Apple Inc. (NASDAQ: AAPL), initiation of coverage, Nov 21, 2026

Record sales cannot offset flat earnings at 37 times profit

Apple sells devices and services across 2.5 billion active devices, and made $478.8 billion of sales in FY26. Safe-haven buying has pushed the shares to 37 times next year’s earnings, while we see earnings barely growing in FY27.

Our rating
Sell
12-month target
$299.35
Price, Nov 19, 2026
$350.60
Expected return, with dividend
−14%

By Penmark Team

AAPLSellTarget $299.35−14% expectedFull report

What Apple is now

Hardware brings three quarters of sales, but services earn two fifths of profit

Apple designs the iPhone, Mac, iPad and wearables, then collects recurring fees for apps, storage, payments and search. It has 2.5 billion active devices and 1.5 billion paid subscriptions.

In FY26, products were 74.2% of $478.8 billion of sales, led by the iPhone at $254.1 billion. Services were 25.8% of sales but 40.2% of gross profit, at a 76.2% gross margin. Sales keep setting records.

Services earn more of the profit than of sales
Share of FY26 sales74.2%25.8%Share of FY26 gross profit59.8%40.2%
ProductsServices

FY26 ended in late September 2026. Products’ share of gross profit is what remains after the 40.2% services share. Source: Apple FY26 Form 10-K; Penmark Research.

Sales keep rising to new records
$416.2bnFY25$478.8bnFY26$516.2bnFY27$542.4bnFY28$566.0bnFY29
ReportedOur estimate

Net sales. The fiscal year ends in late September. Source: Apple Form 10-K filings; Penmark Research estimates.

How devices and services make money (page 7)

What you are really buying

The $351 price pays a 78% premium to similar platform companies

The shares trade at 37.3 times calendar-2027 earnings, against a 21.0 times median for Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon and Meta. That is 2.4 standard deviations above Apple’s own five-year average of 28.5 times.

To justify $350.60, a cash flow valuation needs 8.4% growth forever or a 5.7% discount rate, against our 9.8%. At our base multiple of 27.3 times, the shares would be worth $94.29 less.

Times calendar-2027 earnings, three views
Apple today37.3xOur base case27.3xPeer median21.0x

Forward P/E is the share price divided by calendar-2027 earnings per share. Platform peers are Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon and Meta. Source: Signals, Finviz (19 Nov 2026); Penmark Research.

What the 78% premium prices in (page 18)

Where we disagree: the multiple

Safe-haven buying, not earnings, drove most of the past year’s gain

The shares rose $83.16 in the 12 months to 19 November. Of that, $71.53 came from a higher multiple and only $11.63 from growth in forward earnings, as investors sold companies spending heavily on AI.

We think the premium narrows once peers show returns on that spending. Even if our base earnings hold, a move back to the 21 times peer median would cost $59.20 a share.

Where the 12-month gain of $83.16 came from
12-month price gain, per share$71.53 higher multiple

Price change from 18 Nov 2025 to 19 Nov 2026, split into the change in the forward P/E and the change in next-12-month earnings per share. Source: Signals, Yahoo Finance; Penmark Research.

Why 37 times earnings is too much (page 18)

Where we disagree: hardware margins

Memory costs cut hardware margins by about 3 points and stall earnings

Memory chip prices are rising fast, so we see the products gross margin falling 2.8 points to 36.5% in FY27. Research spending also rises 14%, so earnings per share only reach $9.09, up 1.3%.

Analysts’ $9.61 forecast implies a 48% group gross margin, above the 45% to 46% December-quarter guide. Each 1-point swing in the products margin is worth $6.06 a share.

Earnings per share stall in FY27, ours against analysts
$7.46FY25$8.98FY26$9.09$9.61FY27$10.02FY28
ReportedOur estimateAnalysts’ forecast

Diluted earnings per share. The fiscal year ends in late September. Analysts’ forecast is the Chartmill consensus (45 analysts, 14 Nov 2026). Source: Apple filings; Penmark Research estimates.

Why FY27 earnings stay almost flat (page 16)

Where we disagree: services growth

Services growth is slowing to high single digits, not the old teens

Services grew 13.0% in FY26 but only 9.8% in the fourth quarter, and Apple guided 8% to 9% for the December quarter. Before that guide, analysts expected 10.7%.

App Store link-out rules, a €500m European fine, weaker gaming and AI search all pressure fees. We model 8.5% growth in FY27, with no material paid Siri revenue. Each 1.5 points of growth is worth $3.04 a share.

Services growth slows from FY26’s 13% pace
13.0%FY269.8%Q4 FY268.5%10.7%Q1 FY278.5%FY27
ReportedOur estimateAnalysts’ view before the guide

Year-on-year services sales growth. Q1 FY27 is the December 2026 quarter; Apple guided 8%–9%. Analysts’ view is the Reuters pre-guide expectation (2 Nov 2026). Source: Apple filings; Penmark Research estimates.

Why services growth is slowing (page 17)

The odds

Even our middle case sits well below today’s $351 price

We weight a $188.31 bad case at 25%, a $280.81 middle case at 45% and a $419.68 good case at 30%. Only the good case clears today’s price.

