Summary

Initiate at Sell with a US$190 target as the share price outruns cash flow

InitiationBy Penmark Team
PANWSell$190.31-44%
Page 1 of 32
Equity research | Initiation of coverage | United States
Software & Cybersecurity | Coverage: Initiated | Published 19 November 2026, 07:30 ET
Penmark Team | research@penmarkresearch.com
Palo Alto Networks, Inc. (Nasdaq: PANW)

Initiate at Sell with a US$190 target as the share price outruns cash flow

Rating
Initiation
Sell
12-month target
US$190.31
Price, 18 Nov 26
US$339.92
Price return
−44.0%
Total return
−44.0%
Bull case
US$253.08
Bear case
US$107.91

We initiate on Palo Alto Networks at Sell with a US$190.31 target and −44% expected total return. It sells firewalls, cloud software, security operations and identity controls. Next-Generation Security annual recurring revenue (NGS ARR), active annualised cloud and artificial-intelligence (AI) subscriptions, reached US$9.7bn in FQ1 FY27, yet price outruns cash flow.

  • Core growth slows to 14.5% in FY28E, half the 28% pace priced in. Fading emergency patching and the CyberArk lap explain US$41 a share of the gap to market expectations.
  • Stock-based compensation (SBC), interest and tax cut FY27E cash flow in half to US$2.5bn. Ignoring SBC adds US$22 a share, while expensing it as cash cuts fair value to US$137.
  • A 9.5% cost of equity leaves every scenario below the share price. Today’s price implies a 6.0% discount rate, and a 100bp rate rise cuts base value by US$21 a share.

What the market is missing. Standalone FY28E non-GAAP diluted earnings per share (EPS) reaches US$5.01, beating consensus. Applied Compute’s US$240m operating loss and 13.2m new shares pull consolidated EPS to US$4.72, 3% below the Street.

Catalysts. FQ2 FY27 results in February 2027 test recurring growth. Applied Compute closes in spring 2027 with 13.2m new shares, and August 2027 guidance tests the FY28 slowdown.

Valuation and target. Our 15-year discounted cash flow (DCF) gives US$162 a share, valuing free cash flow (FCF) before SBC and charging future grants via new shares. Cash-expensed SBC gives US$137 and peer enterprise value (EV) multiples give US$184. Weighting bear, base and bull gives US$174, rolling forward at 9.5% to our US$190 target.

Risks. An FQ2 FY27 ARR beat adds US$5 a share of upside, and faster AI compute scale adds US$2. Higher bond yields cut value by US$18 a share, and heavier stock grants cut US$11.

Exhibit 1: Revenue compounds at 21% from FY25A to FY29E, yet PANW trades at 72x FY28E non-GAAP earnings
Yr to 31 Jul, US$mFY25AFY26AFY27EFY28EFY29E
Revenue9,22111,48014,69417,07419,600
Growth y/y14.9%24.5%28.0%16.2%14.8%
Non-GAAP EBIT2,6523,3564,2204,7925,735
Margin28.8%29.2%28.7%28.1%29.3%
GAAP net income1,1343078279631,754
Non-GAAP EPS (US$)3.343.844.164.725.95
Growth y/y17.6%15.0%8.4%13.4%26.1%
Free cash flow3,4704,1135,0505,7596,903
At US$339.92, 18 NovFY25AFY26AFY27EFY28EFY29E
P/E (non-GAAP)101.8x88.5x81.7x72.0x57.1x
EV / non-GAAP EBIT104.7x82.7x65.8x57.9x48.4x
P/B30.8x9.4x8.4x7.8x10.6x
FCF yield (per share)1.4%1.6%1.7%2.0%2.4%
Dividend yield0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%
ROE (GAAP)17.5%1.7%2.7%2.7%5.4%
Net debt / EBIT−3.2x−1.8x−2.6x−3.4x−1.4x
P/E at our target57.0x49.6x45.7x40.3x32.0x

Source: Company filings (FY25A–FY26A); Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research model (FY27E–FY29E). Non-GAAP EBIT is the software EBITDA equivalent; multiples at US$339.92 except the final row.

Base value is US$162 a share, and even our US$253 bull case sits 26% below the price

Exhibit 3: Our US$190 12-month target sits 44% below the share price
US$100US$200US$300US$400US$500Jan-26Jul-26Jan-27Jul-27ActualEstimatesPrice US$340Bull US$277 (−18%)Base US$177 (−48%)Bear US$118 (−65%)Target US$190 (−44%)

Source: Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research model

Scenarios and price target basis (present value)
BullUS$253.08−25.5%25% prob.

FY30 NGS ARR tops US$20bn on +6pt higher platform growth. Margin reaches 41% and SBC falls to 5%.

BaseUS$161.72−52.4%55% prob.

Core growth fades from 14.5% in FY28E to 3.5% by FY41E. Margin reaches 38% and SBC falls to 7%, at a 9.5% cost of equity.

BearUS$107.91−68.3%20% prob.

Emergency patching fades and platform growth runs 4pts lower. Margin stalls at 32% while SBC only falls to 12%.

12M target (rolled forward at 9.5%)US$190.31−44.0% total return = Sell
Present value (weighted)US$173.80All cases < US$339.92
Exhibit 4: SBC and amortisation keep GAAP EBIT below 10% from FY26A to FY29E
Income stmt, US$mFY25AFY26AFY27EFY28EFY29E
Revenue9,22111,48014,69417,07419,600
Non-GAAP EBIT2,6523,3564,2204,7925,735
SBC-related charges(1,386)(1,712)(2,278)(2,561)(2,842)
Intang., M&A & other(23)(949)(1,340)(1,200)(1,059)
GAAP EBIT1,2436956021,0321,834
Net interest & notes353(159)175442652
Tax (expense)/ben.(462)(229)49(511)(732)
GAAP net income1,1343078279631,754
Exhibit 5: Deferred revenue and SBC lift headline FCF to US$6.9bn by FY29E
Cash flow, US$mFY25AFY26AFY27EFY28EFY29E
GAAP net income1,1343078279631,754
Stock compensation1,2951,7742,2782,5612,842
D&A and non-cash3438551,1221,5791,701
Def. rev. & work. cap.9441,6171,4191,8091,919
Operating cash flow3,7164,5535,6456,9128,216
Capex (core & AI)(246)(440)(595)(1,153)(1,313)
Free cash flow3,4704,1135,0505,7596,903
Share repurchases0(1,000)(500)(500)(15,362)
Exhibit 6: M&A goodwill lifts total assets to US$59bn while net cash stays positive
Balance sheet, US$mFY25AFY26AFY27EFY28EFY29E
Cash & investments8,4597,90611,04116,2997,840
Work. cap. ex def. rev.4,5215,0075,4376,1476,860
Property & equip.3875238001,4542,066
Goodwill & intang.5,33029,02731,90730,82729,827
Total assets (net)21,89046,28453,46359,00550,871
Deferred revenue12,75214,75616,60419,12321,756
Net cash / (debt)8,4596,13211,04116,2997,840
Shareholders’ equity7,82427,49234,59637,62026,853
Exhibit 7: Diluted shares climb 22% from FY25A to 865m in FY28E
Per share & KPIsFY25AFY26AFY27EFY28EFY29E
Diluted shares (m)709.0764.0850.1865.0836.8
Non-GAAP EPS (US$)3.343.844.164.725.95
Standalone EPS (US$)3.343.844.285.016.11
GAAP EPS (US$)1.600.400.971.112.10
FCF per share (US$)4.895.385.946.668.25
Book value / sh (US$)11.0435.9840.6943.4932.09
NGS ARR (US$m)5,5809,10011,60313,92316,429
Core revenue (US$m)9,22111,48014,64416,77419,000

Source: Company 10-K filings (FY25A–FY26A); Penmark Research model (FY27E–FY29E). Shaded columns are estimates (E). Balance-sheet total assets are stated on the model’s operating-liabilities-netted basis; CyberArk 2029 convertible notes (US$1,774m at FY26A) settle in cash in FY27E.

Standalone FY27E sales beat consensus by 3%, yet consolidated FY28E EPS trails it by 3%

Exhibit 8: Core margins expand while Applied Compute trims FY28E group EBIT
Growth & marginsFY25AFY26AFY27EFY28EFY29E
Growth y/y
Total revenue14.9%24.5%28.0%16.2%14.8%
Core revenue14.9%24.5%27.6%14.5%13.3%
Non-GAAP EBIT21.1%26.5%25.7%13.6%19.7%
Non-GAAP EPS17.6%15.0%8.4%13.4%26.1%
NGS ARR32.2%63.1%27.5%20.0%18.0%
Margins (% of revenue)
Non-GAAP EBIT28.8%29.2%28.7%28.1%29.3%
GAAP EBIT13.5%6.1%4.1%6.0%9.4%
Adjusted FCF38.0%38.4%37.2%38.5%39.6%
FCF ex def. rev.n.d.n.d.21.8%19.0%21.8%
SBC % of revenue15.0%14.9%15.5%15.0%14.5%
Capex / sales2.7%3.8%4.1%6.8%6.7%
Exhibit 9: Goodwill depresses GAAP ROE while current-price P/E stays above 57x
Returns & multiplesFY25AFY26AFY27EFY28EFY29E
Returns and leverage
ROE (GAAP, avg)17.5%1.7%2.7%2.7%5.4%
ROA (GAAP, avg)5.3%0.9%1.7%1.7%3.2%
ROCE (non-GAAP)n.m.32.4%18.8%21.4%28.4%
Net debt / equity−108%−22%−32%−43%−29%
Net debt / EBIT−3.2x−1.8x−2.6x−3.4x−1.4x
Valuation at US$339.92
P/E (non-GAAP)101.8x88.5x81.7x72.0x57.1x
EV / non-GAAP EBIT104.7x82.7x65.8x57.9x48.4x
P/B30.8x9.4x8.4x7.8x10.6x
FCF yield (EV)1.3%1.5%1.8%2.1%2.5%
Dividend yield0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%
P/E at our target57.0x49.6x45.7x40.3x32.0x

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model. ROCE = non-GAAP EBIT / average invested capital (equity less net cash); FY25A invested capital was negative.

Exhibit 10: We sit 3% above FY27E consensus sales and 3% below FY28E EPS
US$m / US$/sh27E SA27E Grp28E SA28E Grp
Revenue (US$m)
Penmark estimate14,64414,69416,77417,074
Consensus (pre-raise)14,16014,16016,23016,230
Prior-year period11,48011,48014,64414,694
Diff. vs consensus+3.4%+3.8%+3.4%+5.2%
Growth y/y (Penmark)+27.6%+28.0%+14.5%+16.2%
Non-GAAP diluted EPS (US$)
Penmark estimate4.284.165.014.72
Consensus (pre-raise)4.184.184.894.89
Prior-year period3.843.844.284.16
Diff. vs consensus+2.4%−0.4%+2.5%−3.5%
Growth y/y (Penmark)+11.5%+8.4%+17.1%+13.4%

Source: LSEG/CNBC & StockAnalysis pre-results consensus (18 Nov 2026); Penmark Research model. SA = standalone; Grp = consolidated incl. Applied Compute. FQ2 FY27 guide: US$3,530m–US$3,550m sales, US$1.01–US$1.03 EPS.

Exhibit 11: Consolidated non-GAAP EPS trails pre-deal FY28E consensus by 3%
ConsensusUS$0US$2US$4US$6FY25AFY26AFY27EFY28EFY29EActualEstimatesUS$3.34US$3.84US$4.16US$4.72US$5.95

Source: Company filings (A); LSEG/CNBC & StockAnalysis consensus; Penmark Research model (E)

Why standalone beats while consolidated EPS trailsStandalone FY28E EPS of US$5.01 beats pre-deal consensus, while Applied Compute brings a US$240m FY28E operating loss and 13.2m new shares.

At 65x trailing free cash flow, PANW trades at almost twice the peer multiple despite slower growth

Exhibit 12: PANW trades at nearly double peer EV/FCF and EV/sales medians
At current pricePANWPeersDiff.
Valuation
EV / LTM FCF65.1x34.4x+89%
EV / LTM revenue22.3x11.0x+103%
FCF yield (EV basis)1.5%2.9%−1.4pp
Dividend yield0.0%0.0%0.0pp
Growth, cash & risk
Revenue growth*19.9%24.3%−4.4pp
FCF margin (pre-SBC)34.3%29.8%+4.5pp
SBC % of revenue15.6%20.7%−5.1pp
FCF margin less SBC18.6%7.0%+11.6pp
Net cash / EV2.6%5.6%−3.0pp
Equity beta1.05x1.14x−0.09x

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model. Peers (CRWD, FTNT, ZS, NET, OKTA) use 16 Nov 2026 closes, and PANW uses 18 Nov. *PANW growth compares the FY27 guidance midpoint with FY26 pro forma revenue adjusted for CyberArk only. Peer growth mixes reported LTM, nine-month and half-year bases. Peer median FCF margin less SBC is 7.0%, while the difference of medians is 9.1pp.

Exhibit 13: Four dated catalysts test growth and dilution through August 2027
  • Feb 27FQ2 FY27 results: NGS ARR vs US$10.20bn–US$10.22bn guide (+US$5.26/sh bull).
  • Spr 27Applied Compute close: ~13.2m est. share issue and ~US$2.4bn est. capex start.
  • Mid 27SASE agentic metering launch: monetises 9x y/y AI traffic (+US$1.52/sh).
  • Aug 27Initial FY28 guidance: tests post-patching deceleration (−US$6.86/sh).

Source: Company calendar; Penmark Research model.

Exhibit 14: Rate compression and SBC lead probability-weighted risks
  • Higher-for-longer rates. 5.10% 10Y yield compresses multiples. Prob. 40%; −US$17.54/sh.
  • Persistent SBC dilution. FY28E stock pay runs 2pts higher near 17% of sales. Prob. 55%; −US$10.89/sh.
  • Patching wave fades. Emergency AI budgets normalise in FY28. Prob. 40%; −US$6.86/sh.
  • FQ2 FY27 ARR beat (upside). Beats US$10.22bn ARR guide. Prob. 60%; +US$5.26/sh.
The thesis is invalidated ifOrganic core revenue compounds above 22% across FY28E–FY30E, SBC falls below 10% of revenue, and the 10-year Treasury yield drops below 3.5%.

Source: Penmark Research model.

Exhibit 15: At 65x trailing free cash flow, PANW trades near two standard deviations above its 3-year mean
0x20x40x60x80x202420252026Mean 41.4x+1 SD 53.9x−1 SD 29.0x+2 SD 66.4x−2 SD 16.5x65.1x, +1.9 SD

Source: Company filings; Yahoo Finance monthly closes, Dec 2023 to Nov 2026; Penmark Research

Monthly EV/trailing FCF derived from monthly closes and reported period FCF, shares and net cash.

