 1-vote Class A and Class C shares on the fifth IPO anniversary. Over 75% of the Board is independent (Affirm CFO Rob O'Hare joined Jul 2026), with 100% independent committees, clawbacks, and anti-pledging rules. The Up-C Tax Receivable Agreement (TRA) still carries a $268m liability paying pre-IPO holders 85% of tax step-up benefits, and October's two senior departures put extra focus on aviation execution.

Capital allocation & guidance discipline

Management returns excess cash steadily through buybacks and regular dividends. In Q3 FY26 alone, Clear Secure returned $191.4m to shareholders, including $171m in share buybacks (3.7m shares at $46.19), leaving $254m authorised remaining. Diluted shares declined from 139.0m in FY24A to 135.0m in FY25A and 132.8m in Q3 FY26. Regular dividends ($0.60 FY26E) supplement repurchases. FY26 FCF guidance rose three times from $440m (Feb) to at least $490m (Nov), while revenue beat the top of guidance by $6m to $8m in Q1 to Q3 2026.

Exhibit 34: FY26E OCF ($529m) funds $197m buybacks, $100m dividends and distributions, and $106m cash build
Operating cash flow$528.6mCash generated$528.6mShare buybacks$197.2mNet cash build$105.8mDividends & dist.$99.7mAward tax, TRA & dist.$96.1mCapEx (e-gates)$29.8m

Source: Penmark Research model (FY26E cash flow reconciliation)

What it means for value: Strong founder alignment ($1.1bn stake, 14.6%) and consistent buybacks support per-share compounding, though repurchases near $55 carry lower returns than earlier vintages, and October's President and EVP Aviation exits make Q1 FY27 execution a key watch item.
PART 3 · INVESTMENT THESIS · 9 WHAT MOVES THE STOCK

Bookings and margin surprises drive earnings-day moves more than the market does

Clear Secure trades mostly on company-specific surprises rather than market indices. Earnings-day share moves usually follow bookings growth, operating margin gains and free cash flow guidance raises, though Q1 and Q2 FY26 showed modest pullbacks even after headline beats.

Exhibit 35: Four stock drivers explain share moves, price expectations and upcoming catalysts
DriverWhat moves the stockMarket view vs Penmark modelDebateNext number to watch
Active CLEAR+ member growth & bookings Quarterly bookings beats and annual FCF guidance raises (with Q1 and Q2 FY26 pullbacks as exceptions). Price implies FY27E member growth of 6.4% if prepayments count as cash, or 9.3% if treated as financing (vs 7.0% model). Q1 surge renewal & Touchless ID Late Feb (Q4 FY26): $340m bookings, 8.65m active members.
Operating margin & e-gate leverage Direct ambassador salary ratio falling as automated e-gates absorb lane volume. Consensus FY27E EPS ($2.79) is within about 1% of ours, so the Street already assumes margin gains close to ours. e-gate operating leverage Late Feb (Q4 FY26): direct salaries at 16.8% of revenue.
Free cash flow quality & prepayments Headline FCF multiple (~16x, 3.9-year mean) vs cash flow excluding deferred revenue. Treating customer prepayments as financing rather than equity cash cuts DCF value by $10.43/sh. Prepayment cash flow quality Late Feb (FY27 guide): company-defined FCF ($509m est.).
CLEAR1 enterprise & pricing power New healthcare and federal wins, plus subscriber retention after $10 annual price increases. Large CLEAR1 contracts add +$1.46/sh upside; July 2027 $229 rise is in base ($0.73/sh vs flat price). CLEAR1 traction & pricing Early May / Jun-Jul: CLEAR1 wins & $229 renewal test.

Source: Company filings, earnings transcripts (Q3 25 to Q3 26), Yahoo Finance (to 18 Nov 2026), Penmark Research model.

Exhibit 36: Q4 FY25 (+39%) and Q3 FY26 (+24%) led earnings moves, with two Q1-Q2 pullbacks
Q4 FY24Q1 FY25Q2 FY25Q3 FY25Q4 FY25Q1 FY26Q2 FY26Q3 FY26−6.5%−7.6%+6.2%+12.7%+39.0%−4.5%−6.1%+23.7%

Source: Yahoo Finance; SEC Form 8-K earnings dates

Exhibit 37: FCF per share growth (+146 points) drove most of YOU's 199% three-year return
0%+50%+100%+150%+200%FCF/sh growthMultiple chgDividends3Y Total ret.+146%+35%+18%+199%

Source: Yahoo Finance; Company filings; Penmark Research (Nov 2023 to Nov 2026)

Earnings days show how bookings and guidance set the tone. Clear Secure jumped +39.0% on Q4 FY25 results (25 Feb 2026) after renewing its multi-year American Express deal alongside strong FY26 bookings and free cash flow guidance. It rose another +23.7% on Q3 FY26 results (4 Nov 2026) after +24% y/y bookings growth (beating the top of guidance by $7.5m, or about 2%), e-gate margin gains and a third FY26 free cash flow guidance raise to at least $490m. Conversely, when bookings slowed in Q4 FY24 and Q1 FY25, shares fell 6.5% and 7.6%. Q1 and Q2 FY26 were notable exceptions, with shares slipping despite headline beats.

Multi-year returns came mostly from cash flow compounding. Over three years through November 2026, Clear Secure delivered +199% total return (beating the S&P 500 by 125 percentage points). Free cash flow per share growth generated +146 points of that gain, multiple expansion added +35 points and dividends contributed +18 points. Future returns therefore depend on whether underlying free cash flow keeps compounding once the Q1 FY26 surge laps.

PART 3 · INVESTMENT THESIS · 9 FACTOR SENSITIVITY AND INVESTOR FOCUS

Market indices explain less than 5% of weekly returns; investor questions focus on renewals and pricing

Exhibit 38: Market, software and airline indices explain less than 5% of weekly variance
Company-specific shareCombined 3-factor modelAirlines ETF (JETS)Software ETF (IGV)S&P 50095.6%4.4%3.5%1.0%0.5%

Source: Yahoo Finance (3-year weekly returns); Penmark Research

Exhibit 39: CLEAR+ renewals (38%) and pricing/Amex (25%) lead analyst call questions
CLEAR+ growth &renewalsPricing, Concierge & AmexCLEAR1 / enterpriseE-gates, margins & CapExCapital allocation & cash38.3%24.5%19.1%14.9%3.2%

Source: Company earnings call transcripts (Q3 FY25 to Q3 FY26)

Member growth and bookings

What the market does: Over three years, S&P 500, software (IGV) and airline (JETS) indices explain only 4.4% of weekly return variance combined. Investor Q&A concentrates heavily on CLEAR+ member additions, renewals and Touchless ID (38% of questions), and major share moves followed bookings and free cash flow guidance surprises (+39% on Q4 FY25 with the Amex renewal; +24% on Q3 FY26).