The three weight to $273.22 today, which rolls forward to our $299.35 target: 14.6% below the $350.60 close, or 14.3% with the dividend. Our conviction is low, as one change in the discount rate would make it a Hold.

  • Good, 30%iPhone sales rise 13%, Mac 15% and services 10.5%, the products margin holds 38.5%, paid Siri tiers launch and the multiple keeps a 75% peer premium.
  • Middle, 45%Sales rise 7.8% on iPhone Duo and price rises, the products margin falls to 36.5%, earnings grow 1.3% and the premium fades to 30%.
  • Bad, 25%The products margin falls to 35.0%, services growth slows to 6.0%, iPhone grows 3.0% and the multiple falls to the 21.0 times peer median.
Where the price could be in 12 months
−$162.29 down+$69.08 upToday $350.60$188.31Bad case$280.81Middle case$419.68Good caseOur target $299.35

Circle size shows how likely we think each case is. The target weights all three and adds 12 months of expected return at a 9.88% cost of equity less a 0.32% dividend yield. Source: Penmark Research.

How we reach the $299 target (page 24)

What would change our mind

Only a lower discount rate would end the Sell on its own

A 1-point fall in the discount rate would lift our target to $344, and a 0.94 beta to $327, both a Hold. Business news alone narrows the downside without flipping the call.

Late January’s results and second-quarter margin guide are the first test of memory costs. June’s developer conference shows whether paid Siri tiers can restore faster services growth.

What bulls get right. Apple turns 102.9% of its profit into free cash flow while peers spend heavily on AI. Faster memory relief would add $12 a share, and an earlier iPhone Duo ramp $5.80.
Dates to watch
  1. The second-quarter margin guide tests memory costs. A guide above 47.5% would narrow the downside.

  2. Hyperscaler AI spending plans. Clearer returns could reverse the safe-haven buying of Apple.

  3. Memory buffers fade and iPhone Duo supply shows. We expect iPhone growth of 9.0%.

  4. Paid Siri pricing. A paid tier above $3bn of yearly sales would add $2.90 a share.

What would narrow or end the Sell (page 19)

Inside the full report

What each page covers after the summary on pages 1 and 2. Each opens the full report at that page.

See all 28 pages
  1. 3Margins dip 2pp in FY27E; our EPS sits 5% below consensus
  2. 4AAPL trades at a 78% P/E premium to platform peers and 2.4 SD above its 5-year mean
  3. 5Four charts frame the Sell: stalling margins, rich consensus and a 37x multiple
  4. 6Four debates decide whether Apple holds 37x or de-rates toward 27x
  5. 7A $5 trillion hardware maker where one quarter of sales generates 40% of gross profit
  6. 8Half a century of vertical integration created a $479bn hardware-to-services flywheel
  7. 9iPhone and Services supply 79% of sales; negative working capital funds growth
  8. 10Apple captures 49% of smartphone revenue on 20% of units while memory vendors take margin
  9. 11Vertical integration defends hardware pricing power, but AI cloud scale lags peers
  10. 12CEO John Ternus steps up with 75% performance-equity pay; insiders sold $126m since 1 October
  11. 13Apple returned $515bn over five years, but buybacks at 37x P/E are less accretive
  12. 14Multiple expansion, memory margins and iPhone demand drive Apple more than headline EPS
  13. 15Weekly variance tracks S&P 500 and US Tech; Q&A focuses on iPhone, AI spend and margins
  14. 16Memory inflation and AI spending stall FY27E earnings despite 8% revenue growth
  15. 17Services growth slows into single digits as regulation and AI search test fees
  16. 18A 78% peer multiple premium prices Apple for 8% perpetual growth with no cushion
  17. 19Why our Sell carries Low conviction: 103% cash conversion and a 100bp rate flip
  18. 20GAAP earnings quality is high, but Q4 FY26 margins benefited from a 1pp tariff refund
  19. 21Net sales reach $566bn by FY29E (+6% CAGR), anchored inside FQ1 guidance
  20. 22Our FY27E EPS sits 5% below consensus; cash flow still tops $149bn
  21. 23Primary 27x CY27E P/E yields $256; DCF cross-check sits 42% lower at $148
  22. 24Probability-weighted value of $273 rolls 12 months to our $299 target
  23. 25Late-January FQ2 margin guidance and June WWDC anchor the next 12 months
  24. 26Upside risks to our Sell total +$23/share operationally, led by memory relief (+$12)
  25. 2761% of Street analysts rate AAPL Buy; short interest rose 10% ahead of Q4 print
  26. 28Annual financial summary: FY24A–FY29E income statement, balance sheet and cash flow
  27. 29Quarterly progression confirms FQ1 margin step-down; ROIC remains above 235%
  28. 30Methodology note, accounting reconciliation, definitions and data sources

Penmark Research. This summary draws on our initiation report on Apple Inc., published Nov 21, 2026. It is not investment advice. Analyst certification, rating definitions and important disclosures are in the full report.

Sign in to Penmark