Exhibit 16: PANW trades at 22x sales on 20% guided pro forma growth, above the peer fit line
0x10x20x30x40x50x10%20%30%40%EV / LTM revenueRevenue growth (%)PANWOKTAFTNTZSCRWDNETR² 0.37, n=5

Source: Company filings; Yahoo Finance (peers 16 Nov 2026, PANW 18 Nov 2026); Penmark Research model

PART 1 · SUMMARY · 3 THE THESIS IN CHARTS

Six exhibits trace why US$9.7bn of NGS ARR still leaves 44% downside

Strong recurring bookings explain the rally, but ongoing share dilution and slowing growth cap intrinsic value. Granting every optimistic sell-side convention at once lifts base value only to US$264 a share, still US$76 below the share price.

Exhibit 17: Next-Generation Security ARR climbed 74% to US$9.7bn, lifted by CyberArk and Chronosphere
NGS ARR (US$bn)Quarter-end share price (right)US$0bnUS$2bnUS$4bnUS$6bnUS$8bnUS$10bnUS$150US$200US$250US$300US$350US$400FQ4FY25FQ1FY26FQ2FY26FQ3FY26FQ4FY26FQ1FY27

Source: SEC Form 10-K/8-K filings and presentations; Yahoo Finance

Exhibit 18: Core revenue growth fades to 15% in FY28E, half the 28% pace the share price requires
Total revenue growthCore revenue growth0%10%20%30%FY26AFY29EFY32EFY35EFY38EFY41EActualEstimates3.5%3.5%Implied FY28E core growth, 28.3%

Source: Company filings (FY26A); Penmark Research model (FY27E-FY41E)

Exhibit 19: Stock pay, interest and tax strip half of FY27E free cash flow
US$0mUS$2,000mUS$4,000mUS$6,000mCompany FCFSBC chargesNet interest &tax adj.Unlev. FCFafter SBCUS$5,050m−US$2,278m−US$253mUS$2,519m

Source: Penmark Research model, FY27E

Exhibit 20: Granting every sell-side convention lifts base value to US$264, still US$76 below the price
0100200300400BaseDCFExcludeSBC9.0%disc. & 4.0% g+2ptgrowth & 41% marginHolddef. rev. at 113%Sell-sidemaxUnexplainedpremium18 Novprice162+22+32+45+3264+76340

Source: Penmark Research model (Market Check walk, US$/share)

Values in US$ per share.

Exhibit 21: Even at US$340, PANW trades between the 70x and 85x non-GAAP earnings bands
PricePrice at each multiple of non-GAAP EPSUS$100US$200US$300US$40020242025202640x55x70x85xUS$340 (81.7x)

Source: Company filings; Yahoo Finance monthly closes; Penmark Research model

Bands apply reference multiples to interpolated fiscal-year non-GAAP diluted EPS.

Why the re-rating breaks. PANW traded between 55x and 70x non-GAAP earnings during 2024 and 2025. Paying 82x FY27E earnings while guided pro forma growth of 20% trails peers leaves acute multiple-compression risk.
Exhibit 22: PANW pairs 20% pro forma growth with a 34% cash margin, near peers at half its multiple
30%50%10%22%10%40%LTM FCF marginPro forma / peer revenue growthCircle area: market cap (US$bn)Cash cow, slowerFast growth, high FCFBelow median on bothGrowth over marginPANWCRWDFTNTZSNETOKTA

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model

PART 1 · SUMMARY · 4 KEY DEBATES

We sit below the market on all four debates, explaining about US$102 a share (57%) of the gap

Tested one at a time, four divides explain 57% of the US$178 gap to base value. Stacking all four lifts base value to US$264 a share, leaving an unexplained US$76 premium.

Exhibit 23: We take the conservative side on post-patching growth, discount rate, stock pay and steady-state margins
Debate Market view Penmark view Evidence What changes our view Resolves
Post-patching growth Growth runs 4pts higher across FY28E–FY31E, worth US$203.11 a share; price implies 28.3%. Core growth slows from 27.6% in FY27E to 14.5% in FY28E and 10.8% by FY31E: US$161.72, or −US$41.40. Emergency AI patching lasts at least 18 months. CyberArk closed 11 Feb 2026 and laps in FQ3 FY27; guided pro forma growth is 19.9%. Initial FY28 organic core growth guidance above 22%. Aug 2027
Discount rate Cost of equity sits 100bp lower at 8.50%, worth US$190.75 a share; price implies 6.04%. 9.50% cost of equity: 4.46% normalised risk-free rate (12-month average) plus 1.05 beta times 4.80% equity risk premium (−US$29.03 vs 8.50%). US 10-year yield hit 5.10% on 17 Nov 2026, with 51.5% of EV in terminal value. Shares fell 23.0% from 27 Oct to 17 Nov. Sustained 10-year yields below 3.5% with lower equity risk premiums. Dec 2026–Mar 2027
Stock compensation Excluded from FCF with zero future dilution: US$183.77 a share Street upper bound. Charged via dilution at US$338.40 for US$161.72 a share (−US$22.06), or US$137.41 as cash. FY26A operating SBC was US$1,712m, or 14.9% of sales; FQ1 FY27 hit US$622m, or 18.1%, as shares rose 18%. GAAP SBC charges below 10% of sales with shrinking diluted shares. Sep 2027
Long-term margin Core non-GAAP margin reaches 41% at maturity (US$170.81/sh). Core margin reaches 38% from FY38E (−US$9.10 vs 41%); Applied Compute dilutes near-term margin. Standalone FY27E margin is flat at 29.5%. Applied Compute brings a US$240m FY28E loss and US$2,400m est. 4-yr capex. FY28E non-GAAP margin above 31.5% with AI capex below US$1.5bn. May–Aug 2027

Source: SEC filings; Federal Reserve; Penmark Research model (Market Check sheet). Per-share gaps show one-at-a-time shifts from US$161.72 base value.

Exhibit 24: Four debates account for about US$102 a share, or 57% of the gap to base value
Market settingPenmark basePost-patching growthDiscount rateStock compensationLong-term marginUS$161.72US$203.11US$161.72US$190.75US$161.72US$183.77US$161.72US$170.81

Source: Penmark Research model (Market Check debates, one driver at a time)

Zero robustness tests flip the rating. Across all eight stress tests, including an 8.5% discount rate and excluding SBC, upside stays between −35% and −70%.

How the debates map to our thesis chapters

Three chapters test these four divides. Our growth chapter tests Post-patching growth, worth US$41 a share, alongside Long-term margin, worth US$9 a share. Our cash-quality chapter tests Stock compensation, worth US$22 a share, and advance billings. Our valuation chapter tests Discount rate, where a 100bp cut adds US$29 a share.

Why consensus targets misprice PANW

Bulls apply high-growth multiples to headline FCF without charging stock pay. The US$399 average Street target capitalises adjusted FCF, guided at a 38% FY27 margin, while ignoring share dilution.

Exhibit 25: All four valuation debates reach hard data checkpoints between December 2026 and September 2027
Dec 2026FOMC rate decisionTests 5.10% 10Y yield &ERPFeb 2027FQ2 FY27 resultsNGS ARR vsUS$10.20-10.22bn guideMay 2027FQ3 FY27 & AppliedCompute13.2m share issue & capexstartAug 2027Initial FY28 guidanceTests post-patching fadeto 14.5%Sep 2027FY27 10-K filingFull-year SBC & sharedilution

Source: Company calendar; Federal Reserve schedule; Penmark Research

PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 5.1 THE STORY

Palo Alto Networks generated US$4.1bn of free cash flow in FY26 but only US$0.3bn of GAAP net income

Founded in 2005 to replace blind network firewalls, Palo Alto Networks now guards networks, clouds, security centres and identities for more than 70,000 organisations. Its consolidation model wins enterprise budgets, yet deferred revenue and employee stock grants disguise how little cash reaches each share.

21 yrsIncorporated 2005, Santa Clara
70,000+Enterprise & public customers
US$11,480mRevenue, FY26A, +24.5% y/y
US$21.0bnContracted backlog, FQ1 FY27
US$284,853mMarket cap at US$339.92

The scene

In summer 2026, a major telecom carrier signed a US$126m deal with Palo Alto Networks across its network, identity vaults and security centre. PayPal signed a US$53m multi-product contract in the same quarter. Across the group, 78 accounts spend over US$10m a year on cloud and AI security, up 50% year on year.

What it actually does

Enterprises once stitched together dozens of point security tools. Palo Alto Networks sells three linked control planes: Network and AI Security covers firewalls and Secure Access Service Edge (SASE), Cortex automates security operations centres (SOCs), and Idira secures identities via CyberArk.

How the money comes in

Subscriptions and support supply 80% of sales under multi-year deals, and product adds 20%, with hardware near 10%. Of each US$1 of FY26A sales, 70¢ cleared delivery costs, yet only 6¢ survived as generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) operating profit. Advance billings and working capital added US$1.6bn of cash and stock-based compensation added US$1.8bn, lifting free cash flow to 36¢ per dollar.

Where the story turns

Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Nikesh Arora arrived in June 2018 and turned a firewall vendor into a serial acquirer. In February 2024 he launched platformisation, granting free transition months to displace rivals. He closed CyberArk in February 2026, and on 18 November 2026 agreed to buy Applied Compute for US$4.5bn in stock. We expect the business to need about US$2.4bn of data-centre capex through FY30.

Why it works, and why it might not

Wiring firewall rules, SOC telemetry and privileged identities into one vendor makes switching painful. Platformised accounts post a 120% net retention rate (NRR), expanding spend by 20% net of churn. Valuation math breaks per-share returns: Post-patching growth cools once emergency AI upgrades and the CyberArk lap pass, while Stock compensation and AI capex dilute per-share cash.

14.9%FY26A SBC charges / sales
Operating stock-based compensation cost US$1,712m in FY26, nearly six times GAAP net profit of US$307m.Source: FY26 Form 10-K. Cash-flow SBC was US$1,774m; charging future share grants via dilution cuts DCF base value by US$22 a share.
1 · HOW THEY FIND IT
30%Two-tier channel leads sales; two distributors handled 30% of FY26A revenue.
2 · WHAT THEY BUY
3 pillarsNetwork, Cortex SOC and Idira identity; 78 accounts exceed US$10m NGS ARR.
3 · WHAT THEY PAY
120% NRRMulti-year subscriptions expand 20% net of churn, with about 30% billed annually.
4 · WHAT PANW KEEPS
17.1¢Each US$1 of FY27E sales yields 34.4¢ of headline FCF, or 17.1¢ after stock pay and tax.

Source: Channel, platform, retention and cash-retention unit economics from FY26A filings and FY27E model ratios (US$2,519m unlevered FCF after SBC on US$14,694m revenue).

Why the story matters for the stockPalo Alto Networks is an exceptional franchise priced as if acquisition-boosted growth and deferred-revenue inflows were permanent free cash flow. Our growth and cash-quality chapters show why consolidated FY28E EPS lags consensus and cash flow after stock pay sits at half the headline figure.
PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 5.2 HOW THE COMPANY MAKES MONEY

Subscriptions generate 80% of FY26A revenue, yet acquisitions and stock pay consume GAAP profit

Exhibit 26: Seven milestones from 2005 to 2026 turned a firewall pioneer into a US$11.5bn multi-platform vendor
2005
Founded in Santa ClaraNir Zuk incorporates PANW to inspect application traffic rather than ports.2005 Delaware inc.
2012
Public listing & scaleAdopts public equity plans alongside its July 2012 initial public offering (IPO).Jun 2012 equity plan
2018
Arora named CEONikesh Arora joins in June 2018, launching cloud and SOC acquisitions.US$5,502m FY22A sales
2024
Platformisation pivotOffers free transition periods so enterprises consolidate point tools.~1,000 FQ4 FY24 bundles
Nov 25
Chronosphere dealAdds cloud-native observability alongside FQ1 FY26 results.ARR >2x in 2 qtrs
Feb 26
CyberArk closesCompletes CyberArk on 11 Feb 2026, forming Idira identity security.US$1,260m pro forma rev
Nov 26
Applied ComputePosts US$9.73bn FQ1 FY27 NGS ARR and signs US$4.5bn AI-compute stock deal.US$11,480m FY26A rev
Turning pointMilestoneToday (19 Nov 2026)

Source: FY26 Form 10-K; 2026 DEF 14A proxy; FQ4 FY26 presentation; FQ1 FY27 Form 8-K.

Exhibit 27: Business model map: US$11.5bn of FY26A revenue flows through three platforms to US$0.7bn GAAP EBIT and US$4.1bn FCF

1 · Customers

70,000+ orgsGlobal enterprise & government accounts
~2,280 bundlesNetSec & Cortex platformisations (FQ3 FY26)
78 >US$10m ARRUp 50% y/y; 223 >US$5m NGS ARR (FQ4 FY26)
Top-10 share: n.d.End-customer concentration not disclosed

2 · Offerings

Network & AIUS$8,354m (72.8% of FY26A)
Cortex SOCUS$1,920m (16.7% of FY26A)
Idira identityUS$614m rep., 5.3%; US$1,260m pro forma
Other servicesUS$592m (5.2% of FY26A)

3 · Streams

Subscriptions & supportUS$9,200m (80.1% of FY26A) · 1–3 yr contracts
Product revenueUS$2,280m (19.9% of FY26A) · hardware ~10%
Billing terms~30% annual billing; FY26A def. rev. 129%

4 · Channels

Two-tier channelIndirect distributors, value-added resellers (VARs)
30% top-2 dist.Two distributors handled 30% of FY26A sales
Americas 66.9%US$7,679m (+24%); EMEA US$2,428m (+27%); APAC US$1,373m (+25%)

5 · Cost to serve

Cost of revenueUS$3,403m (29.6%) · 70.4% GAAP gross margin
Sales & mktgUS$3,931m (34.2% of FY26A)
R&D + G&AUS$2,552m (22.2%) + US$899m (7.8%)

6 · What is left

GAAP EBIT: US$695m6.1% margin; GAAP net income US$307m (2.7%)
Non-GAAP EBITUS$3,356m (29.2% margin) before SBC/amort.
SBC: US$1,712m14.9% of sales; +US$1,617m billings & WC
FCF: US$4,113m35.8% FCF margin; cash-flow SBC US$1,774m
US$9.73bnNGS ARR, FQ1 FY27 · +66% y/y
US$21.0bnRPO backlog, FQ1 FY27 · +35% y/y
120%Platformised NRR, FQ4 FY26
US$1.6bnSASE ARR, FQ3 FY26 · +~40% y/y
US$700mXSIAM ARR, FQ4 FY26 · +70% y/y

Source: FY26 Form 10-K; FQ4 FY26 presentation; FQ1 FY27 Form 8-K; Penmark Research model. Segment operating profit is n.d.

What Palo Alto Networks sells and why enterprises consolidate

Platformisation trades short-term discounting for multi-pillar lock-in across network, SOC and identity. Platformised accounts supply 65% of NGS ARR and retain 120% of prior-year spend. Segment operating profit is not disclosed.

How contracts are priced, billed and converted into cash

Revenue equals installed security modules multiplied by user, bandwidth or telemetry tiers. Multi-year contracts lift deferred revenue to 129% of FY26A sales and 113% in FY27E, pulling cash ahead of GAAP profit.