Model value vs market: Holding our treatment of customer prepayments constant, the $55 share price needs member growth 2.3 points a year faster than our model. If prepayments count as cash, our growth forecast sits $2 a share above what the price implies. Each 1 percentage point shift in annual member growth moves DCF value by about $3.25 a share.

Next number to watch: Q4 FY26 results in late February (Penmark estimates $340m bookings and 8.65m active members).

e-gate operating leverage and pricing

What the market does: Pricing, Concierge and American Express generate 25% of analyst questions, with e-gates and capital spending adding 15%. Consensus FY27E EPS ($2.79) is within about 1% of ours, so the Street already assumes margin gains close to ours.

Model value vs market: Our base case models direct salaries falling from 21.4% of revenue in FY25A to 17.4% in FY26E and 15.8% in FY27E, alongside a $229 CLEAR+ price rise in July 2027. Holding price flat instead of raising it to $229 would cost about $0.73 a share, while extra e-gate savings beyond base would add $1.30 a share.

Next number to watch: Q4 FY26 direct salaries (Penmark estimates 16.8% of revenue) and Q1 FY27 cohort retention in early May.

Exhibit 40: Macro and balance-sheet factors that do not drive Clear Secure's share price
Factor reviewedEvidence in trading historyWhy it is not a primary driver
US airline stocks (JETS ETF)Weekly R-squared of just 3.5% vs YOU over three years.CLEAR+ subscription revenue depends on member renewals and card credits, not airline seat yields or fuel costs.
Enterprise software (IGV ETF)Weekly R-squared of just 1.0% vs YOU over three years.Investors still price Clear Secure as a consumer travel subscription rather than a software multiple peer.
Broad equity market (S&P 500)Weekly R-squared of 0.5%; stock rallies and sells off on company news.High idiosyncratic risk means quarterly execution dominates broad index direction.
Interest rates & debt leverageZero debt and $633m net cash; minimal analyst Q&A focus on debt or rates (the 3% share in Exhibit 39 covers capital allocation and cash).No refinancing risk, though higher discount rates still reduce DCF value (-$5.85/sh per +100bp).

Source: Yahoo Finance weekly returns (Nov 2023 to Nov 2026), company earnings transcripts (Q3 25 to Q3 26), Penmark Research model.

Trading takeaway: Because index moves explain less than 5% of weekly variance, Clear Secure behaves as an event-driven stock around quarterly earnings, American Express milestones and renewal checkpoints.

Key calendar focus: Three checkpoints over the next nine months will settle the main debates: Q4 FY26 bookings and FY27 guidance in late February, Q1 FY27 surge-cohort renewals in early May, and the July 2027 $229 price test.

PART 3 · INVESTMENT THESIS · 10 PILLAR ONE: CASH FLOW QUALITY

Prepayments add about $125m to FY26E free cash flow; treating them as financing takes $10 a share off value

1 · The claim

Headline free cash flow overstates recurring economic earnings by $261m in FY26E. Prepayment inflows ($117m net of prepaid fees) and stock-based compensation ($50m) explain about $167m of that gap, with interest income, tax items and partnership timing making up the rest. Treating customer prepayments as financing reduces DCF value by $10 a share.

2 · What the market believes

At $55 (about 16x trailing company free cash flow), the market treats deferred revenue inflows as permanent free cash flow. Our valuation bridge splits the $8 gap between our $47 base value and the $55 share price into -$10 a share from prepayment treatment and +$2 a share from our higher member growth view. Treating prepayments as working capital would lift DCF value to $57.

3 · Three independent pieces of evidence

  • Deferred revenue equals 57% of sales: Q3 FY26 Form 10-Q reports $603.6m of deferred revenue against $633.0m of cash and marketable securities. Because deferred revenue rises only when billings outpace revenue, annual inflows shrink from $124m in FY26E to $89m in FY28E as growth slows from 25% to 12%.
  • Stock-based compensation is a real economic cost: Management excludes SBC ($50.1m in FY26E) from Adjusted EBITDA and headline free cash flow, yet shareholders bear it through dilution or offsetting buybacks.
  • Adjusted peer multiples match our DCF: Applying the 22.1x peer median P/FCF to trailing company FCF ($458m) yields $76 a share, but applying the same 22.1x multiple to trailing FCF excluding prepayments and SBC ($277m) yields $46 a share, right beside our $47 DCF.
Exhibit 41: Prepayments and SBC add $150m to $175m a year to headline FCF in FY26E-FY28E
Change in deferred revenueEquity-based compensation$0m$50m$100m$150m$200mFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EActualEstimates$115m$175m$154m$152m

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model

Exhibit 42: Headline FCF vs valued unlevered FCF ($m)
Cash flow line ($m)FY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Company-defined FCF343.1498.8508.7590.6
Less: deferred rev. inflow (net)*(76.4)(117.0)(92.5)(84.1)
FCF excl. prepayments266.7381.8416.2506.5
Less: SBC (non-cash exp.)(38.9)(50.1)(55.7)(62.5)
Less: interest, tax & timing adj.n.a.(93.9)(65.5)(102.0)
Valued unlevered FCFn.a.237.8295.0342.0
Valued FCF / company FCFn.a.47.7%58.0%57.9%

Source: Company filings (FY25A), Penmark Research model (FY26E to FY28E). *FY25A excludes the change in prepaid revenue-share fees.

4 · What it is worth

Prepayment accounting is the single largest valuation swing at $10 a share. Our equity bridge deducts $603.6m of deferred revenue (net of $34.9m prepaid revenue-share fees) and $83.6m of accrued partnership liabilities, and values unlevered FCF without future deferred revenue inflows. If investors instead capitalise the inflows as permanent equity cash, value rises from $47 to $57 a share, flipping Hold to Buy.

5 · Dated signposts

Late Feb 2027 (FY27 guidance): Watch how fast deferred revenue inflows slow as billings growth cools from 28% toward 11% to 12%. May 2027 (Q1 FY27): First quarter under quarterly Amex settlement cadence reveals underlying quarterly cash generation without annual settlement noise.

PART 3 · INVESTMENT THESIS · 11 PILLAR TWO: GROWTH DURABILITY

The 550,000-member Q1 FY26 surge faces its renewal test in May 2027, beside free TSA Touchless ID

1 · The claim

Active CLEAR+ member growth slows from 14% in FY26E to 7% in FY27E. The 551,000-member Q1 FY26 surge (5.1x the trailing four-quarter average) was driven by temporary airport staffing lapses, and its first annual renewal arrives in Q1 FY27 beside free TSA PreCheck Touchless ID.

2 · What the market believes

Holding our treatment of customer prepayments constant, the $55 price needs member growth 2.3 points a year faster than our model (9.3% vs 7.0% in FY27E). If prepayments count as cash, our growth forecast sits $2 a share above what the price implies (6.4% FY27E). Consensus FY27E revenue growth is 15.2%, right in line with our 15.1%.