What this shows for valueHeadline FCF of US$4.1bn is 13 times GAAP net profit mainly because cash-flow stock pay of US$1.8bn, depreciation and amortisation and US$1.6bn of billing and working-capital inflows bridge the gap. As growth slows, working-capital inflows narrow while share dilution compounds.
PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 5.2 HOW THE COMPANY MAKES MONEY (CONTINUED)

Of every US$1 of FY26A revenue, 56¢ goes to sales and R&D, leaving 6¢ in GAAP operating profit

Exhibit 28: Network and AI generates US$8.4bn of FY26A's US$11.5bn revenue across three regions
AmericasUS$7,679mEMEAUS$2,428mAPACUS$1,373mFY26A revenueUS$11,480mNetwork & AIUS$8,354mCortexUS$1,920mIdira identityUS$614mOther servicesUS$592m

Source: FY26 Form 10-K geographic note; FQ4 FY26 earnings presentation

Exhibit 29: Sales, marketing and R&D absorb 56% of FY26A revenue, leaving a 6% GAAP operating margin
Subscription & supportUS$9,200mProduct revenueUS$2,280mRevenueUS$11,480mCost of revenueUS$3,403mGross profitUS$8,077mSales & marketingUS$3,931mResearch & developmentUS$2,552mGeneral & administrativeUS$899mOperating profitUS$695m

Source: Audited FY26 Form 10-K income statement (US$m)

Fixed versus variable costs and limits on operating leverage

Cloud hosting, hardware build and support scale with volume, while R&D and sales carry heavy stock grants. FY26A gross margin reached 75.8% non-GAAP versus 70.4% GAAP. Sales and marketing took 34.2% of sales and R&D took 22.2%, holding GAAP operating margin to 6.1%.

Applied Compute adds physical data-centre fixed costs. Standalone FY27E non-GAAP margin holds at 29.5%, while Applied Compute’s losses pull consolidated FY28E margin to 28.1%.

Why this flow mattersNon-GAAP operating profit of US$3.4bn is nearly five times GAAP profit of US$0.7bn after excluding US$2.7bn of stock pay, deal amortisation and other items.
Exhibit 30: Core platforms generate over 99% of FY27E's US$14.7bn revenue
Network & AIUS$9,816m (+17.5%)CortexUS$2,669m (+39.0%)Idira identityUS$1,520m (+20.6%)Other servicesUS$639m (+8.0%)Core platformsUS$14,644m (+27.6%)FY29E baseUS$600mFY27-30E capexUS$2,400mApplied ComputeUS$50m (new)Total revenue, FY27EUS$14,694m (+28.0%)

Source: Penmark Research model (Revenue Build)

Idira growth is measured against FY26A pro forma revenue of US$1,260m.

75.8%FY26A non-GAAP gross margin
70.4%FY26A GAAP gross margin
29.2%FY26A non-GAAP EBIT margin
38.0%Steady-state core margin, FY38E+
PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 5.2 HOW THE COMPANY MAKES MONEY (CONTINUED)

Stock pay and working-capital inflows make up over 80% of FY26 free cash flow

Exhibit 31: The Americas generated 67% of FY26A's US$11.5bn revenue
11.5bnFY26A revenueAmericas (+24% y/y)67%7.7bnEMEA (+27% y/y)21%2.4bnAPAC (+25% y/y)12%1.4bn

Source: FY26 Form 10-K geographic note

Values in US$bn (FY26A total US$11,480m).

Regional mix and channel concentration

The Americas anchor two-thirds of sales, while distributors carry billing concentration. Americas revenue rose 24% in FY26A to US$7.7bn, with EMEA and APAC up 27% and 25%. Two distributors handled 30% of FY26A sales; single end-customer share is not disclosed.

Volume and price drivers inside platformised accounts

Expansion attaches SASE, XSIAM and Idira modules onto firewall estates. Net new platformisations rose from 60 in FQ1 FY26 to about 220 in FQ4 FY26, lifting accounts above US$10m NGS ARR to 78 and XSIAM sites to 1,000.

Exhibit 32: Platformisation lifted Next-Generation Security ARR to US$9.7bn and large accounts to 78
NGS ARRFQ1 FY27: 9.7bnFQ4 FY25FQ1 FY27Total RPOFQ1 FY27: 21.0bnFQ4 FY25FQ1 FY27XSIAM sitesFQ4 FY26: 1,000FQ2 FY26FQ4 FY26Large acctsFQ4 FY26: 78FQ2 FY26FQ4 FY26

Source: Company quarterly filings and presentations; FQ4 FY26 deck; FQ1 FY27 Form 8-K

NGS ARR and Total RPO in US$bn; Large accts = customers above US$10m ARR.

Exhibit 33: Non-cash stock pay, D&A and billings turned US$0.3bn of FY26A profit into US$4.1bn of FCF
US$0mUS$1,000mUS$2,000mUS$3,000mUS$4,000mUS$5,000mGAAP net incomeStockcompensationD&ADef. rev. & workingcap.Operating cashflowCapexHeadline FCFUS$307m+US$1,774m+US$855m+US$1,617mUS$4,553m−US$440mUS$4,113m

Source: FY26 Form 10-K cash flow statement; Penmark Research model

Why cash outpaces earnings today and narrows tomorrow

Multi-year advance subscription billings keep generating deferred-revenue inflows while revenue grows, and shrink as growth slows. Revenue growth moderates from 28.0% in FY27E to 3.5% by FY41E. Deferred revenue eases from 129% of sales in FY26A to 108% from FY32E, narrowing working-capital tailwinds mechanically.

Why we value PANW on DCF rather than trailing EV/FCFA single-year EV/FCF multiple treats US$1.6bn of billing and working-capital inflows and US$1.8bn of employee share grants as recurring distributable profit. Our 15-year DCF captures both billing normalisation and ongoing share issuance.
PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 6 THE CYBERSECURITY MARKET

Global security spending grows 12%–17% into 2027, yet AI emergency budgets are cyclical

Enterprise security demand is expanding, though third-party series differ by scope. Gartner forecasts global information-security spend rising 11.6% to US$276bn in 2027, while International Data Corporation (IDC) projects a broader market rising 16.6% to US$362bn.

Exhibit 34: External 2027 security-spending forecasts reach US$276bn at Gartner and US$362bn at IDC
CY26ECY27EIDC security marketGartner info securityUS$310.4bnUS$361.9bnUS$247.4bnUS$276.1bn

Source: Gartner and IDC public forecasts compiled Nov 2026

Gartner and IDC use distinct market definitions and forecast vintages.

10.2%Canalys/Omdia global cyber tech share, calendar Q2 2025
~US$340bnManagement 2030 total addressable market (TAM)

Bottom-up market structure: seats, traffic and telemetry

Enterprise security spend equals protected identities, inspected network bandwidth and ingested security-log volume multiplied by annual tier pricing. Gartner placed 2026 end-user information-security spending at US$247bn, rising to US$276bn in 2027. Management estimates a 2030 TAM near US$340bn across network security, Cortex and Idira identity.

Exhibit 35: PANW spans three security layers while two distributors handle 30% of FY26A revenue
Cloud & silicon infraAWS, Azure, GCP, customASICsHosting & hardware fabNetwork & SASEPANW, Fortinet, Zscaler,NetskopeUS$8.35bn FY26A NASEndpoint & identityPANW (Cortex/Idira),CrowdStrike, OktaUS$1.26bn pro forma IdiraAI SOC & telemetryPANW(XSIAM/Chronosphere),MicrosoftUS$1.92bn FY26A CortexChannel & MSSPsTwo-tier distributors,VARs, GSIsTop 2 dist. = 30% revPANW unified platformisation footprint (US$11.48bn FY26A revenue)

Source: FY26 Form 10-K; FQ4 FY26 presentation; Penmark Research

Demand drivers and cycle position

AI exploits opened emergency budgets in 2026, creating a temporary surge. Critical vulnerabilities jumped roughly sevenfold year on year and agentic traffic rose ninefold, sparking a patching wave of at least 18 months alongside a partial firewall refresh.

Concentration and market share

Cybersecurity stays fragmented, with PANW at 10.2% of cyber tech spend. Canalys/Omdia placed PANW first at 10.2% in calendar Q2 2025 across broad cyber technology rather than firewall or SASE alone. Gartner and IDC named PANW a 2026 Leader in Hybrid Mesh Firewall and SASE.

Who earns the industry margin

Software control-plane vendors earn 70%–80% gross margins, while cloud hosts and partners take fixed slices. Public clouds charge compute and egress fees, and distributors earn resale rebates without retaining recurring software rights.

Technology, regulatory and substitution threats

Bundled hyperscaler security and commoditising AI features cap pricing power. Microsoft bundles Defender and Sentinel into E5 licences, and management expects frontier AI defence to commoditise within two years, risking US$7 a share.

~7x y/yCritical vulnerability surge cited
≥18 mosManagement patching-wave horizon
~9x y/yAgentic network traffic growth
6–9 mosExpected SASE agentic metering
What the industry backdrop means for our Sell callA 12%–17% industry growth tailwind supports mid-teens organic growth at PANW, not the 28% FY28E core pace priced into the shares. Once the emergency patching wave normalises after at least 18 months, PANW’s top line converges toward secular market growth.
PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 7 COMPETITIVE POSITION

PANW leads peers on multi-pillar breadth at US$12.5bn of LTM sales, yet trails Fortinet by about 29pp on GAAP margin

Exhibit 36: At US$12.5bn of trailing revenue, PANW is more than double CrowdStrike's US$5.4bn scale
PANWFTNTCRWDZSOKTANETUS$12,451mUS$7,881mUS$5,396mUS$3,353mUS$3,073mUS$2,733m

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model (Peers tab)

Scale comes partly from M&A rather than organic efficiency. PANW’s 19.9% FY27 guided pro forma growth, adjusted for CyberArk only, lags the 24.3% reported peer median across Cloudflare, Zscaler, CrowdStrike, Fortinet and Okta.
Exhibit 37: PANW leads in multi-pillar breadth and firewall scale, while Fortinet leads on GAAP cost efficiency
PANWCRWDFTNTZSHybrid mesh firewallCloud SASE & SSEAI SOC / SIEMPrivileged identityEnterprise channelGAAP cost disciplineNoneWeakFairStrongLeading

Source: Penmark Research assessment; Gartner and IDC 2026 reports; company filings

Qualitative capability scores reflect Penmark Research assessments informed by 2026 Gartner/IDC reports and GAAP filings.

Exhibit 38: PANW spans network, SOC and privileged identity on one vendor roster, creating high multi-module switching costs
Pillar (FY26A rev.) Primary rivals & substitutes Customer buying criteria PANW competitive rank & moat evidence
Network & AI
(US$8,354m · 72.8%)
Fortinet, Zscaler, Check Point, Cisco, Cloudflare, native cloud firewalls. Zero-trust policy consistency across data centres, branches and AI agents. Co-leader with Fortinet & Zscaler. Gartner & IDC 2026 Leader in Hybrid Mesh Firewall and SASE; US$1.6bn SASE ARR (+~40% y/y, FQ3 FY26).
Cortex SOC & Cloud
(US$1,920m · 16.7%)
CrowdStrike (Falcon Flex), Microsoft (Defender/Sentinel), SentinelOne, Splunk. Mean time to detect/respond, telemetry ingestion cost, endpoint footprint. Top-three challenger. XSIAM reached US$700m ARR (+70% y/y) and 1,000 accounts in FQ4 FY26, but faces fierce CrowdStrike Flex & Microsoft E5 bundling.
Idira Identity
(US$614m · US$1,260m pro forma)
Okta, Microsoft Entra, SailPoint, HashiCorp, BeyondTrust. Privileged credential vaulting, secrets management for machine & AI identities. Category leader in privileged access. CyberArk annual contract value (ACV) grew 27% y/y in FQ4 FY26 with immediate cross-sell into US$50m+ deals.
Applied Compute
(US$0m · US$4.5bn deal)
Hyperscaler AI studios, Databricks, Together AI, open-weight internal tooling. Secure post-training and low-latency inference on proprietary enterprise data. Unproven entrant. Pending FQ3 FY27 close; needs ~US$2,400m of modelled FY27E–FY30E capex outside PANW's historic software core.

Source: FY26 Form 10-K competition disclosures; FQ4 FY26 presentation; FQ1 FY27 Form 8-K; Penmark Research assessment.

Evidence the switching-cost moat lasts, and its cost

Platformised accounts retain 120% of spend, yet buying that breadth depresses GAAP profitability. Ripping out firewall rules, XSIAM telemetry pipelines and CyberArk vaults together carries high operational risk, supporting durable retention. Free transition periods, CrowdStrike Flex rivalry and 15.6% LTM stock-based pay leave PANW at a 3.9% LTM GAAP operating margin against Fortinet’s 33.0%, a gap of about 29pp.

Exhibit 39: Fortinet earns a 33% trailing GAAP operating margin against 4% at PANW
FortinetPANWLTM FCF margin43.5%34.3%LTM non-GAAP op.margin36.9%29.5%LTM GAAP op. margin33.0%3.9%LTM SBC % ofrevenue3.9%15.6%

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model (Peers & Historicals tabs)

LTM to Sep 2026 for Fortinet and to Oct 2026 for PANW; Fortinet non-GAAP equals GAAP plus 3.9% SBC.

PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 8 MANAGEMENT, GOVERNANCE AND CAPITAL ALLOCATION

Equity awards supply 94% of FY26 executive pay, while acquisitions absorbed 40% of five-year operating cash

Exhibit 40: 94% of FY26 pay is stock tied to ARR, sales and TSR rather than GAAP EPS
Executive Tenure & background How they are paid (FY26 reported) What they own (at US$339.92)
Nikesh AroraChair & Chief Executive Officer 8.4 yrs in roleChair & CEO since Jun 2018; 8.4 yrs at PANW. Prior: President & COO, SoftBank. US$80.27m total, FY26
Salary US$1.00m; other US$2.33m; bonus US$1.00m; stock US$75.94m, or 94.6%. PSUs track NGS ARR, organic sales, margin & TSR.
US$733.8m · 0.26%2.16m shares, or 734x base. Variable forward on up to 500k shares, 12 Oct 2026.
Dipak GolechhaEVP & Chief Financial Officer 5.7 yrs in roleCFO since Mar 2021; met 5-yr hold rule Mar 2026. Prior: CFO, Nature's Bounty & Chobani; P&G. US$21.82m total, FY26
Salary & other US$0.60m; bonus US$0.60m; stock US$20.62m, or 94.5%. Bonus tracks organic sales & margin.
US$139.2m · 0.05%0.41m shares, or 232x US$0.60m base. Met 1x hold rule; no FY26 open-market buys.
William “BJ” JenkinsPresident 5.3 yrs in rolePresident since Aug 2021; 5.3 yrs at PANW. Prior: CEO, Barracuda Networks; EMC. US$22.13m total, FY26
Salary & other US$0.76m; bonus US$0.75m; stock US$20.62m, or 93.2%. Same corporate PSU & cash metrics.
US$140.2m · 0.05%0.41m shares, or 187x US$0.75m base. Sold 56,214 shares for US$19.92m, 2–4 Nov 2026, via 10b5-1.
Lee KlarichEVP, Chief Product & Tech Officer; Director 1.3 yrs in roleCPTO & Director since Aug 2025; 20.5 yrs at PANW since 2006. US$13.83m total, FY26
Salary & other US$0.66m; bonus US$0.55m; stock US$12.63m, or 91.3%. Leads all three product pillars.
US$365.1m · 0.13%1.07m shares, or 664x US$0.55m base. Met hold guideline May 2011.
Nir ZukFounder Emeritus, Former CTO Co-founder, 2005Left CTO & executive role 14 Aug 2025 after 20 yrs at PANW. US$6.44m total, FY26
Salary & other US$0.32m; bonus US$0; prior PSU value US$6.11m, no FY25 or FY26 grant.
US$677.2m · 0.24%1.99m shares; base US$0 post-Aug 2025. Non-executive before 18 Sep 2026 record date.
Salary & other benefitsAnnual cash incentiveEquity awards (ASC 718 grant-date value)

Source: 2026 Proxy Statement DEF 14A filed 27 Oct 2026 and Form 4 filings to 18 Nov 2026. Ownership at 18 Sep 2026 on 818.44m shares, valued at US$339.92 including options/units vesting in 60 days, excluding unvested PSUs. Current officers and directors ex Mr. Zuk hold 4.49m shares, or US$1,527.7m and 0.55%.