3 · Three independent pieces of evidence

  • Q1 FY26 additions were an outlier: Active CLEAR+ net additions spiked to 551,000 in Q1 FY26 (5.1x the prior four-quarter average), then settled back to 162,000 in Q2 and 145,000 in Q3 once federal airport wait times normalised.
  • Free biometric competition has reached national scale: TSA PreCheck Touchless ID expanded from 15 airports to about 65 airports by spring 2026 across five participating airlines, giving PreCheck flyers a free facial-scan lane at major hubs.
  • Four straight price hikes test non-card renewals: CLEAR+ list pricing rose from $179 to $219 over four years (our base models $229 in July 2027). Non-Amex subscribers paying out of pocket are most exposed if Touchless ID narrows the perceived time savings.
Exhibit 43: Q1 FY26 added 551,000 net members, about 5x the prior four-quarter average
−200k0k200k400k600kQ1 25AQ2 25AQ3 25AQ4 25AQ1 26AQ2 26AQ3 26A42k−2k172k217k551k162k145k

Source: Company quarterly releases (recast Active CLEAR+ member basis)

Exhibit 44: Member growth sensitivity around $47 base
Annual growth shiftFY27E gr.DCF / shvs base
-2.0pp / yr5.0%$40.68-$6.03
-1.0pp / yr6.0%$43.58-$3.12
Base case (Penmark)7.0%$46.71--
+1.0pp / yr8.0%$50.07+$3.36
+2.3pp / yr (Implied, fin.)9.3%$54.81+$8.10

Source: Penmark Research model (DCF sensitivity on member growth path).

4 · What it is worth

Each 1 percentage point shift in annual member growth moves DCF value by about $3.25 a share. On specific downside risks, surge-cohort churn costs $1.06 a share (50% probability), Touchless ID costs $0.71 (35%), and price elasticity costs $1.10 (35%). Those three sum to about -$2.90 individually; our $31 bear case is a separate run of those pressures at full strength (3% member growth plus lower pricing and margins).

5 · Dated signposts

Early May 2027 (Q1 FY27 results): First renewal readout on the 551,000 Q1 FY26 cohort; thesis confirmed if FY27E member growth holds near 7% and net additions stay positive. Jun-Jul 2027: Retention response to the $229 CLEAR+ list price and updated Touchless ID adoption disclosures.

PART 3 · INVESTMENT THESIS · 12 PILLAR THREE: MARGIN EXPANSION

E-gates lift adjusted EBITDA margin to 38% by FY28E: real progress, but already in the price

1 · The claim

Automated e-gates are delivering real cost leverage, lifting adjusted EBITDA margin from 29% in FY25A to 38% in FY28E. However, airport revenue share stays fixed near 14.7% and ambassadors remain essential for enrolment, so further upside beyond our base case is modest relative to the $55 share price.

2 · What the market believes

Consensus FY27E EPS ($2.79) is within about 1% of ours, so the Street already assumes margin gains close to ours. After Q3 FY26 adjusted EBITDA margin jumped 490 basis points y/y to 35.5%, the share rally priced in near-term e-gate execution, leaving little valuation cushion if labour savings plateau.

3 · Three independent pieces of evidence

  • Labour decoupled from sales in 9M FY26: Direct salaries stayed essentially flat in dollars in the first nine months of 2026 while revenue climbed 25% y/y, pulling the direct salary ratio down 400 basis points to 17.4% for FY26E.
  • Most airports already have e-gates: Automated e-gates now operate at 53 of 62 CLEAR+ airports (85% of airports), with management targeting most airports by end-2026 and noting on the Q3 call that over 96% of travellers clear in under five minutes.
  • Structural cost floors cap long-run margins: Airport revenue share holds near 14.7% from FY27E onward, and ambassadors remain required to sign up new members and resolve document exceptions. Our base model reaches 15.0% direct salaries by FY29E and 32.1% operating margin by FY30E.
Exhibit 45: Direct salaries fall from 27% to 15% of revenue while airport fees stay near 15%
Direct salaries (% rev)Revenue share fee (% rev)Operating margin (%)−60%−40%−20%0%20%40%FY21AFY22AFY23AFY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EActualEstimates15%15%31%

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model

Exhibit 46: Cost structure and margin path (% of revenue)
% of revenueFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Airport revenue share14.2%14.5%14.7%14.7%
Direct ambassador salaries21.4%17.4%15.8%15.3%
G&A, R&D, S&M & D&A43.7%40.2%39.4%38.9%
GAAP operating margin20.7%27.9%30.1%31.1%
Adjusted EBITDA margin28.9%34.7%36.9%37.9%
CapEx (% of revenue)3.3%2.6%2.7%2.6%

Source: Company filings (FY25A), Penmark Research model (FY26E to FY28E).

4 · What it is worth

Extra e-gate savings add $1.30 a share and large CLEAR1 wins add $1.46 a share as separate upside catalysts. Even adding both catalysts to our $47 base value gives roughly $49.50 a share, still below $55. Reaching our $62 bull case requires faster member growth, pricing power and deeper leverage together. At -8.3% total return, the rating rule sets Hold with Low conviction; the Sell line sits near $56.

5 · Dated signposts

Late Feb 2027 (Q4 FY26): Direct salaries at 16.8% of revenue confirm the full-year e-gate run rate. FY27 quarterly results: Operating margin moving past 30% while G&A leverage holds confirms our base; rising airport concession fees or stalled labour savings would trigger downside.

PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 13 TRACK RECORD AND QUALITY OF REPORTED NUMBERS

Sales grew 4.4x in five years and EBIT rose $430m, but prepayments and Up-C items blur profit and cash

Clear Secure delivered an operational turnaround from a $115m operating loss in FY21A to $314m operating profit in FY26E. Yet investors must look past headline FCF and GAAP EPS, both of which carry recurring structural adjustments tied to upfront member billing and the Up-C tax structure.

Exhibit 47: Revenue beat the top of management guidance by $6m to $8m in Q1-Q3 2026
$0m+$2m+$4m+$6m+$8mQ1 26AQ2 26AQ3 26AQ4 26EActualEstimates+$8.0m+$6.8m+$5.9m+$1.0m

Source: Company quarterly releases (Q1-Q3 FY26A vs top of guide); Penmark Research model (Q4 FY26E)

Exhibit 48: Company FCF runs 1.3x to 2.0x net income on deferred revenue and SBC add-backs
Net income (cons./exch.)Company FCF$0m$200m$400m$600mFY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EActualEstimates$225m$284m$168m$343m$258m$499m$317m$509m$366m$591m

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model

Exhibit 49: Quality of earnings audit: four accounting features that flatter or distort headline metrics
Accounting itemFY25A / FY26E scaleEffect on reported numbersPenmark model treatment
Customer prepayments (deferred revenue)+$76m FY25A / +$124m FY26E cash inflowBoosts company FCF to 44.3% of FY26E sales whenever bookings exceed revenue.Treated as financing: stripped from valued FCF and deducted ($604m) in equity bridge.
Stock-based compensation (SBC)$38.9m (4.3%) FY25A / $50.1m (4.4%) FY26EAdded back to Adjusted EBITDA ($391m) and company FCF ($499m); real economic cost.Treated as a cost in valued unlevered FCF ($238m FY26E) and adjusted FCF screen.
Up-C NCI & Tax Receivable Agreement$267.8m TRA liab. vs $315.0m DTA (Q3 26)FY24A GAAP EPS ($1.56) included a $158.6m non-cash valuation allowance tax benefit and $89m TRA remeasurement.Fully exchanged 132.8m share count; 25% normalised tax rate; TRA & DTA netted in DCF bridge (+$47m).
CapEx & capitalised software$29.3m (3.3%) FY25A / $29.8m (2.6%) FY26ELow hardware intensity even during EnVe pod and 53-airport e-gate rollout; clean D&A alignment ($27.1m FY26E).Modelled at 2.6% to 2.7% of sales through FY36E, tracking depreciation closely.