Does pay reward per-share value?

Pay rewards recurring scale and total shareholder return (TSR), not per-share dilution. Bonuses track organic sales and margin with a 10% responsibility modifier. Three-year performance stock units (PSUs) vest on NGS ARR and organic goals, with target TSR at the 55th percentile. Neither penalises FQ1 FY27’s 18% share-count rise or deal stock.

Governance, perks and insider hedging

Single-class voting is offset by a combined Chair-CEO, US$2.33m of perks and a 500,000-share collar. Average board tenure is eight years; Nikesh Arora chairs the board and Lee Klarich joined in August 2025. CEO perks included US$1.06m of security and US$0.93m of aircraft use. Mr. Arora collared up to 500,000 shares, or 23% of his stake, on 12 October 2026; Mr. Jenkins sold via 10b5-1.

Exhibit 41: Acquisitions consumed 40% of the US$16.3bn in operating cash generated over FY22A to FY26A
Operating cash flow, FY22-26US$16,289mAcquisitions, netUS$6,570mCash & note paydownUS$5,805mShare repurchasesUS$2,732mCapexUS$1,182m

Source: FY22-FY26 Forms 10-K; Penmark Research model (Historicals tab)

PART 2 · THE BUSINESS · 8 MANAGEMENT, GOVERNANCE AND CAPITAL ALLOCATION (CONTINUED)

Consistent quarterly beats contrast with 46% share-count expansion and a capital-heavy pivot into AI compute

Exhibit 42: Diluted shares climb 46% from FY22A to FY28E despite US$3.7bn of cumulative buybacks
Share repurchases (US$m)Weighted diluted shares (m) (right)US$0mUS$200mUS$400mUS$600mUS$800mUS$1,000m500m600m700m800m900mFY22AFY24AFY26AFY28EActualEstimates

Source: FY22-FY26 Forms 10-K; Penmark Research model

Exhibit 43: PANW beat the top end of revenue, ARR and EPS guidance in both FQ4 FY26 and FQ1 FY27
ActualGuidanceFQ4 FY26 revFQ4 FY26 ARRFQ1 FY27 revFQ1 FY27 ARRFQ1 FY27 EPS3,410m vs guide 3,345m–3,355m9,100m vs guide 8,900m–8,950m3,445m vs guide 3,300m–3,310m9,730m vs guide 9,540m–9,560m1.05 vs guide 0.96–0.98

Source: Company releases; Penmark Research model (Guidance tab)

Revenue and Next-Generation Security ARR in US$m; non-GAAP diluted EPS in US$.

Operational execution is not in dispute. Management sets conservative bars and beats them; we sit US$99m above raised FY27 standalone revenue guidance.
Exhibit 44: FY26 cash M&A, Applied Compute stock and modelled AI capex total US$11.1bn net of cash received
Capital use / deal Timing & terms Scale & funding Economic return vs 9.5% cost of equity
CyberArk, Idira Closed 11 Feb 2026 Cash & stock; drove US$4,663m FY26A net cash M&A and lifted equity US$19.7bn Sound fit, full price. Adds US$1,260m FY26A pro forma sales growing 20.6% in FY27E, plus US$1,774m of 2029 cash-settled notes.
Chronosphere Closed FY26; ann. Nov 2025 Within US$4,663m FY26A cash M&A and stock issue; standalone sales n.d. Unverified return. Stock fell 7.4% on announcement; folded into Cortex and NGS without separate disclosure.
Applied Compute Expected close FQ3 FY27 US$4,500m stock, ~13.2m est. shares at 18 Nov close (ref. price n.d.) + US$2,400m modelled FY27E–30E capex (<US$3bn guide); ~US$500m cash/compute in Near neutral at +US$0.91 a share vs 9.5% cost of equity. Losses in FY27E–29E on US$50m, US$300m and US$600m sales before 25% margin.
Share repurchases FY22A–26A: US$2,732m; US$500m/yr FY27E–28E US$1,000m in FY26A vs US$1,774m cash-flow SBC and US$1,712m operating SBC Dilutive above value. Buying near US$340, over twice our US$162 base DCF, erodes value without halting dilution.
Core organic capex FY22A–26A: US$1,182m 2.7%–3.8% of sales, or US$440m in FY26A High return at 32.4% FY26A non-GAAP ROCE. Cloud points of presence earned wide spreads, now diluted by AI capex.

Source: FY22–FY26 Forms 10-K; FQ1 FY27 Form 8-K Ex. 99.2; Penmark Research model. Gross outlay and modelled capex total US$11.6bn before ~US$0.5bn of Applied Compute cash and compute received; CyberArk stock sits in FY26A’s US$19.7bn equity rise.

Why serial M&A changes the equity story

PANW is shifting from asset-light software into capital-heavy AI compute. Core capex took 7.3% of FY22A–FY26A operating cash, while cash M&A took 40.3% alongside stock deals. Applied Compute issues US$4.5bn of stock while bringing ~US$0.5bn of cash and prepaid compute. Management guided under US$3.0bn of capex, and we expect it to need about US$2.4bn through FY30, in a business where PANW has no incumbent moat.

What it means for per-share value

Dilution and AI losses explain why beats do not justify US$340. Diluted shares rose from 591m in FY22A to 764m in FY26A and reach 865m in FY28E, up 46% despite US$3.7bn of buybacks. Applied Compute adds +US$0.91 a share on DCF, yet cuts FY27E EPS by US$0.12 to US$4.16 and posts a US$240m FY28E operating loss.

PART 3 · THE THESIS · 9 WHAT MOVES THE STOCK

Four drivers set the share price, and multiple expansion supplied 78% of the last year’s 69% gain

PANW trades on AI recurring momentum and sector multiple swings, not GAAP earnings. Across event days, return splits, 157-week regressions and 41 Q&A turns, four drivers pass at least two tests, and each prices more value than our DCF supports.

Exhibit 45: Four confirmed drivers explain PANW’s tape, and FQ1 FY27’s 7% jump added US$21.2bn
Confirmed driver What moves the stock Tests passed Market reaction vs our model value Linked debate Next number to watch
NGS ARR & platformisation Net-new NGS ARR and full-year ARR guide raises. 3 of 4 tests
Events, returns, Q&A: 34.1%
FQ1 FY27’s US$180m ARR beat lifted PANW 7.4% after hours to US$365.18, adding ~US$21.2bn on 838m shares after a 9.9% DHS/CISA rally. Repeat beat value: +US$5.26 a share. Post-patching growth FQ2 NGS ARR, Feb 2027: guide US$10.20–10.22bn; FY27E US$11.60bn.
AI threat & post-patching growth AI patching urgency, XSIAM/AIRS & FY28+ organic pace. 3 of 4 tests
Events, returns, Q&A: 39.0%
US$339.92 implies 28.3% FY28E core growth vs our 14.5% fade. That sits US$41.40 a share below a +4pt growth path, with a −US$6.86 bear fade risk. Post-patching growth Initial FY28 guide, Aug 2027: tests fade to 14.5% core growth.
M&A allocation & share dilution Large stock/cash deals, SBC % of sales & share count. 2 of 4 tests
Events, Q&A: 19.5%
CyberArk, Chronosphere and FQ4 FY26 drove 5%–9% drops on dilution fears. Charging SBC cuts DCF by US$22.06–46.36 a share, with a −US$10.89 bear risk. Stock compensation FQ3 Applied Compute close, May 2027: ~13.2m shares & capex ramp.
Sector multiple & discount rate CIBR ETF multiple swings & equity risk appetite. 3 of 4 tests
Events, returns, R²: 71.1%
Trailing P/E rose from 60.2x to 88.5x, pricing a 6.04% cost of equity vs our 9.50%. +100bp cuts base value US$21.35 a share; −100bp adds US$29.03. Discount rate 10Y yield & CIBR, Dec 2026 FOMC: 5.10% yield, 94bp spread.

Source: Company filings & releases; earnings-call transcripts; Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research model. Confirmed drivers pass at least two of four empirical tests.

Exhibit 46: M&A and dilution updates drove −5% to −9% drops before FQ1 FY27 rose 7% after hours
FQ1 FY27 (after hours)FQ4 FY25 resultsFQ1 FY25 resultsFQ2 FY25 resultsCyberArk dealFQ3 FY26 resultsFQ3 FY25 resultsFQ2 FY26 resultsFQ1 FY26 + ChronosphereFQ4 FY26 results+7.4%+3.1%+1.2%−0.9%−5.2%−5.6%−6.8%−6.8%−7.4%−9.3%

Source: Yahoo Finance next-session closes and 18 Nov 2026 after-hours print, FQ1 FY25 to FQ1 FY27

Exhibit 47: Multiple expansion supplied 54pp of PANW's 69% one-year return
Non-GAAP EPS growthP/E multiple expansion0%+100%+200%+300%1-Year3-Year5-Year+69%+161%+292%

Source: Yahoo Finance; company filings; Penmark Research decomposition to 18 Nov 2026 (1Y Nasdaq-100 +10.7%; dividends 0%)

Why headline EPS beats repeatedly failed to lift the stock before FQ1 FY27 after hours PANW fell between 0.9% and 9.3% on seven of ten results and deal days since FQ1 FY25, including six quarters that beat EPS guidance, as investors penalised deal dilution and slowing organic ARR. On 18 November, regular-session shares rose 9.9% before results on DHS and CISA cyber alerts, then gained 7.4% after hours on FQ1 FY27’s ARR beat. Over 12 months non-GAAP EPS grew 15%, while trailing P/E expanded from 60.2x to 88.5x.
PART 3 · THE THESIS · 9 WHAT MOVES THE STOCK (CONTINUED)

Sector factor moves explain 71% of weekly variance, while 93% of call Q&A targets AI, ARR and M&A

Exhibit 48: Market and cybersecurity sector moves explain 71% of weekly share-price variance
Cybersecurity ETF (incr.)Company-specific(idiosync.)S&P 500 market factor51.4%28.8%19.8%

Source: Yahoo Finance weekly returns, n = 157, 24 Nov 2023 to 18 Nov 2026; Penmark Research OLS

Weekly 10-year Treasury yield changes add less than 0.1% incremental R-squared.

Exhibit 49: AI demand, NGS ARR and M&A dilution drove 93% of analyst questions across five calls
AI threat & productdemandNGS ARR &platformisationM&A & dilutionMargins, FCF & guideHardware firewall cycle39.0%34.1%19.5%4.9%2.4%

Source: Company earnings-call transcripts across FQ2 FY25 to FQ4 FY26, n = 41 analyst turns

CONFIRMED DRIVERNGS ARR and AI demand drive 73% of call questions; the jump ran 5x our model value

What the market does

Bulls extrapolate AI beats. AI at 39% and NGS ARR at 34% lead Q&A. After 18 Nov’s 9.9% rally, FQ1 FY27’s US$180m ARR beat added 7.4%, or US$25.26, after hours.

What our model says

One beat adds US$5.26 a share, 79% below the jump. Core growth fades from 27.6% in FY27E to 14.5% in FY28E, half the 28.3% priced in.

Debate and next number

Links to Post-patching growth. Watch FQ2 FY27 NGS ARR in Feb 2027 vs the US$10.20bn–10.22bn guide, then FY28 guidance in Aug 2027.

CONFIRMED DRIVERM&A deals and share issuance trigger sell-offs whenever dilution overshadows ARR

What the market does

Dilution drew 20% of Q&A with hedged answers. CyberArk fell 5.2% and Chronosphere 7.4%; Applied Compute escaped on FQ1 FY27’s ARR beat.

What our model says

Charging SBC cuts value US$22.06–46.36 a share. Applied Compute issues ~13.2m shares and needs about US$2.4bn of capex on our estimate, cutting FY27E EPS US$0.12; SBC bear risk is US$10.89.

Debate and next number

Links to Stock compensation. Watch FQ3 FY27 Applied Compute close in May 2027 vs our 851m share base, plus FY27 SBC in Sep 2027.

CONFIRMED DRIVERPANW trades at a 1.5x beta to the cyber ETF, amplifying sector multiple compression

What the market does

Market and sector explain 71.1% of weekly variance. A 1.47x CIBR slope drove 54pp of PANW’s 69% 1Y gain and Nov’s 23% drop.

What our model says

US$339.92 prices a 6.04% cost of equity, 94bp over 10Y yields. +100bp cuts value US$21.35 a share; rate bear risk is US$17.54.

Debate and next number

Links to Discount rate. Watch the Dec 2026 FOMC and peer EV/LTM FCF, where the 34.4x median sits near half PANW’s 65.1x.

Candidates tested and dropped: failed to pass two of four tests

Weekly 10Y yield moves, 0 of 4: R² is 0.6% standalone and 0.0% incremental; rates act via regime shifts.
Hardware firewall cycle, 1 of 4: 2.4% of Q&A; hardware is ~10% of sales, with a US$3.45 bear pull-forward risk.
Quarterly margin beats, 1 of 4: 4.9% of Q&A; PANW fell 5%–9% on four FY26 beats when ARR or M&A lagged.
Methodology & limits: Covers 10 earnings/M&A dates from FQ1 FY25 to FQ1 FY27, 157 weekly returns to 18 Nov 2026, and 41 Q&A turns across five calls; joint events limit attribution.
PART 3 · THE THESIS · 10 THESIS CHAPTER ONE: ORGANIC GROWTH NORMALISATION
THE CLAIM · RESTS ON NGS ARR & AI POST-PATCHING GROWTH DRIVERSCore revenue growth fades from 28% in FY27E to about 15% in FY28E once CyberArk laps and patching cools

What the market believes

Bulls extrapolate FQ1 FY27’s deal-boosted 39% revenue and 66% ARR growth. Consensus expects 14.6% FY28E growth, yet US$339.92 implies 28.3% FY28E core growth at a 9.5% cost of equity.