Source: Clear Secure FY21 to FY25 Form 10-K, Q3 FY26 Form 10-Q, Penmark Research model.

Volume and pricing both drove Clear Secure's 37% four-year revenue CAGR (FY21A to FY25A). Revenue expanded from $254m in FY21A to $901m in FY25A with zero currency exposure and no transformational acquisitions ($63m of goodwill reflects small bolt-ons). In FY26E, revenue growth accelerates to 25% ($1,127m), split nearly evenly between average Active CLEAR+ member growth (+12.5%) and revenue per average member growth (+11.2%).

Cash conversion is genuinely strong even after stripping prepayments and SBC. Excluding both customer prepayments and equity-based compensation, Clear Secure converts roughly 101% of GAAP operating profit after tax into economic unlevered free cash flow, with no debt and $633m of cash.

PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 14 FORECASTS

Revenue growth slows from 25% to 12% by FY28E as e-gates lift EBITDA margin to 38%

Our model builds revenue from two explicit drivers: average Active CLEAR+ members multiplied by revenue per average member (including CLEAR1). We sit modestly above FY26E guidance and consensus after three straight $6m to $8m beats, then model an FY27E normalisation as the Q1 FY26 surge cohort cycles.

Exhibit 50: Revenue nearly doubles from FY24A to $1.45bn by FY28E as EBIT margin hits 31%
Revenue ($m)Operating margin (%) (right)$0m$500m$1000m$1500m15%20%25%30%35%FY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28EActualEstimates

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model

Exhibit 51: DCF value spans $39 to $55 across member growth and G&A shifts
$41.93$44.92$48.14$51.61$55.33$41.30$44.25$47.42$50.84$54.50$40.68$43.58$46.71$50.07$53.68$40.05$42.91$45.99$49.30$52.85$39.43$42.24$45.27$48.53$52.03Member growth shift (FY27E-FY36E)-2.0pt-1.0pt0.0pt+1.0pt+2.0ptG&A % rev shift-1.0pt-0.5pt0.0pt+0.5pt+1.0pt

Source: Penmark Research model

Exhibit 52: Core operating driver and margin path (FY25A to FY28E)
Driver / % of salesFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Active CLEAR+ (m)7.628.659.259.86
Member growth (%)6.0%13.6%7.0%6.5%
Rev / avg member ($)$122.86$136.61$144.80$152.05
Rev / member growth (%)n.a.11.2%6.0%5.0%
Airport rev share (%)14.2%14.5%14.7%14.7%
Direct salaries (%)21.4%17.4%15.8%15.3%
G&A + R&D + S&M (%)39.9%37.8%36.9%36.4%
GAAP EBIT margin (%)20.7%27.9%30.1%31.1%
Adj. EBITDA margin (%)28.9%34.7%36.9%37.9%
CapEx (% of rev)3.3%2.6%2.7%2.6%

Source: Company filings (FY25A), Penmark Research model (FY26E to FY28E).

Exhibit 53: Penmark vs consensus and guidance line by line
Metric & periodPenmarkCons./GuideGap
Q4 FY26E Revenue$303.0m$301.2m+0.6%
Q4 FY26E Bookings$340.0m$335-340mTop end
FY26E Revenue$1,126.6m$1,120.0m+0.6%
FY27E Revenue$1,296.3m$1,290.0m+0.5%
FY26E Adj. EPS (ex-SBC)$2.21$2.08+6.1%
FY27E Adj. EPS (ex-SBC)$2.76$2.79-1.1%
FY26E Company FCF$498.8m≥$490.0m+1.8%
FY27E Company FCF$508.7mn.a.+2.0% y/y
FY26E Unlev. FCF valued$237.8mn.a.Ex-prepay
FY27E Unlev. FCF valued$295.0mn.a.+24.0% y/y

Source: Company guidance (4 Nov 2026), Yahoo Finance consensus, Penmark Research model.

Member growth sensitivity±1pp/yr Active CLEAR+ growth (FY27 to FY36E) shifts DCF value by about ±$3.25/share (-$3.12 / +$3.36).
Prepayment treatmentTreating customer prepayments as working capital instead of financing raises DCF value by $10.43/share to $57.13.
G&A / EBIT margin sensitivity±1pp G&A % of sales shift (base 32.1% long-run EBIT by FY30E) moves DCF value by ±$1.44/share.

Why we sit above FY26E guidance and slightly below consensus FY27E EPS. Management beat the top end of revenue guidance by $8.0m, $6.8m and $5.9m across Q1 to Q3 FY26, supporting our $303m Q4 estimate ($1m above guide) and $499m FY26E FCF ($9m above floor). By FY27E, our 7.0% member growth fade and 25% fully exchanged tax rate place our Adjusted EPS ($2.76) 1.1% below consensus ($2.79).

Balance sheet stays debt-free while cash passes $1.0bn. With capital expenditure steady at $30m to $38m a year and deferred revenue tracking 57% of sales, year-end cash and marketable securities rise from $700m (FY25A) to $806m (FY26E) and $1,010m (FY28E), funding $0.60 to $0.73 regular dividends and roughly $200m to $315m a year of share repurchases.

PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 15 VALUATION

DCF values Clear Secure at $47 a share; peer P/FCF on adjusted cash flow gives $46

We value Clear Secure primarily by discounted cash flow (DCF) on unlevered free cash flow excluding customer prepayments, cross-checked against peer price-to-free-cash-flow (P/FCF) multiples. Weighted average cost of capital (WACC, the blended return required by all capital providers, equal here to the 10.04% cost of equity given zero debt) discounts 10.25 years of cash flows plus a 3.0% terminal growth rate (the perpetual steady-state growth rate beyond FY36E).

Exhibit 54: Cash ($0.6bn) offsets net deferred revenue (-$0.6bn); net bridge adds $28m to EV
$0bn$2bn$4bn$6bn$8bnPV FCFsPV TerminalEV (Sep 26)Cash & sec.Def. rev netPartner/TRAEquity value+$2.90bn+$3.19bn$6.10bn+$0.63bn−$0.57bn−$0.04bn$6.12bn

Source: Q3 FY26 Form 10-Q; Penmark Research model ($6,095m EV + $28m net bridge = $6,123m equity)

Explaining the 63% gap between primary DCF ($47) and headline peer P/FCF ($76)

Two accounting items explain the full $30 a share divergence, and once aligned, both methods converge within 1.3%. Applying the 22.1x peer median P/FCF (Netflix, Duolingo, Grindr, Okta, SailPoint, rescaled to 18 Nov 2026 closes) directly to Clear Secure's $458m trailing company-defined FCF yields $76 a share. However, $134m of that trailing cash flow came from customer prepayments (deferred revenue build) and $47m from non-cash stock-based compensation. Stripping both leaves $277m of recurring economic FCF; applying the exact same 22.1x peer median yields $46 a share, within 1.3% of our $47 primary DCF.

Exhibit 55: Core DCF parameters and equity bridge (as of 18 Nov 2026)
DCF input / bridge lineValueBasis
Discount rate (cost of equity)10.04%5.07% Rf + 1.20 beta x 4.14% ERP
Terminal growth / RONIC3.0% / 30.0%Return on new invested capital
PV of FQ4 26E to FY36E UFCF$2,901m47.6% of enterprise value
PV of terminal value$3,194m52.4% of enterprise value
Enterprise value (30 Sep 26)$6,095mUnlevered FCF ex-prepayments
Net equity bridge items+$28m$633m cash - $604m def. rev + net tax/other
Equity value / diluted shares$6,123m / 132.8m$46.11 at Sep 30 to $46.71 at Nov 18

Source: Penmark Research model (equity risk premium, ERP, 4.14%; shares include Class C units).

Why DCF on unlevered FCF excluding prepayments fits best. Pure earnings multiples ignore both the upfront cash benefit and the $604m balance-sheet deferred revenue liability, while headline P/FCF capitalises temporary bookings surges as perpetual earnings. Separating operating cash flow from customer prepayments isolates recurring earning power.

Current multiples versus target multiples. At $55, Clear Secure trades at 28.5x FY26E P/E on fully exchanged EPS (24.8x adjusted EPS ex-SBC), 17.0x FY26E EV/Adjusted EBITDA and 15.9x trailing company P/FCF (6.9% FY26E company FCF yield). At our $50 12-month target, those step down to 25.8x FY26E P/E (20.4x FY27E P/E) and 15.2x FY26E EV/Adjusted EBITDA.

Alternative working-capital treatment. Treating customer prepayments as permanent working capital instead of financing raises base DCF value by $10 to $57 a share, separating our Hold call from Street Buy ratings.

PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 15 VALUATION: SENSITIVITIES, REVERSE DCF AND SCENARIOS

At $55, the price implies 5% perpetual growth or member growth about 2 points a year faster than ours

Reverse DCF, solving backwards from the current share price to find the single assumption that justifies it, shows the $55 price implies slower deceleration (9.3% FY27E member growth, down from 13.6% in FY26E) rather than our 7.0% fade. Three stress tests flip our Hold rating: higher discount rates or beta move the call to Sell, while treating prepayments as working capital moves it to Buy.

Exhibit 56: DCF value spans $39 to $60 across discount rate and terminal growth
$50.81$47.31$44.25$41.56$39.17$52.52$48.70$45.40$42.51$39.96$54.51$50.31$46.71$43.59$40.86$56.86$52.17$48.21$44.81$41.86$59.66$54.37$49.96$46.22$43.01Cost of equity9.04%9.54%10.04%10.54%11.04%Terminal growth2.0%2.5%3.0%3.5%4.0%

Source: Penmark Research model

Exhibit 57: Adjusted peer P/FCF ($46) confirms our DCF; headline FCF and working-capital DCF clear $55
DCF scenarios (Bear-Bull)WACC ±1.0ptDCF (prepayments as cash)Peer P/FCF (adj. FCF, 18-22x)Peer P/FCF (headline, 18-22x)$20$40$60$80$30.96$61.58$40.86$54.51$46.71$57.13$37.64$46.10$62.27$76.27Price $54.81Target $49.63

Source: Penmark Research model; Peer filings (18 Nov 2026; both peer bars span 18.1x min to 22.1x median)

Exhibit 58: Reverse DCF: what the $55 market price implies
Single-input solveBase modelPrice-impliedGap
Terminal growth rate3.00%5.06%+2.06pp
Equity beta (WACC)1.20 (10.04%)0.95 (9.01%)-0.25
Annual member growth shift+7.0% FY27E+9.3% FY27E+2.30pp/yr
Adjusted FCF peer multiple22.1x ($46.10)26.3x+4.2x

Source: Penmark Research model (18 Nov 2026 close, $54.81).

Exhibit 59: Robustness tests that flip the Hold rating
Stress testDCF valueNew ratingTakeaway
Prepayments = working cap.$57.13BuyFlips rating (+$10.43)
Discount rate +1.0pp (11.0%)$40.86SellFlips rating (-$5.85)
Published beta high (1.44)$40.89SellFlips rating (-$5.82)
Published beta low (0.97)$54.08HoldRemains Hold (+$7.37)

Source: Penmark Research model. Published beta range 0.97 to 1.44.

Exhibit 60: Probability-weighted scenarios produce a $50 12-month target and Hold rating
ScenarioWeightIntrinsic value12M targetTotal return*Implied ratingOperating drivers
Bull case25%$61.58$67.10+23.6%BuyLarge CLEAR1 wins, annual price rises, full e-gate labour savings.
Base case45%$46.71$50.74-6.2%HoldMember growth fades to 7.0% FY27E; rev/member +6%; EBIT to 32.1%.
Bear case30%$30.96$33.41-37.8%SellQ1 surge cohort churns; Touchless ID wins PreCheck; pricing & margins stall.
Prob-weighted100%$45.70$49.63-8.3%HoldProbability-weighted 12-month target (-9.5% price / -8.3% total; Low conviction).

Source: Penmark Research model. *Includes $0.66 FY27E regular dividend over 12 months. 12M target rolls intrinsic value forward at cost of equity less dividend.

Limits of scenario weights: Scenario probabilities (25% Bull / 45% Base / 30% Bear) reflect analyst judgement on skewed downside risk given the dated May 2027 surge renewal test, live Touchless ID competition and 18.9% short interest; they are not statistical frequencies. Equal weights (33%/33%/33%) would lift the 12-month target by about $0.80 to $50.40, still inside our -10% to +10% Hold band.
PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 16 CATALYSTS AND 17 RISKS

Q4 FY26 results (late Feb) and the Q1 FY27 renewal test (early May) define the next 12 months

Four scheduled checkpoints over the next 12 months will test Clear Secure's post-surge retention, pricing power and enterprise traction. Because total return (-8.3%) sits near the edge of our Hold band, small changes in either fundamentals or share price can trigger a rating move.