Three independent sources of evidence

  • Pro forma math. Guided FY27 pro forma growth is 19.9%, adjusted for CyberArk while keeping Chronosphere. CyberArk booked US$614m in FY26A vs US$1,260m pro forma, so US$1,520m FY27E Idira sales is 20.6% organic, not 148%.
  • Management’s patching clock. Nikesh Arora cited a 7x vulnerability spike driving at least 18 months of patching, before AI defence turns into a standard feature within two years.
  • Peer checks. Guided 19.9% pro forma growth trails the 24.3% peer median, while CrowdStrike Falcon Flex above US$2.2bn ARR and Microsoft contest Cortex renewals.
Exhibit 50: Once the FY27E Idira lap passes, total revenue growth slows from 28% to 12% by FY31E
Network & AICortexIdiraApplied ComputeOtherTotal growth0pp+10pp+20pp+30ppFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31E+28%+16%+15%+13%+12%

Source: Penmark Research model (Revenue Build)

Exhibit 51: Consolidated FY28E EPS sits 3% below consensus, while core growth sits 14pp below what the price requires
US$m (except EPS & %) FY27E FY28E FY29E FY30E
Core revenue, Penmark14,64416,77419,00021,288
Core growth y/y27.6%14.5%13.3%12.0%
Consolidated revenue14,69417,07419,60022,188
Pre-raise consensus rev.14,16016,230n.d.n.d.
FY28E growth price needsn.a.28.3%n.a.n.a.
Non-GAAP EPS, PenmarkUS$4.16US$4.72US$5.95US$6.58
Pre-raise consensus EPSUS$4.18US$4.89n.d.n.d.
EPS gap vs consensus−0.4%−3.5%n.a.n.a.

Source: LSEG/CNBC & StockAnalysis pre-results consensus; Penmark Research model. Standalone FY27E revenue of US$14,644m sits 3.4% above consensus and 0.7% above the raised guidance midpoint.

What it is worth

Post-patching fade is our largest operational debate, worth US$41.40 a share vs +4pt growth. Adding 2pts to FY28E–31E growth lifts base value from US$161.72 to US$181.41, and +4pts reaches US$203.11; adding a 41% margin reaches US$214.76. Bear air-pocket and 15% hardware risks cost US$6.86 and US$3.45.

Dated signposts

  • Feb 2027, FQ2 FY27: NGS ARR vs US$10.20bn–10.22bn guide, up 61% with deals.
  • May 2027, FQ3 FY27: First clean organic quarter past CyberArk’s 11 Feb 2026 close.
  • Aug 2027, FY28 guide: Tests whether FY28 core growth cools toward 14.5%.
Why beating raised FY27 guidance does not rescue the valuation We model US$14,644m of standalone FY27E sales, above the raised guide, and match the US$4.28 standalone EPS midpoint. Growth slows in FY28E as CyberArk’s lap removes 6.8pp of pro forma tailwind, or 7.7pp on the guide basis, while Applied Compute’s loss and shares leave consolidated FY28E EPS 3.5% below consensus.
PART 3 · THE THESIS · 10 THESIS CHAPTER ONE (CONTINUED)

FY30E recurring revenue lands US$0.9bn shy of US$20bn on our US$2.4bn AI capex forecast

Exhibit 52: Next-Generation Security ARR reaches US$19.1bn in FY30E, 5% shy of management's target
US$0bnUS$5bnUS$10bnUS$15bnUS$20bnFY25AFY26AFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EActualEstimatesUS$5.6bnUS$9.1bnUS$11.6bnUS$13.9bnUS$16.4bnUS$19.1bnCompany FY30 target, US$20.0bn

Source: FQ4 FY26 presentation; Penmark Research model

Exhibit 53: Applied Compute needs US$2.4bn of data-centre capex through FY30E to reach US$0.9bn of revenue
Data-centre capex (US$m)Applied Compute revenue (US$m) (right)US$0mUS$200mUS$400mUS$600mUS$800mUS$0mUS$200mUS$400mUS$600mUS$800mUS$1,000mFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30E

Source: FQ1 FY27 Form 8-K Ex. 99.2; Penmark Research model

US$19.06bnFY30E NGS ARR (−4.7% vs US$20bn target)
65% / 120%NGS ARR from bundles / bundle NRR
US$4.5bn + US$2.4bnApplied Compute stock + est. 4-yr capex
−US$240mFY28E Applied Compute EBIT

Law of large numbers on the US$20bn ARR target

Reaching US$20.0bn of NGS ARR from US$9.10bn by FY30 needs US$2.7bn net-new each year. Bundles supply 65% of NGS ARR at 120% net retention across ~2,280 accounts at FQ3 FY26, with 78 above US$10m. We top raised FY27 guidance at US$11.60bn, up 27.5%, before growth slows to 20%, 18% and 16% in FY28E–30E, landing US$942m short at US$19.06bn.

Agentic SASE metering is incremental. Agentic traffic rose ~9x over the past year, with metering due in six to nine months, yet +1pt in FY28E Network and AI growth adds US$98m of sales and US$1.52 a share.

Applied Compute trades software margins for GPU capex

PANW has agreed to acquire Applied Compute for US$4.5bn in stock, issuing about 13.2m shares on our estimate at the 18 Nov close, since the reference price is not disclosed. Closing in FQ3 FY27, the deal brings ~US$500m of cash and prepaid compute; Applied Compute passed US$100m of annualised revenue within 18 months of founding, the company says.

Upfront capex and losses weigh on cash flow. Management set a US$1.0bn FY29 ARR ambition and a US$3.0bn capex ceiling; we model sales rising from US$50m in FY27E to US$900m in FY30E on US$2,400m of capex, with losses through FY29E (+US$240m FY29E sales adds US$2.47 a share).

What would prove us wrong on organic growth and Applied Compute We would lift this pillar if August 2027 FY28 guidance points to organic core growth above 22% and Applied Compute passes US$500m of ARR by mid-FY28 inside US$1.5bn of capex. Even our full bull case reaches US$253.08 a share, 25.5% below US$339.92.
PART 3 · THE THESIS · 11 THESIS CHAPTER TWO: ECONOMIC CASH CONVERSION & DILUTION
THE CLAIM · RESTS ON M&A ALLOCATION & SHARE DILUTION DRIVERCharging SBC cuts FY27E free cash flow to US$2.5bn, under half the US$5.5bn headline

What the market believes

The Street values PANW on adjusted FCF without charging stock pay. Guidance is 38.0% FY27 adjusted FCF margin, or ~US$5.58bn; we model 37.2%, or US$5.47bn. Both and our US$2.52bn unlevered FCF after SBC include US$1,848m of deferred-revenue inflows and Applied Compute’s loss. The US$2.95bn gap deducts US$2,278m of SBC, US$253m of interest/tax, US$220m of acquisition-related costs and US$200m of Applied Compute data-centre capex.

Three independent sources of evidence

  • Audited cash split. FY26A GAAP net income was US$307m after US$1,712m of operating SBC, while FCF hit US$4,113m via US$1,774m of cash-flow SBC (15.5% of sales), US$855m of depreciation and amortisation, and US$1,617m of deferred revenue/working capital. Deferred revenue eases from 129% in FY26A to 113% in FY27E and 108% by FY32E.
  • FQ1 FY27 dilution. FQ1 FY27 SBC reached US$622m, or 18.1% of sales, as diluted shares rose 18% to 838m; we model 844.6m standalone FY27E shares and 851.2m with 13.24m Applied Compute shares.
  • Fortinet proof. Fortinet posted a 43.5% LTM FCF margin on 3.9% SBC, earning a 33.0% LTM GAAP margin vs PANW’s 3.9% on 15.6% LTM SBC, a ~29pp gap.
Exhibit 54: Unlevered FCF after SBC is US$2.5bn in FY27E, under half of US$5.5bn adjusted FCF
Adjusted FCF (company)FCF ex deferred-rev. changeUnlevered FCF after SBCUS$2.5bnUS$5.0bnUS$7.5bnUS$10.0bnUS$12.5bnUS$15.0bnFY27EFY29EFY31EFY33EFY35EUS$12.8bnUS$9.4bnUS$8.6bn

Source: Penmark Research model (Financials & Valuation tabs)

Exhibit 55: Charging stock compensation cuts fair value by US$22 to US$46 a share
SBC excluded (Street)Def. rev. held at 113%Base: SBC via dilutionSBC as cash expenseDef. rev. as customer debtUS$184US$164US$162US$137US$86

Source: Penmark Research model (Valuation & Market Check tabs)

Why our dilution method lifts value only because price exceeds value Our US$161.72 base DCF converts US$39,289m of PV of future SBC into 116.1m shares at US$338.40, taking diluted shares to 967.3m. That sits US$24.31 above our US$137.41 SBC-as-cash case solely because overpriced grants shift dilution onto new buyers.

What it is worth

Employee equity cuts base value by US$22.06–46.36 a share, yet zero SBC still leaves 45.9% downside. Dropping SBC lifts base value to US$183.77 and our target to US$216.27, still a Sell. Holding deferred revenue at 113% adds US$1.85 to US$163.57, while treating prepayments as debt cuts base value to US$86.37. If FY28E SBC runs 2pts higher near 17%, bear dilution costs US$10.89 a share.

Dated signposts

  • May 2027, FQ3 FY27: Final Applied Compute share count vs 13.24m modelled, plus any bolt-on deals such as reported US$0.5bn Clutch talks.
  • Sep 2027, FY27 10-K: Full-year SBC vs FY26A’s 14.9% operating rate and deferred revenue vs 113%.
PART 3 · THE THESIS · 12 THESIS CHAPTER THREE: PRICE-IMPLIED DISCOUNT RATE & MULTIPLE RISK
THE CLAIM · RESTS ON SECTOR MULTIPLE & DISCOUNT RATE DRIVERAt US$340, PANW prices a 6% cost of equity, less than 1pt above 10-year Treasuries

What the market believes

With 44 Buys, zero Sells and a US$398.63 mean target, the Street prices PANW as rate-immune. At US$339.92, PANW trades at 65.1x EV/LTM FCF and 72.0x FY28E EPS, an 89% FCF multiple premium over peers growing 4.4pp faster.

Three independent sources of evidence

  • Reverse-DCF check. US$339.92 needs a 6.04% cost of equity, 94bp above 5.10% 10-year yields, or 7.96% terminal growth, or 28.3% FY28E core growth.
  • Generosity walk. Zero SBC, 9.0% cost of equity, 4.0% terminal growth, faster growth, a 41% margin and flat deferred revenue reach US$263.58, still US$76.34 short.
  • Drawdown history. At a 1.47x CIBR beta, PANW fell 29.5% to 24 Feb 2026 and 23.0% from 27 Oct to US$309.29 on 17 Nov, including −9.6% on 5 Nov after Fortinet’s slowdown.
Exhibit 56: Justifying US$340 requires a 6% cost of equity or 28% FY28E core growth
Penmark baseImplied at US$339.92FY28E core rev. growthCost of equityTerminal growthEquity risk premium14.5%28.3%6.0%9.5%3.5%8.0%1.5%4.8%

Source: Penmark Research model (Market Check reverse DCF)

Zero of eight robustness tests change our Sell call We test eight alternative setups: a 1pt lower or higher discount rate, five-year beta of 0.97, peer-median beta of 1.14, our base case alone, excluding SBC, expensing SBC as cash, and treating deferred revenue as customer debt. Twelve-month targets span US$101.64 to US$222.42 across those eight tests, and zero of eight alter our Sell rating.
Exhibit 57: PANW fell 30% from its rolling closing peak in Feb 2026 and sits 19% below peak
Drawdown vs rolling daily closing peak−30%−20%−10%0%Jan-26Apr-26Jul-26Oct-26−19%Worst −30%, Feb 2026

Source: Yahoo Finance daily closes, 18 Nov 2025 to 18 Nov 2026

Series shows daily drawdown vs rolling closing peak; only the 18 Nov point (−19%) is measured against 6 Oct's US$419.91 high.

What it is worth

+100bp cuts base value US$21.35 to US$140.37 a share; −100bp adds US$29.03. Peer-median 34.4x EV/LTM FCF plus net cash yields US$183.95, 45.9% below US$339.92. A 10% rate-led peer multiple drop is our largest bear hit at US$17.54 a share.

Dated signposts

  • Dec 2026 & Mar 2027, FOMC: Rate path vs 5.10% 10-year Treasury yield.
  • 1 Dec 2026, CrowdStrike FQ3 FY27: Tests whether 18 Nov’s 6%–12% sector jump holds.
  • Aug 2027, FY28 outlook: Mid-teens organic growth compresses PANW toward peers.
PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 13 TRACK RECORD AND QUALITY OF REPORTED NUMBERS

Four years of 20% compound sales growth rest on widening GAAP adjustments and deferred-revenue inflows

Exhibit 58: Non-GAAP operating income rose US$1.7bn over FY23A–FY26A, while the GAAP exclusion gap more than doubled to US$2.7bn
US$m unless stated (fiscal year to 31 July) FY22A FY23A FY24A FY25A FY26A FY27E
Growth, profitability and GAAP-to-non-GAAP bridge
Revenue5,5026,8938,0279,22111,48014,694
Revenue growth, y/y (%)n.d.25.3%16.5%14.9%24.5%28.0%
Gross profit (GAAP)3,7834,9835,9686,7708,077n.d.
GAAP gross margin (%)68.8%72.3%74.3%73.4%70.4%n.d.
Non-GAAP operating incomen.d.1,6602,1902,6523,3564,220
Non-GAAP operating margin (%)n.d.24.1%27.3%28.8%29.2%28.7%
Less: SBC-related charges (deck basis)n.d.(1,145)(1,162)(1,386)(1,712)(2,278)
Less: intangible amort., acquisition & other itemsn.d.(128)(344)(23)(949)(1,340)
GAAP operating income(189)3876841,243695602
GAAP operating margin (%)−3.4%5.6%8.5%13.5%6.1%4.1%
GAAP net income(267)4402,5781,134307827
Cash conversion, stock compensation and share count
Net cash from operating activities1,9852,7783,2583,7164,5535,645
Stock-based compensation (cash-flow statement)1,0111,0751,0751,2951,7742,278
Free cash flow (OCF less capex)1,7922,6313,1013,4704,1135,050
Free cash flow margin (%) / Adjusted FCF (US$m)32.6% / n.d.38.2% / 2,67138.6% / 3,12137.6% / 3,50735.8% / 4,41434.4% / 5,470
Weighted-average diluted shares (m, split-adjusted)591.0684.6708.0709.0764.0850.1

Source: Audited FY22–FY26 Forms 10-K; FQ4 FY26 earnings presentation (1 Sep 2026); Penmark Research model. Note: Non-SBC line combines intangible amortisation/deal costs (US$123m, US$132m, US$54m and US$933m in FY23A–FY26A) with other GAAP items (−US$5m, −US$212m, +US$31m and −US$16m); FY24A GAAP net income includes a US$1,590m tax valuation-allowance release.