Exhibit 61: Unweighted per-share catalyst and risk impacts (quick-multiple basis)

Upside catalysts (beyond base, except $229 rise*)

CLEAR1 large wins (40%)
+$1.46
Extra e-gate savings (50%)
+$1.30
$229 rise in base (65%)*
+$0.73*
DHS / TSA lapses recur (25%)
+$0.61
PreCheck & channels (40%)
+$0.35

Downside risks (below base)

Price elasticity (35%)
-$1.10
Q1 surge churn (50%)
-$1.06
Touchless ID loss (35%)
-$0.71
Softer travel & rates (40%)
-$0.53

Source: Penmark Research model (quick-multiple basis: change in FY27E revenue x 33.8% x 22.1x P/FCF / 132.8m shares, not DCF). *July 2027 $229 rise is in base (+$0.73 vs flat price).

Exhibit 62: 12 to 18 month catalyst calendar and thesis monitoring framework
Date / EventCore indicatorPenmark vs Cons./GuideThesis confirmed ifThesis broken if (rating change)
Late Feb 2027
Q4 FY26 results
Q4 bookings, direct salaries & FY27 FCF guide.Rev $303m vs $301m cons.; bookings $340m; salaries 16.8%.FY27 FCF slows as prepayment inflow cools; CLEAR1 stays small.CLEAR1 disclosed >5% of bookings or FY27 FCF guide >$560m (toward Buy).
Early May 2027
Q1 FY27 results
Renewal of 551k Q1 FY26 surge cohort & net adds.Base models 7.0% FY27E member growth fade.Active CLEAR+ growth slows cleanly toward ~7%; net adds positive.Member growth falls toward 3% to 4% (Sell) or cohort renews strongly (Buy).
Jun-Jul 2027
Pricing review
CLEAR+ $229 list price & Amex credit match.Base already models $229 rise (+6% FY27E rev/member).The $229 price rise holds without extra subscriber churn.Price held flat (-$0.73/sh) or churn spikes sharply (toward Sell).
2H 2027
e-gate & GovTech
e-gate savings run rate & VA.gov production.Direct salaries fall to 15.8% of FY27E sales.Adj. EBITDA settles at 36% to 38%; VA.gov shares screen.Direct salaries fall faster (<14%) or multi-agency federal contract won (Buy).

Source: Company filings, Q3 FY26 earnings call (4 Nov 2026), Penmark Research model.

Exhibit 63: Key investment risks: downside and upside triggers around our Hold call
Risk factorDirectionLikelihoodModel impactWhat happens and why it matters
Q1 surge cohort churnDownsideMed (50%)-$1.06/shEmergency-queue joiners lapse in May 2027, slowing bookings and deferred revenue.
Touchless ID substitutionDownsideMed (35%)-$0.71/shFree TSA biometric lanes at about 65 airports win out-of-pocket PreCheck travellers.
Price elasticity fatigueDownsideMed (35%)-$1.10/shFour straight $10 price rises to $219 (and $229 in base) curb non-Amex renewals.
Softer air travel & ratesDownsideMed (40%)-$0.53/shSeptember TSA volume dipped 2% y/y while 10-year Treasury yields hit 5.07%.
Amex / aviation exits / cyberDownsideLow-MedTail riskAmex concentration; Oct 2026 exits of President & EVP Aviation; biometric data breach.
CLEAR1 breakoutUpsideMed (40%)+$1.46/shLarge federal or healthcare contract win accelerates B2B revenue beyond base model.

Source: Penmark Research model (unweighted quick-multiple impacts), FY25 Form 10-K Risk Factors, SEC Form 8-K (16 Sep 2026).

What would change our Hold view: Our rating rule implies a Sell above about $56 (+2% from here) and a Buy below about $46. Fundamentally, we would upgrade to Buy on a confirmed multi-year CLEAR1 contract win or proof in May 2027 that the Q1 FY26 surge cohort renews cleanly; we would downgrade to Sell if Active CLEAR+ member growth falls toward 3% to 4% or discount rates rise 100 basis points.
PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 18 OWNERSHIP, TRADING AND STREET POSITIONING

The Street leans bullish with a $70 mean target, while 19% short interest adds two-way earnings risk

Sell-side analysts lean Buy (4 Buy / 1 Hold / 1 Sell; $70 mean target, $50 to $90 range), yet short sellers hold 12.69m shares (18.9% of float per data provider; 12.8% of Class A shares). That positioning widens earnings-day swings (+39% in Feb 2026; +24% in Nov 2026). Our Hold rating rests strictly on our -8.3% total return sitting inside the ±10% band, with Low conviction.

Exhibit 64: Top eight institutional holders (Class A shares, Q3 2026 Form 13F)
Institutional holderShares (m)% Class AQ/Q chg
BlackRock16.2816.4%+2.3%
Vanguard Group13.1513.2%+2.4%
State Street3.863.9%+4.4%
Renaissance Tech.3.723.7%+13.6%
Geode Capital3.333.3%+11.3%
Arrowstreet Capital3.293.3%+22.6%
Morgan Stanley2.712.7%+5.7%
First Trust Advisors2.512.5%-2.9%

Source: SEC Form 13F filings (30 Sep 2026; 98.6% Class A coverage).

Exhibit 65: Institutions hold 74% of diluted shares; founder Caryn Seidman Becker holds 15%
BlackRock & VanguardOther 13F institutionsFounder (Alclear Inv.)Other Class C & insidersDiluted shares (132.8m)22%52%15%11%

Source: 2026 DEF 14A; Q3 2026 Form 13F filings (98.6% Class A coverage)

Exhibit 66: Short interest climbed 46% since May to 13m shares
Short shares (m)Days to cover (right)0m5m10m15m468101205-1505-2906-1506-3007-1507-3108-1408-3109-1509-3010-1510-30

Source: FINRA bi-monthly short interest to 30 Oct 2026 (days to cover uses FINRA settlement-window volume)

Exhibit 67: Trading profile, ownership structure and insider activity
Ownership / trading metricLatest value
Diluted shares (incl. Class C)132.79m (Class A 99.48m)
3M average daily volume / value1.75m shares / $79.5m
52-week trading range (intraday)$30.98 to $69.07
FINRA short interest (30 Oct 26)12.69m sh (18.9% float / 12.8% Class A)
Days to cover (3M avg / FINRA*)7.3 days / 11.0 days*
Institutional Class A 13F coverage98.6% (98.2m sh, Q3 2026)
Founder / Alclear stake (Apr 26)19.38m shares (14.6% diluted)
Recent Form 4 (4 Nov 2026)CEO 10b5-1 sale: 176k sh at $60.47-$61.26
Voting overhang status20-vote Class B/D sunsetted 2 Jul 2026

Source: SEC Form 13F (30 Sep 2026), FINRA (30 Oct 2026), Form 4, Yahoo Finance (18 Nov 2026). *FINRA uses settlement-window volume.

Institutional ownership broadened after the July 2026 dual-class sunset. Converting 20-vote Class B/D stock into 1-vote shares removed an institutional governance barrier, with passive giants BlackRock (16.4% of Class A) and Vanguard (13.2%) plus quantitative funds (Renaissance +13.6%, Arrowstreet +22.6%) adding shares in Q3 2026 while Goldman Sachs trimmed 19.1%.

High short interest amplifies earnings-day moves. Short interest climbed from 8.7m shares in May 2026 to 13.8m ahead of Q3 results before falling 8.2% to 12.69m (7.3 days on 3-month average volume; 11.0 days on FINRA's settlement-window volume). That positioning amplified the +23.7% Q3 earnings rally driven by bookings beats, e-gate margin gains and higher FCF guidance. Planned Rule 10b5-1 CEO sales on 4 November ($10.7m, under 1% of her stake) were pre-scheduled.

PART 5 · APPENDIX · 19 FINANCIAL MODEL

Full five-year financial model and quarterly FY26 progression (fully exchanged basis)

Exhibit 68: Annual income statement, cash flow and balance sheet summary (FY24A to FY28E, US$m unless stated)
Line item (US$m)FY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Income statement (fully exchanged basis; Class C treated as Class A)
Revenue770.5900.81,126.61,296.31,452.8
Revenue growth (%)25.6%16.9%25.1%15.1%12.1%
Cost of revenue share fee108.1127.8163.6190.5213.6
Cost of direct salaries & benefits173.0192.6196.2204.8222.3
R&D + Sales & marketing122.2126.8147.7167.2186.0
General & administrative217.5232.4278.1311.1342.9
Depreciation & amortisation26.534.627.132.436.3
Operating income (GAAP EBIT)123.2186.5313.9390.2451.8
Adjusted EBITDA (EBIT + D&A + SBC)185.0260.0391.1478.3550.6
Interest income & other, net-56.619.636.332.236.0
Income tax (incl. member tax dist. FY26E+)-158.637.992.8105.6122.0
Net income (fully exchanged)225.3168.1257.5316.8365.9
Diluted EPS ($/sh, reported FY24-25A / exch. E)$1.56$1.12$1.93$2.44$2.92
Adjusted EPS excl. SBC ($/sh)n.a.n.a.$2.21$2.76$3.30
Cash flow and balance sheet highlights
Operating cash flow (company basis)295.7372.5528.6543.7628.4
Capital expenditure12.029.329.835.037.8
Free cash flow (company definition)283.7343.1498.8508.7590.6
Free cash flow excl. customer prepaymentsn.a.266.7381.8416.2506.5
Unlevered FCF valued in DCF (ex-prepay, post-SBC)n.a.n.a.237.8295.0342.0
Cash & marketable securities (year end)609.5700.2806.0900.91,009.7
Deferred revenue (year end)439.8516.2640.6738.9828.1
Total assets / Total liabilities1,195 / 9571,303 / 1,0991,432 / 1,2661,514 / 1,3511,610 / 1,447
Total equity (incl. non-controlling interests)237.9204.4166.2163.1163.6

Source: Clear Secure Form 10-K (FY24A to FY25A), Penmark Research model (FY26E to FY28E). FY24A tax benefit reflects valuation allowance release.

Exhibit 69: Quarterly progression: FQ4 FY25A through FQ4 FY26E (US$m unless stated)
Quarterly KPI / metricFQ4 25AFQ1 26AFQ2 26AFQ3 26AFQ4 26EFY26E
Revenue ($m)240.8253.0277.8292.9303.01,126.6
Total bookings ($m)287.1291.7295.9323.5340.01,251.1
Operating income ($m)53.962.083.082.986.1313.9
Adjusted EBITDA ($m)*79.980.6101.1103.9106.9391.1
Adjusted EBITDA margin (%)33.2%31.9%36.4%35.5%35.3%34.7%
Active CLEAR+ members (m, end)7.6168.1678.3298.4748.6498.649
Total CLEAR members (m, end)37.99840.98643.50146.741n.m.n.m.
Deferred revenue ($m, end)516.2554.9573.0603.6640.6640.6

Source: Quarterly releases FQ4 25A to FQ3 26A (recast Active CLEAR+ series), Penmark Research model. *Q1-Q3 26A as reported; FQ4 26E ($106.9m) and FY26E ($391.1m) on model basis (EBIT + D&A + SBC).

Exhibit 70: Per-share data, returns and valuation ratios at $54.81 current share price (FY24A to FY28E)
Per-share & ratio metricFY24AFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Diluted shares, fully exchanged (m)*139.0135.0133.7130.0125.3
Regular dividend per share ($/sh)$0.42$0.50$0.60$0.66$0.73
P/E (reported / fully exchanged) / Adjusted P/E35.1x / n.a.48.9x / n.a.28.5x / 24.8x22.5x / 19.9x18.8x / 16.6x
EV / Adjusted EBITDA (at $54.81)35.9x25.6x17.0x13.9x12.1x
Return on equity (ROE) / Return on assets (ROA)94.7% / 18.9%82.3% / 12.9%154.9% / 18.0%194.2% / 20.9%223.7% / 22.7%

Source: Company filings (FY24A to FY25A), Penmark Research model (FY26E to FY28E). *FY24A and FY25A are year-end share counts; FY26E to FY28E are averages. No debt; net cash $633m at 30 Sep 2026.

PART 5 · APPENDIX · 20 REFERENCE

Non-GAAP reconciliations, peer set, definitions and methodology note

Exhibit 71: Reconciliation from GAAP reported figures to Adjusted EBITDA, Adjusted EPS and valued unlevered FCF (US$m)
Reconciliation lineFY25AFY26EFY27EFY28E
Operating income (GAAP EBIT)186.5313.9390.2451.8
(+) Depreciation & amortisation34.627.132.436.3
(+) Equity-based compensation (SBC)38.950.155.762.5
Adjusted EBITDA (Penmark model basis)260.0391.1478.3550.6
Company-definition Free Cash Flow (OCF - CapEx)343.1498.8508.7590.6
(-) Net inflow from customer prepayments (def. rev - prepaid rev share)*-76.4-117.0-92.5-84.1
Free cash flow excluding customer prepayments266.7381.8416.2506.5
(-) SBC, interest income after tax & timing adjustments to unlevered basisn.a.-144.0-121.2-164.6
Unlevered FCF valued in primary DCFn.a.237.8295.0342.0
Diluted EPS ($/sh) / Adjusted EPS excl. SBC ($/sh)$1.12 / n.a.$1.93 / $2.21$2.44 / $2.76$2.92 / $3.30

Source: Clear Secure FY25 Form 10-K, Q3 FY26 Form 10-Q, Penmark Research model. FY25A sum-of-quarters reported Adj. EBITDA was $262.2m (minor other add-backs). *FY25A excludes the change in prepaid revenue-share fees.