Exhibit 59: The non-GAAP-to-GAAP operating profit gap widens from US$1.3bn in FY23A to US$3.6bn in FY27E
Non-GAAP op. incomeGAAP op. incomeUS$0mUS$1,000mUS$2,000mUS$3,000mUS$4,000mUS$5,000mFY23AFY24AFY25AFY26AFY27EFY28EActualEstimates

Source: FY23-FY26 Forms 10-K; FQ4 FY26 deck; Penmark Research model

Why GAAP net income fell 73% in FY26A while FCF rose 19% FY26A GAAP profit fell from US$1,134m to US$307m, or US$0.40 a share. CyberArk and Chronosphere added ~US$474m of amortisation to reach US$638m, plus US$295m of deal costs and US$159m of other expense; FCF added back US$1,774m of SBC, US$855m of depreciation/amortisation and US$1,617m of working-capital inflows.

Growth split: software mix vs M&A step-ups

Sales grew 20.2% a year in FY22A–26A, with M&A driving FY26A. Subscriptions hit US$9,200m, or 80.1%; product was US$2,280m (~10% hardware). Growth slowed from 25.3% in FY23A to 14.9% in FY25A before 24.5% in FY26A (17.8% ex US$614m of Idira post-11 Feb 2026; Chronosphere n.d.).

Accounting choices that flatter headline metrics

  • SBC add-back. US$1,712m of SBC drove 14.9pp of the 23.1pp FY26A gap (6.1% vs 29.2%), with 8.2pp from deal/amortisation items; FQ1 FY27 SBC hit US$622m, or 18.1%.
  • Commissions & financing. Deferred contract costs rose from US$1,005m to US$1,211m in FY26A alongside US$1,397m of financing receivables.
  • FCF add-backs. US$4,414m FY26A adjusted FCF adds US$301m above US$4,113m FCF and will exclude ~US$2.4bn of modelled Applied Compute capex.
  • Tax & note marks. FY24A’s US$2,578m profit held a US$1,590m tax release; US$1,930m of 2029 notes at 31 Oct 2026 swing GAAP earnings.
PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 14 FORECASTS

Standalone FY27E revenue beats raised guidance by about US$100m before core growth slows to about 15% in FY28E

Exhibit 60: Consolidated revenue more than doubles from US$11.5bn in FY26A to US$24.7bn by FY31E
Network & AICortexIdira identityOther & Applied ComputeUS$0mUS$5,000mUS$10,000mUS$15,000mUS$20,000mUS$25,000mFY26AFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31EActualEstimatesUS$11,480mUS$14,694mUS$17,074mUS$19,600mUS$22,188mUS$24,743m

Source: FQ4 FY26 earnings presentation (FY26A); Penmark Research model (Revenue Build, FY27E-FY31E)

Exhibit 61: Core platform revenue growth slows from 28% in FY27E to 11% in FY31E and 3.5% by FY41E
US$m unless stated FY26A FY27E FY28E FY29E FY30E FY31E
Network & AI Security8,3549,81610,99412,20313,42414,632
Growth, y/y (%)17.2%17.5%12.0%11.0%10.0%9.0%
Cortex (XSIAM, XDR, Cloud & Chronosphere)1,9202,6693,3094,0044,7255,481
Growth, y/y (%)24.8%39.0%24.0%21.0%18.0%16.0%
Idira, identity security (FY26A pro forma: US$1,260m)6141,5201,7942,0812,3932,704
Organic / pro forma growth, y/y (%)21.2%20.6%18.0%16.0%15.0%13.0%
Other (Unit 42, services & financing)592639678712747777
Core platform revenue11,48014,64416,77419,00021,28823,593
Core platform growth, y/y (%)24.5%27.6%14.5%13.3%12.0%10.8%
Applied Compute (open-weight AI models)n.a.503006009001,150
Total consolidated revenue11,48014,69417,07419,60022,18824,743
Total consolidated growth, y/y (%)24.5%28.0%16.2%14.8%13.2%11.5%
Memo: Next-Generation Security ARR (year-end)9,10011,60313,92316,42919,058n.d.
NGS ARR growth, y/y (%)63.1%27.5%20.0%18.0%16.0%n.d.

Source: FQ4 FY26 earnings presentation (1 Sep 2026); Penmark Research model (Revenue Build). Core revenue fades linearly from 10.8% in FY31E to 3.5% in FY41E.

Exhibit 62: We model FY27E ahead of raised guidance, while Applied Compute puts FY28E EPS 3% below Street
Metric & period Guidance Consensus Penmark Reason for gap
FY27E standalone rev. (US$m)14,520–14,57014,16014,644+US$99m vs midpoint after +4.2% FQ1 beat; Street pre-raise
FY27E NGS ARR (US$m)11,475–11,525n.d.11,603+US$103m vs midpoint; FQ1 US$9.73bn beat by US$180m
FY27E non-GAAP EPS (US$)4.26–4.30 SA4.184.28 SA / 4.16Matches midpoint; US$100m AI loss & +5.6m shares cut US$0.12
FY27E adj. FCF margin (%)38.0%n.d.37.2%Within 100bp; FCF before add-backs is 34.4%, or US$5,050m
FY28E consol. rev. (US$m)n.d.16,23017,074+5.2% vs Street: US$16,774m core (+14.5%) + US$300m AI
FY28E non-GAAP EPS (US$)n.d.4.894.72−3.5% vs Street: US$5.01 SA less US$240m loss & 13.2m shares
FY30E ARR / FY29E AI (US$m)20,000 / 1,000n.d.19,058 / 6004.7% shy of FY30 ARR goal; prudent Applied Compute ramp

Source: FQ1 FY27 Form 8-K Ex. 99.1 (18 Nov 2026); LSEG/CNBC & StockAnalysis consensus (18 Nov 2026 pre-raise); Penmark Research model. SA = standalone ex Applied Compute.

PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 14 FORECASTS (CONTINUED)

Even 4pts faster annual growth with a 41% long-run margin caps base value at US$215 a share

Exhibit 63: Cortex, Idira and Applied Compute rise from 22% of revenue in FY26A to 38% by FY31E
0%20%40%60%80%100%FY26AFY27EFY28EFY29EFY30EFY31EActualEstimatesNetwork & AICortexIdiraApplied ComputeOther

Source: Penmark Research model (Revenue Build)

Exhibit 64: Adding 4pts of annual growth and a 41% margin lifts base value only to US$215 a share
120.9135.9152.6171.1191.5124.4139.9157.2176.3197.3127.9143.9161.7181.4203.1131.4147.9166.3186.6208.9134.9151.9170.8191.7214.8FY28E to FY31E growth delta−4pts−2pts0pts+2pts+4ptsLong-term margin delta−3.0pts−1.5pts0.0pts+1.5pts+3.0pts

Source: Penmark Research model (Sensitivities tab)

Values in US$ per share.

Sensitivity to confirmed operating drivers Each 2pt increase in annual FY28E–FY31E platform growth adds US$15.0 to US$23.0 a share across the grid. Each 1.5pt increase in long-term core margin adds US$3.5 to US$5.8 a share. Even the top-right cell at US$214.76 leaves 36.8% downside from US$339.92.
Exhibit 65: Applied Compute trims consolidated FY28E non-GAAP margin to 28% while unlevered FCF starts at US$2.5bn
Margins, cash conversion, capex & balance sheet (US$m) FY26A FY27E FY28E FY29E FY30E FY31E
Core non-GAAP operating income / margin (%)3,356 / 29.2%4,320 / 29.5%5,032 / 30.0%5,795 / 30.5%6,599 / 31.0%7,491 / 31.8%
Applied Compute operating income / margin (%)n.a.(100) / −200%(240) / −80%(60) / −10%90 / 10%230 / 20%
Consolidated non-GAAP EBIT / margin (%)3,356 / 29.2%4,220 / 28.7%4,792 / 28.1%5,735 / 29.3%6,689 / 30.1%7,721 / 31.2%
SBC-related charges / % of revenue1,712 / 14.9%2,278 / 15.5%2,561 / 15.0%2,842 / 14.5%3,106 / 14.0%3,217 / 13.0%
Change in deferred revenue (cash inflow)n.d.1,8482,5192,6322,6522,563
Capital expenditure: Core / Applied Compute(440) / n.a.(395) / (200)(453) / (700)(513) / (800)(575) / (700)(637) / (345)
Unlevered free cash flow after SBC / margin (%)n.a.2,519 / 17.1%2,844 / 16.7%3,546 / 18.1%4,355 / 19.6%5,209 / 21.1%
Year-end cash & investments (after note payoff & buybacks)7,90611,04116,2997,8408,8759,897

Source: Penmark Research model (Financials and Valuation tabs). FY26A standalone deferred-revenue cash change is n.d. (combined deferred revenue, working capital & non-cash items = +US$1,617m). Core margin reaches 38.0% and SBC reaches 7.0% from FY38E.

Platform mix shift and fixed-vs-variable cost leverage

Software platforms lift core margins to 38.0% long term, while Applied Compute trims FY27E–28E group margins. Variable cloud, support and appliance costs stay near 24% of core sales, letting R&D and sales scale core margins up 50–100bp a year. Applied Compute posts losses of US$100m in FY27E and US$240m in FY28E, inside guided 100bp and 200bp drags, before reaching 25% from FY32E.

Working capital, GPU capex and balance-sheet path

Deferred-revenue inflows peak in FY28E, while ~US$2.4bn of modelled AI capex absorbs cash. Deferred revenue eases from 113% of sales in FY27E to 108% from FY32E, pulling inflows from 12.6% of sales to 3.7% as growth slows to 3.5% by FY41E. We model US$2,400m of FY27E–30E Applied Compute capex, under the US$3.0bn ceiling. FY27E settles US$1,915m of notes and adds US$500m of deal cash/compute; excess-cash buybacks cut shares from 865.0m in FY28E to 836.8m in FY29E.

PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 15 VALUATION

Discounted cash flow values PANW at US$162 a share, 12% below our US$184 peer cash-flow cross-check

Exhibit 66: Every valuation method and sensitivity range sits well below the US$340 share price
DCF scenarios (bear-bull)12m target roll-forwardCost of equity 10.5% to8.5%SBC cash to excludedPeer EV/FCF (±10% band)US$100US$200US$300US$400US$108US$253US$118US$277US$140US$191US$137US$184US$166US$202Price US$340Target US$190

Source: Penmark Research model (Valuation, Scenarios & Thesis tabs)

Exhibit 67: Across our discount-rate and terminal-growth grid, base value spans US$133 to US$213 a share
175.3182.4190.8200.9213.3162.6168.3175.0183.0192.6151.6156.3161.7168.1175.6142.0145.8150.3155.4161.4133.5136.7140.4144.6149.4Terminal growth2.5%3.0%3.5%4.0%4.5%Cost of equity8.5%9.0%9.5%10.0%10.5%

Source: Penmark Research model (Scenarios tab)

Values in US$ per share.

Exhibit 68: Pre-SBC DCF diluted by 116m shares gives US$162, above US$137 cash-SBC and 12% below peer EV/FCF
15-yr DCF: SBC-as-cash test (US$m) Value Primary SBC-dilution bridge & peer check Value
DCF parameters & EV (31 Oct 2026)Primary DCF bridge: SBC as share dilution
Risk-free / Beta / Equity risk premium4.46%/1.05x/4.80%EV excluding SBC (31 Oct 2026, US$m)148,032
Cost of equity (no debt) / Terminal g9.50% / 3.50%Equity ex SBC (+US$7,705m pro forma cash)155,737
PV explicit FCF after SBC (FY27E–41E)52,721PV of future SBC / 31 Oct disc. price39,289 / US$338.40
PV terminal value (US$213,619m; 51.5% EV)56,023Future dilution (116.1m) + base (851.2m)967.3m
EV, SBC as cash expense (31 Oct 2026)108,744Primary base DCF (18 Nov; 31 Oct: US$161.00)US$161.72
Net cash & share bridge (18 Nov 2026)Peer EV/LTM FCF check & comparison
Cash (US$9,135m) + Applied Compute (US$500m)9,635Peer EV/LTM FCF × US$4,268m LTM FCF34.43x = 146,946
Less: convertible notes fair value (31 Oct)(1,930)Plus: net cash (US$7,205m) / 838.0m shares154,151 / 838.0m
Equity value (31 Oct), SBC as cash116,449Peer EV/LTM FCF cross-check (pre-SBC)US$183.95
Diluted shares (838.00m + 13.24m AI deal)851.24mDCF with SBC excluded (zero dilution)US$183.77
SBC-as-cash test (31 Oct: US$136.80; 18 Nov)US$137.41Gap (+13.7%) / 18 Nov share price+US$22.23 / US$339.92

Source: Penmark Research model (Valuation, Peers & Methodology tabs). Rolling 31 Oct to 18 Nov 2026 (0.049 yrs) compounds at 9.50% cost of equity.

Why 15-year DCF is primary and P/E or EV/sales fail

Three distortions make static multiples unreliable. Deferred-revenue inflows add US$1,848m, or 12.6% of FY27E sales, before falling to 3.7% by FY41E as growth cools. LTM SBC runs at 15.6% of sales vs 3.9% at Fortinet, distorting pre-SBC multiples while amortisation depresses GAAP profit. CyberArk, Chronosphere and Applied Compute reshape cash flow through FY31E, so our 15-year DCF fades core growth to 3.5% by FY41E.

SBC dilution vs cash downside test & cross-check gap

Our US$183.95 peer check tops US$161.72 base DCF by US$22.23 because EV/LTM FCF ignores SBC. Dropping SBC adds US$22.06 to US$183.77, leaving US$0.18 from working capital and growth fade. Base DCF keeps the SBC tax shield and converts US$39,289m of PV of future SBC into 116.1m shares at US$338.40 (18 Nov discounted to 31 Oct at 9.5%), beating our US$137.41 cash-SBC test only via overpriced grants. Cost of equity (9.50%) is required equity return; terminal growth (3.50%) is perpetual growth post-FY41E.

PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 15 VALUATION (CONTINUED)

Probability-weighted value of US$174 rolls forward to our US$190 12-month target, implying 44% downside

Exhibit 69: Rolling US$174 weighted value forward at 9.5% sets our US$190 target
050100150200Cash-SBCDilutionBaseDCFBullskewWeighted12m rollTarget137+24162+12174+17190

Source: Penmark Research model (Valuation & Scenarios tabs, US$/share)

Values in US$ per share.