Exhibit 72: Core valuation peer set (five consumer subscription and identity security comparables, 18 Nov 2026)
Company (Ticker)CategoryMarket capTrailing P/FCFLatest-qtr rev growthTTM EBIT margin
Netflix (NFLX)Consumer subscription$246.0bn22.1x11.8%n.a.
Duolingo (DUOL)Consumer subscription$7.6bn20.0x13.7%12.4%
Grindr (GRND)Consumer subscription$2.6bn18.1x22.1%20.7%
Okta (OKTA)Digital identity / security$35.4bn34.4x10.6%n.a.
SailPoint (SAIL)Digital identity / security$12.7bn65.8x16.8%-18.9%
Peer median / Clear Secure (YOU)Subject: $7.3bn diluted$12.7bn22.1x / 15.9x13.7% / 27.8%12.4% / 26.5%

Source: Company filings, Yahoo Finance (rescaled to 18 Nov 2026 closes), Penmark Research model.

Glossary & metric definitions

Active CLEAR+ Members: Paying annual consumer subscribers to Clear Secure's airport biometric lane service at period end (8.474m at 30 Sep 2026; recast series).

Total Bookings: GAAP revenue plus net change in deferred revenue, representing upfront cash billings collected before monthly revenue recognition.

Customer Prepayments (Deferred Revenue): Cash collected upfront for 12-month subscriptions ($603.6m at 30 Sep 2026) recorded as a liability until service delivery.

Up-C / Tax Receivable Agreement (TRA): Partnership structure paying pre-IPO unit holders 85% of realised tax step-up savings ($267.8m TRA vs $315.0m DTA).

Valuation definitions

WACC (Weighted Average Cost of Capital): Blended required return on capital; equals Clear Secure's 10.04% cost of equity (5.07% risk-free rate + 1.20 beta x 4.14% ERP) given zero funded debt.

Reverse DCF: Solving backwards from the current share price ($54.81) to find the single perpetual growth, beta or member-growth assumption that justifies it.

Terminal Growth & RONIC: Steady-state perpetual cash flow growth rate (3.0%) and return on new invested capital (30.0%) beyond FY36E.

Standard-Deviation Valuation Bands: Historical P/FCF plotted against its 3.9-year monthly mean (15.7x) and ±1σ / ±2σ dispersion lines.

Methodology, model cut-off & key disclosures

Archetype & model basis: Clear Secure is modelled as a recurring consumer subscription platform (average Active CLEAR+ members multiplied by revenue per average member) with a business-to-business digital identity option (CLEAR1). All per-share figures use a fully exchanged share count (132.79m diluted shares treating Class C units as Class A); future unit exchanges are not modelled. Data cut-off & limitations: Model date 20 November 2026; share prices as of 18 November 2026 ($54.81). Sources: SEC Form 10-K (FY21 to FY25), Form 10-Q (Q3 FY26), 2026 DEF 14A, Form 8-K, company earnings transcripts, SEC Form 13F, FINRA, Yahoo Finance consensus, TSA and MarketsandMarkets. CLEAR1 revenue is not separately disclosed in SEC filings; consensus Adjusted EBITDA and forward peer FCF were unavailable at cut-off; published equity betas span 0.97 to 1.44 (midpoint 1.20 used).

PART 5 · APPENDIX · 21 DISCLOSURES

Analyst certification and important disclosures

Ratings

Ratings are based on the total return from the share price to our 12-month price target, including dividends. The price target is weighted across bull, base and bear scenarios.

BuyTotal return to price target above +10%
HoldTotal return to price target from −10% to +10%, inclusive
SellTotal return to price target below −10%

We review ratings at each set of results and whenever the facts change materially. A share price can move outside its band before the rating changes, and targets may not be reached.

Analyst certification

The Penmark Team certifies that (1) the views in this report accurately reflect its views about the subject company and its securities, and (2) no part of its compensation was, is or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific ratings, price targets or views in this report.

Contact

Penmark Research

Questions about our research:
research@penmarkresearch.com

All our research and coverage:
penmarkresearch.com

Basis of preparation

This report uses information publicly available up to its publication date. Share prices are closing prices on the trading day before the publication date, unless stated otherwise. Forecasts, valuations and price targets are Penmark Research’s own, and forecast periods are marked E. Sources are shown beneath each exhibit.

Valuation and price targets

Price targets are based on the valuation methods set out in each report and are weighted across bull, base and bear scenarios. The main risks to each rating and price target are described in the report. Penmark Research updates its coverage after each set of results but is not obliged to update a report at any other time.

Independence and conflicts of interest

Penmark Research is independent. It does not provide investment banking, brokerage, market-making or asset management services, does not trade securities, and does not accept payment from any company for research coverage. Companies do not see or review Penmark Research reports before publication.

No member of the Penmark Team holds a long or short position, directly or through derivatives, in the securities of any company Penmark Research covers.

Regulatory status

Penmark Research publishes general, impersonal investment research on a regular basis. It is not registered as an investment adviser with the US Securities and Exchange Commission or any state securities authority, is not a registered broker-dealer and is not a member of FINRA. Penmark Research does not give advice tailored to any person’s circumstances.

Not investment advice or an offer

This report is for information only. It is not personalised investment advice and is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or other financial instrument. It does not take into account any reader’s objectives, financial situation or needs. Readers should make their own investment decisions and seek independent professional advice where appropriate.

Forward-looking statements and risk

Forecasts, valuations and price targets are estimates based on assumptions that may prove wrong, and they may not be achieved. Opinions are current as of the publication date and may change without notice. Investing in equities involves risk, including the loss of capital. Share prices can be volatile, and past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.

Data and sources

Company financials, operating data and filings come from company filings, earnings releases and earnings calls. Market data and any consensus estimates come from third-party sources named beneath the relevant exhibit; consensus figures from aggregators are unofficial. Penmark Research does not use other brokers’ research. Third-party data belong to their providers and may not be extracted from this report.

Accuracy and liability

Information is taken from sources believed to be reliable, but Penmark Research makes no representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. To the fullest extent permitted by law, Penmark Research accepts no liability for any loss arising from use of this report. Descriptions of litigation and regulatory matters reflect allegations and public records, not findings, unless stated. If a published report is corrected, the corrected version carries an “Updated” date at penmarkresearch.com.

Distribution and access

Penmark Research reports are published at penmarkresearch.com. Downloads and programmatic access are governed by the Penmark Research terms of use. This report is not directed at, or intended for, any person in Singapore or India, and access from those countries is blocked. It is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any person in any jurisdiction where that would be contrary to law or regulation or would subject Penmark Research to registration or licensing requirements there.

Copyright and permitted use

© Penmark Research. All rights reserved. Penmark Research is a trade name of Brightriver Labs. Readers may share a link to this report but may not copy, reproduce, redistribute, sell or use its content, including for text and data mining, without written consent. Contact: research@penmarkresearch.com.

Keep reading

Sign in to Penmark