Exhibit 70: Every scenario sits below US$340, with probability-weighted value at US$174 a share
US$0US$100US$200US$300US$400US$108US$162US$253Bear20%Base55%Bull25%Weighted US$174Price US$340

Source: Penmark Research model (Scenarios tab, value at 18 Nov 2026)

Exhibit 71: Scenario matrix, reverse-DCF implied inputs and multiples at US$340 versus our US$190 target price
Scenario / valuation metric Bear (20%) Base (55%) Bull (25%) Weighted / Target
Scenario assumptions tied to confirmed stock drivers
FY28E–FY31E platform growth delta vs base−4.0pp / yr14.5%→10.8%+6.0pp / yrScenario-weighted
Long-term core non-GAAP operating margin32.0% (−6pp)38.0%41.0% (+3pp)Scenario-weighted
Long-term SBC (% of revenue) / Deferred rev. ratio12.0% / 100%7.0% / 108%5.0% / 112%Scenario-weighted
Applied Compute scale factor (FY29E base = US$600m)0.5x (US$300m)1.0x (US$600m)2.0x (US$1,200m)Scenario-weighted
Present value per share (18 Nov 2026)US$107.91US$161.72US$253.08US$173.80
Return from US$339.92 to present value (%)−68.3%−52.4%−25.5%−48.9%
12-month rolled-forward value (×1.095, zero dividend)US$118.17US$177.08US$277.13US$190.31
12-month total return vs US$339.92 (sets Sell rating)−65.2%−47.9%−18.5%−44.0%
Multiples at actual share price (US$339.92) vs at our 12-month target (US$190.31) & reverse-DCF check
EV / LTM FCF (US$4,268m, pre-SBC)At US$339.92 price: 65.1x (US$277,648m EV)At US$190.31 target: 35.7x
Non-GAAP P/E: FY27E (US$4.16) / FY28E (US$4.72)At US$339.92 price: 81.7x / 72.0xAt US$190.31 target: 45.7x / 40.3x
Reverse DCF (one lever solved at US$339.92 vs base)Implied cost of equity: 6.04% (vs 9.50%)Implied g: 7.96% | FY28E core: 28.3%

Source: Penmark Research model (Summary, Scenarios, Market Check and Valuation tabs). Reconciles identically to the Page 1 call box (US$190.31 target, −44.0% total return, US$253.08 bull, US$107.91 bear).

Reverse DCF and robustness across eight model tests

Reverse DCF solves what single input US$339.92 needs: 6.04% cost of equity, 7.96% perpetual growth or 28.3% FY28E core growth. Zero of our eight tests alter our Sell call: a 1pt lower or higher discount rate, five-year beta of 0.97, peer-median beta of 1.14, our base case alone, excluding SBC, expensing SBC as cash, and treating deferred revenue as customer debt.

Limits of scenario probability weights & after-hours check Our 20% bear, 55% base and 25% bull weights are analytical judgements tilted toward FQ1 FY27 ARR momentum, not statistical frequencies. Even 100% on our US$253.08 bull case leaves 25.5% downside from US$339.92, or 18.5% on its US$277.13 12-month value; vs US$365.18 after hours, US$190.31 implies 47.9% downside.
PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 16 CATALYSTS

Initial FY28 guidance in August 2027 is the decisive catalyst testing post-patching growth fade

Exhibit 72: Dated 12–18 month catalyst calendar linking company events to expectations and per-share impact
Date Event Penmark expectation vs guide / consensus Driver & expected impact
8 Dec 20262026 Annual Meeting (virtual, 11am PST)Advisory say-on-pay vote on US$144.5m FY26 NEO pay (94% equity) and governance proposalsM&A & dilution: tests shareholder pushback on 15.6%–18.1% SBC load
Mid-Feb 2027 (est.)FQ2 FY27 results & FY27 guide checkNGS ARR beats US$10.20bn–US$10.22bn guide (+61% y/y); rev beats US$3.53bn–US$3.55bn; EPS beats US$1.01–US$1.03NGS ARR driver: +US$5.26/sh bull catalyst (60% prob.; upside to base value)
Spring 2027 (FQ3 FY27E)Applied Compute clearance & closeUS$4.5bn all-stock close (~13.2m est. shares at 18 Nov close; ref. price n.d.); ~US$500m cash/compute received; ~US$2.4bn est. capex startsM&A & dilution: prior deals sold off −5.2% to −7.4% on close/announce
Mid-May 2027 (est.)FQ3 FY27 results (post-CyberArk lap)First full organic comparison after 11 Feb 2026 CyberArk close; update on emergency AI patching spendPost-patching growth: +US$1.68/sh if emergency spend holds; −US$6.86/sh if fading
Mid-2027 (6–9m window)Prisma SASE agentic traffic meteringCommercial launch of usage-based SASE metering (~9x y/y agentic traffic); Penmark assumes modest adoptionNGS ARR driver: +US$1.52/sh bull upside (40% prob.) if surcharges stick
Aug 2027 (est.)FQ4 FY27 results & initial FY28 guidancePenmark models US$17,074m FY28E rev (14.5% core growth) & US$4.72 consolidated EPS vs US$4.89 StreetPrimary Sell catalyst: exposes gap vs 28.3% price-implied core growth
CY27 FOMC checkpointsUS 10-year yield & CIBR factor movesSpot 10Y at 5.10% (17 Nov 2026); persistent >4.5% yields pressure 65.1x EV/FCF multiple (1.47x CIBR beta)Multiple & discount rate: −US$17.54/sh bear risk (40% prob.) on rate stickiness

Source: 2026 DEF 14A; FQ1 FY27 Form 8-K Ex. 99.1 & Ex. 99.2; LSEG/CNBC & StockAnalysis consensus; Penmark Research model. Quarterly release dates beyond 8 Dec 2026 are expected windows based on reporting history.

Exhibit 73: Three major acquisition integrations overlap with the FY28 post-patching growth test
202620272028Idira (CyberArk) integrationApplied Compute regulatory & closeApplied Compute US$2.4bn capex rampSASE agentic metering rolloutInitial FY28 guidance test19 Nov 2026Tests 14.5% core growth

Source: FQ1 FY27 Form 8-K; FQ4 FY26 presentation; Penmark Research

Exhibit 74: Monitoring framework: operating and market signposts that confirm or break our Sell thesis
Confirmed stock driver Next number to watch Thesis confirmed if Thesis broken if
NGS ARR & platformisationFQ2 FY27 NGS ARR (Feb 2027; US$10.20bn–US$10.22bn guide) Organic ARR growth slows toward 20% in FY28E once CyberArk/Chronosphere lap Organic ARR compounds >26% through FY29E on agentic SASE monetisation & >122% NRR
Post-patching AI growthFQ3/FQ4 FY27 Network & AI rev. & initial FY28 guideCore platform growth steps down from 27.6% (FY27E) to ~14.5% in FY28EEmergency AI security budgets sustain >22% organic core revenue growth in FY28E–FY30E
M&A & share dilutionFQ2–FQ3 FY27 SBC % of rev., diluted shares & Applied Compute capexSBC stays 15%–18% of sales, shares hit ~865m in FY28E, or new stock M&A is signedSBC drops rapidly below 10% of revenue with zero additional equity-funded acquisitions
Multiple & discount rateUS 10Y yield (5.10%) & EV/LTM FCF (65.1x)EV/LTM FCF compresses toward peer median 34.4x–35.7x as growth normalises10Y yields fall below 3.5%, compressing equity discount rates toward ~6.0%

Source: Company filings; Penmark Research model (Scenarios & Sensitivities tabs).

What would change our view and move our Sell rating Under Penmark's rating rule, upgrading PANW from Sell to Hold at our US$190.31 target requires the share price to fall below about US$211. Fundamentally, lifting our weighted target above US$306 for a Hold requires organic core revenue growth above 22% across FY28E–FY30E, stock pay below 10% of sales, 10-year yields below 3.5% and accretive Applied Compute scaling together.
PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 17 RISKS

Upside risks add US$2–5 a share individually, while rate and dilution risks cut up to US$18

Exhibit 75: Quantified upside risks against our Sell rating alongside fundamental and multiple downside risks
Risk factor & direction relative to our Sell call Prob. Value / sh Mechanism & stock-driver link
Upside risks against our Sell rating (bull-case catalysts that lift fair value or sustain premium multiples)
FQ2 FY27 NGS ARR beat & second FY27 guide raise60%+US$5.26NGS ARR driver: extends beat-and-raise momentum past Feb 2027
Applied Compute scales toward US$1bn ARR by FY2935%+US$2.47M&A driver: open-weight AI adoption adds +US$240m of FY29E revenue above US$600m base
AI-enabled attack wave keeps emergency budgets open50%+US$1.68Post-patching growth: critical vulnerability wave (7x y/y) extends past CY27
Agentic SASE metering & FTNT / ZS share capture40%–45%+US$1.52 ea.NGS ARR driver: ~9x agentic SASE traffic converts into metered pricing
Combined Bull scenario (all upside levers simultaneously)25%+US$91.37Lifts PV from US$161.72 to US$253.08 (US$277.13 in 12m), still below US$339.92
Downside fundamental & valuation risks (reinforcing downside toward our US$107.91 bear case)
Higher-for-longer rates compress long-duration multiples40%−US$17.54Multiple & rate driver: 5.10% 10Y Treasury forces cost-of-equity repricing
SBC & share issuance stay elevated (+2pts FY28E SBC)55%−US$10.89M&A & dilution: FQ1 SBC hit 18.1% of sales (bear case holds 12% LT SBC vs 7% base)
Patching wave fades & AI defence becomes free feature40%−US$6.86Post-patching growth: frontier AI defence commoditises within ~2 years
Appliance pull-forward reverses / Cortex pricing pressure35% / 30%−US$3.45 / −US$2.10Hardware refresh (~10% of rev) cools; CRWD Flex & MSFT bundle SOC

Source: Penmark Research model (Thesis and Scenarios tabs; unweighted single-catalyst per-share impacts vs US$161.72 base value; probabilities illustrative).

Exhibit 76: Cost of equity, platform growth and stock-compensation treatment dominate per-share value sensitivity
FY28E-31E platform growthCost of equityStock-comp conventionLong-term core marginTerminal growth rateBase US$161.72−4pts US$127.90+4pts US$203.1110.5% US$140.378.5% US$190.75Cash cost US$137.41Excluded US$183.7735% US$152.6241% US$170.813.0% US$156.294.0% US$168.08

Source: Penmark Research model (Sensitivities, Scenarios & Market Check tabs)

What would break our Sell thesis on the upside

Crowded sentiment or sustained hyper-growth could keep shares elevated. Zero of 56 analysts rate PANW Sell, and short interest is 2.5% of basic shares. Quarterly ARR beats can hold a 60x–70x cash-flow multiple until FY28 slows, as in the 7.4% after-hours jump to US$365.18 on 18 November. Fundamentally, breaking our Sell call requires organic core growth above 22% across FY28E–FY30E, GAAP stock pay below 10% and 10-year yields below 3.5% together. At US$339.92, the stock prices 28.3% FY28E core growth or a 6.04% discount rate.

M&A, regulatory, legal and key-person risks

  • Three-way integration. Absorbing CyberArk at US$1.26bn pro forma sales, Chronosphere and US$4.5bn Applied Compute strains execution. Applied Compute still needs regulatory clearance.
  • Breach liability. A critical firewall, SASE or identity flaw would hurt customer trust. Filings do not quantify customer indemnities, so our equity bridge makes no deduction.
  • Key-person risk. Strategy and deal-making centre on Chair and CEO Nikesh Arora. His October 2026 variable forward covers up to 500,000 shares, or about 23% of his stake, cutting downside exposure through 2029.
PART 4 · THE NUMBERS · 18 OWNERSHIP AND TRADING

Zero Sell ratings across 56 analysts and 2.5% short interest leave crowded institutional positioning

Exhibit 77: Top institutional 13F holders (30 Sep 2026) and proxy insider ownership (18 Sep 2026)
Holder (13F institutional / DEF 14A beneficial) Shares (m) % basic Q/Q change (m) Value at US$339.92 (US$m)
Vanguard Group (DEF 14A beneficial: 60.79m / 7.4%)81.5410.0%+0.54 (+0.7%)27,718
BlackRock, Inc. (DEF 14A beneficial: 49.24m / 6.0%)78.199.6%+2.43 (+3.2%)26,577
State Street Corp.37.064.5%+0.08 (+0.2%)12,598
FMR LLC (Fidelity)31.873.9%+11.81 (+58.9%)10,832
Morgan Stanley27.733.4%−1.72 (−5.8%)9,426
Invesco Ltd.27.273.3%+1.62 (+6.3%)9,269
JPMorgan Chase & Co.25.433.1%+3.71 (+17.1%)8,644
Geode Capital Management / Bank of America20.26 / 16.812.5% / 2.1%+0.64 / −5.876,887 / 5,713
Total reported 13F institutional (3,037 filers)657.7080.4%n.d.223,565
Directors & executive officers as a group (DEF 14A, 18 Sep)4.490.55%Arora 2.16m (<1%)1,528

Source: SEC Form 13F filings, 30 Sep 2026 vs 30 Jun 2026; largest holders shown (818.0m basic shares reference); 2026 DEF 14A as of 18 Sep 2026 (818.44m shares; differs from consolidated 13F affiliates by voting/dispositive authority).

Exhibit 78: Short interest stands at 21m shares, or under 3% of basic shares
20m22m24m26m28mJun-26Jul-26Aug-26Sep-26Oct-2620.6m

Source: FINRA bi-weekly short-interest reports, to 30 Oct 2026

Exhibit 79: Zero of 56 covering analysts rate PANW Sell; 41 rate it Strong Buy
Strong Buy (41)Mod. Buy (3)Hold (12)41312

Source: Barchart via Yahoo Finance, 56 analysts as of 16 Nov 2026

Liquidity, indices, insider filings & supply

Three-month daily turnover of US$2.27bn pairs with steady share supply. PANW sits in the S&P 500, Nasdaq-100 and CIBR ETF with single-class stock and no controlling holder. Short interest fell from 47.75m shares in January 2026 to 20.62m on 30 October as CyberArk merger arbitrage unwound. That equals 3.5 days to cover. President BJ Jenkins sold 56,214 shares for US$19.92m on 2–4 November under a Rule 10b5-1 plan, ending with 1,200 shares on 4 November. CFO Dipak Golechha's 69,389-share filing was tax withholding. Closing Applied Compute in FQ3 FY27 adds about 13.2m shares on our estimate for US$4.5bn in stock.

Exhibit 80: Our US$190 target matches the Street low, 52% below the consensus mean
Base DCF US$162Penmark target US$190Street mean US$399Street low US$19018 Nov price US$340Street high US$525

Source: MarketScreener and Yahoo Finance (55 analysts, 18 Nov 2026); Penmark Research model

PART 5 · APPENDIX · 19 FINANCIAL MODEL

Linked annual income statement, cash-flow statement and balance sheet from FY24A to FY31E

Exhibit 81: GAAP operating margin rises from 6% in FY26A to 15% by FY31E (US$m, except EPS)
Fiscal year to 31 July FY24A FY25A FY26A FY27E FY28E FY29E FY30E FY31E
Revenue8,0279,22111,48014,69417,07419,60022,18824,743
Revenue growth, y/y (%)16.5%14.9%24.5%28.0%16.2%14.8%13.2%11.5%
Non-GAAP operating income2,1902,6523,3564,2204,7925,7356,6897,721
Non-GAAP operating margin (%)27.3%28.8%29.2%28.7%28.1%29.3%30.1%31.2%
Less: SBC-related charges(1,162)(1,386)(1,712)(2,278)(2,561)(2,842)(3,106)(3,217)
Less: intangible amort. & deal items(344)(23)(949)(1,340)(1,200)(1,059)(967)(874)
GAAP operating income6841,2436956021,0321,8342,6163,630
GAAP operating margin (%)8.5%13.5%6.1%4.1%6.0%9.4%11.8%14.7%
Interest, other & note marks304353(159)175442652314355
Income tax benefit / (expense)1,590(462)(229)49(511)(732)(804)(1,005)
GAAP net income2,5781,1343078279631,7542,1262,980
GAAP / Non-GAAP diluted EPS (US$/sh)3.64 / 2.841.60 / 3.340.40 / 3.840.97 / 4.161.11 / 4.722.10 / 5.952.56 / 6.583.62 / 7.65

Source: Audited FY24–FY26 Forms 10-K; FQ4 FY25 & FQ4 FY26 releases; Penmark Research model (Financials tab; continues to FY41E).

Exhibit 82: Cash-flow statement and unlevered FCF after stock pay from FY24A to FY31E (US$m)
Fiscal year to 31 July FY24A FY25A FY26A FY27E FY28E FY29E FY30E FY31E
GAAP net income2,5781,1343078279631,7542,1262,980
Plus: stock-based compensation1,0751,2951,7742,2782,5612,8423,1063,217
Plus: depreciation & intangible amort.2843438551,4381,5791,7011,7841,797
Deferred revenue, NWC & non-cash items(679)9441,6171,1031,8091,9191,9671,694
Net cash from operating activities3,2583,7164,5535,6456,9128,2168,9849,689
Capital expenditure (core + AI compute)(157)(246)(440)(595)(1,153)(1,313)(1,275)(982)
Free cash flow (company definition)3,1013,4704,1135,0505,7596,9037,7098,707
Buybacks, note payoff & cash M&A(1,177)(1,054)(5,663)(1,915)(500)(15,362)(6,674)(7,684)
Unlevered FCF after SBC (DCF)n.a.n.a.n.a.2,5192,8443,5464,3555,209

Source: Audited FY24–FY26 Forms 10-K; Penmark Research model. FY27E row nets US$500m buybacks, US$1,915m note payoff and +US$500m Applied Compute cash.

Exhibit 83: Balance sheet on model operating-liabilities-netted basis to FY31E (US$m)
Period end FY25A FY26A FQ1 FY27A FY27E FY28E FY29E FY30E FY31E
Cash, equivalents & total investments8,4597,9069,13511,04116,2997,8408,8759,897
Net working capital (ex-def. rev.)4,5215,0074,1075,4376,1476,8607,5448,413
Property & equipment, net3875236028001,4542,0662,4572,441
Goodwill, intangibles & other assets8,52332,84833,57036,18535,10534,10533,20532,405
Total assets (model operating-netted)21,89046,28447,41453,46359,00550,87152,08153,157
Net cash (31 Oct 2026: US$7,205m)8,4596,1327,20511,04116,2997,8408,8759,897

Source: FY26 10-K; FQ1 FY27 8-K (31 Oct 2026); Penmark Research model. Columns net non-deferred operating liabilities (US$1,686m, US$2,176m and US$1,696m in FY25A, FY26A and FQ1 FY27A); GAAP gross assets were US$23,576m, US$48,460m and US$49,110m.

PART 5 · APPENDIX · 19 FINANCIAL MODEL (CONTINUED)

Quarterly progression, platform KPIs and per-share ratios from FY25A to FY31E

Exhibit 84: Quarterly operating trajectory and FQ2 FY27 guidance (US$m, except EPS)
Quarter ended FQ4 FY25A FQ1 FY26A FQ2 FY26A FQ3 FY26A FQ4 FY26A FQ1 FY27A FQ2 FY27G
Revenue2,5362,4742,5943,0023,4103,4453,530–3,550
Revenue growth, y/y (%)n.d.n.d.14.9%31.1%34.5%39.2%36%–37%
Network & AI Security revenuen.d.1,9042,0252,0942,331n.d.n.d.
Cortex revenuen.d.422431481586n.d.n.d.
Idira identity revenuen.d.n.a.n.a.278336n.d.n.d.
Non-GAAP operating income7687467858141,0111,059n.d.
Non-GAAP operating margin (%)30.3%30.2%30.3%27.1%29.6%30.7%n.d.
GAAP operating income497309397(183)17296n.d.
SBC-related charges372387321517487622n.d.
Next-Generation Security ARR5,5805,8506,3308,1309,1009,73010,200–10,220
Remaining performance obligations (US$bn)15.815.516.018.421.221.021.5–21.6
Non-GAAP diluted EPS (US$/sh)n.d.n.d.n.d.0.851.021.051.01–1.03

Source: Quarterly Forms 8-K Ex. 99.1; FQ4 FY26 presentation; Penmark Research model (FQ2–FQ3 FY25 revenue US$2,257m and US$2,289m; FQ1 FY27A platform split n.d.).

Exhibit 85: Platform revenue, recurring software and customer KPIs from FY25A to FY31E
US$m unless stated FY25A FY26A FY27E FY28E FY29E FY30E FY31E
Network & AI Security revenue7,1318,3549,81610,99412,20313,42414,632
Cortex revenue1,5391,9202,6693,3094,0044,7255,481
Idira identity revenuen.a.6141,5201,7942,0812,3932,704
Other services / Applied Compute revenue551/n.a.592/n.a.639/50678/300712/600747/900777/1,150
Next-Generation Security ARR (year-end)5,5809,10011,60313,92316,42919,058n.d.
Platformised NRR / >US$10m customers (ex-M&A)n.d./52120%/78n.d.n.d.n.d.n.d.n.d.

Source: FQ4 FY26 presentation; company KPI disclosures; Penmark Research model (Idira FY25A–26A pro forma revenue: US$1,040m and US$1,260m).

Exhibit 86: Per-share metrics, returns and multiples at US$340 and our US$190 target
Per-share & ratio summary FY25A FY26A FY27E FY28E FY29E FY30E FY31E
Weighted-average diluted shares (m)709.0764.0850.1865.0836.8830.5823.5
Non-GAAP EPS (US$): Consol. / Standalone3.34/3.343.84/3.844.16/4.284.72/5.015.95/6.116.58/6.607.65/7.55
Consolidated non-GAAP EPS growth, y/y (%)17.6%15.0%8.4%13.4%26.1%10.5%16.3%
FCF per share: Reported / After SBC (US$/sh)4.89/n.a.5.38/n.a.5.94/2.966.66/3.298.25/4.249.28/5.2410.57/6.33
GAAP ROE (avg) / After-tax ROCE (avg. IC, %)17.5%/n.m.1.7%/25.3%2.7%/15.0%2.7%/17.1%5.4%/22.5%8.1%/29.7%12.1%/39.9%
Non-GAAP P/E at US$339.92 share price (x)101.8x88.5x81.7x72.0x57.1x51.7x44.4x
Non-GAAP P/E at our US$190.31 target price (x)57.0x49.6x45.7x40.3x32.0x28.9x24.9x
FCF yield at US$339.92: Pre-SBC / After SBC1.4%/n.a.1.6%/n.a.1.7%/0.9%2.0%/1.0%2.4%/1.2%2.7%/1.5%3.1%/1.9%

Source: Penmark Research model. After-tax ROCE = non-GAAP EBIT × (1 − cash tax: 22% FY26A, 20% FY27E–28E, 21% FY29E–31E) / avg invested capital (FY25A negative). Dividend yield 0.0%.

PART 5 · APPENDIX · 20 REFERENCE

Non-GAAP reconciliations, definitions, peer methodology and source notes

Exhibit 87: Reconciliation from GAAP operating income to non-GAAP and three FCF measures (US$m)
Line item FY25A FY26A FQ1 FY27A FY27E FY28E
GAAP operating income1,243695966021,032
Plus: stock-based compensation-related charges1,3861,7126222,2782,561
Plus: intangible amortisation, acquisition & other items239493411,3401,200
Non-GAAP operating income (company definition)2,6523,3561,0594,2204,792
Net cash from operating activities less total capex = Free cash flow3,4704,1131,8425,0505,759
Plus: M&A cash items & Applied Compute capex = Adjusted FCF3,5074,4141,9375,4706,578
NOPAT (after SBC) + D&A − capex + Δdef. rev. − ΔNWC = Unlevered FCF after SBCn.a.n.a.1,1652,5192,844

Source: FY26 Form 10-K; FQ4 FY26 presentation; FQ1 FY27 Form 8-K Ex. 99.1; Penmark Research model.

Exhibit 88: Peer universe selection, pricing dates and financial ratio definitions
Peer / measure Business model comparability / calculation definition Mkt cap / Source
CrowdStrike (CRWD)Cloud endpoint, SOC (LogScale) & Falcon Flex platform rivalUS$233,143m (24.3% g)
Fortinet (FTNT)ASIC firewall, SD-WAN & SASE rival; low-SBC profit benchmarkUS$91,540m (22.1% g)
Zscaler (ZS)Pure-play cloud Security Service Edge / SASE rival to Prisma SASEUS$31,126m (25.4% g)
Cloudflare (NET) / Okta (OKTA)Edge Zero Trust & AI inference (NET); cloud identity rival to Idira (OKTA)US$104,841m / US$31,866m
EV / LTM FCF & Non-GAAP P/E(Market cap − net cash) / pre-SBC LTM FCF; Price / non-GAAP EPSModel Peers & Summary
ROE, ROA & ROCEGAAP NI / avg equity or net assets; non-GAAP EBIT / avg IC (pre-tax Ex. 9; post-tax Ex. 86)Derived from model

Source: Penmark Research model (Peers tab). Peer closes 16 Nov 2026 (before 18 Nov +6% to +12% sector move); PANW 18 Nov close (US$339.92). Check Point (CHKP) statements unavailable.

Glossary of company & sector terms

NGS ARR: Annualised value of cloud and AI subscriptions across Prisma SASE, Cortex, AI Runtime, software firewalls, CyberArk and Chronosphere, at US$9.73bn in FQ1 FY27.

RPO: Contracted unearned plus unbilled revenue, at US$21.0bn in FQ1 FY27.

Platformisation & NRR: Bundling onto Network and AI, Cortex or Idira (~2,280 bundles in FQ3 FY26). Net retention of 120% tracks expansion net of churn.

SASE, XSIAM & Applied Compute: Cloud network security, AI security operations and PANW's pending US$4.5bn open-weight AI acquisition.

Methodology, limitations & data sources

Archetype & basis: Recurring-revenue software; US$ GAAP; fiscal year to 31 July. Model finalised 19 Nov 2026 on a 31 Oct 2026 balance sheet rolled to the 18 Nov 2026 close.

Departures & limits: Our 15-year DCF leads given deferred-revenue fade, stock-pay gaps and M&A. Base dilution uses discounted share price alongside our US$137.41 cash-SBC test; consensus predates 18 Nov. Peer closes are 16 Nov on mixed periods. Applied Compute reference price, indemnities, capped calls, headcount, segment EBIT, Chronosphere sales and end-user share beyond two distributors at 30% of FY26A sales are n.d.

Sources (18–19 Nov 2026): Forms 10-K (10 Sep 2026), DEF 14A (27 Oct 2026), 8-K (1 Sep & 18 Nov 2026), Form 4 & 13F; FINRA (30 Oct 2026); Yahoo Finance; LSEG/CNBC & StockAnalysis; Gartner & IDC.

PART 5 · APPENDIX · 21 DISCLOSURES

Analyst certification and important disclosures

Ratings

Ratings are based on the total return from the share price to our 12-month price target, including dividends. The price target is weighted across bull, base and bear scenarios.

BuyTotal return to price target above +10%
HoldTotal return to price target from −10% to +10%, inclusive
SellTotal return to price target below −10%

We review ratings at each set of results and whenever the facts change materially. A share price can move outside its band before the rating changes, and targets may not be reached.

Analyst certification

The Penmark Team certifies that (1) the views in this report accurately reflect its views about the subject company and its securities, and (2) no part of its compensation was, is or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific ratings, price targets or views in this report.

Contact

Penmark Research

Questions about our research:
research@penmarkresearch.com

All our research and coverage:
penmarkresearch.com

Basis of preparation

This report uses information publicly available up to its publication date. Share prices are closing prices on the trading day before the publication date, unless stated otherwise. Forecasts, valuations and price targets are Penmark Research’s own, and forecast periods are marked E. Sources are shown beneath each exhibit.

Valuation and price targets

Price targets are based on the valuation methods set out in each report and are weighted across bull, base and bear scenarios. The main risks to each rating and price target are described in the report. Penmark Research updates its coverage after each set of results but is not obliged to update a report at any other time.

Independence and conflicts of interest

Penmark Research is independent. It does not provide investment banking, brokerage, market-making or asset management services, does not trade securities, and does not accept payment from any company for research coverage. Companies do not see or review Penmark Research reports before publication.

No member of the Penmark Team holds a long or short position, directly or through derivatives, in the securities of any company Penmark Research covers.

Regulatory status

Penmark Research publishes general, impersonal investment research on a regular basis. It is not registered as an investment adviser with the US Securities and Exchange Commission or any state securities authority, is not a registered broker-dealer and is not a member of FINRA. Penmark Research does not give advice tailored to any person’s circumstances.

Not investment advice or an offer

This report is for information only. It is not personalised investment advice and is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or other financial instrument. It does not take into account any reader’s objectives, financial situation or needs. Readers should make their own investment decisions and seek independent professional advice where appropriate.

Forward-looking statements and risk

Forecasts, valuations and price targets are estimates based on assumptions that may prove wrong, and they may not be achieved. Opinions are current as of the publication date and may change without notice. Investing in equities involves risk, including the loss of capital. Share prices can be volatile, and past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.

Data and sources

Company financials, operating data and filings come from company filings, earnings releases and earnings calls. Market data and any consensus estimates come from third-party sources named beneath the relevant exhibit; consensus figures from aggregators are unofficial. Penmark Research does not use other brokers’ research. Third-party data belong to their providers and may not be extracted from this report.

Accuracy and liability

Information is taken from sources believed to be reliable, but Penmark Research makes no representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. To the fullest extent permitted by law, Penmark Research accepts no liability for any loss arising from use of this report. Descriptions of litigation and regulatory matters reflect allegations and public records, not findings, unless stated. If a published report is corrected, the corrected version carries an “Updated” date at penmarkresearch.com.

Distribution and access

Penmark Research reports are available to registered users of penmarkresearch.com. Downloads and programmatic access are governed by the Penmark Research subscription terms. This report is not directed at, or intended for, any person in Singapore or India, and access from those countries is blocked. It is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any person in any jurisdiction where that would be contrary to law or regulation or would subject Penmark Research to registration or licensing requirements there.

Copyright and permitted use

© Penmark Research. All rights reserved. Penmark Research is a trade name of Brightriver Labs. Readers may share a link to this report but may not copy, reproduce, redistribute, sell or use its content, including for text and data mining, without written consent. Contact: research@penmarkresearch.com.

Keep reading

Sign in to Penmark